The IranianFly to Iran


email us

Flower delivery in Iran

Fly to Iran

Sehaty Foreign Exchange


May 19, 2000

If the Shah was in power

This is a reply to questions raised by Sahar Nahrvar's letter in her last letter:

"Yes it was better when the Shah was around."

In what way was it better? There was freedom on a superficial level only and nothing like what you expect from an even slightly democratic system.

"But still, one wonders, would the Shah not have closed down 16 opposition publications?"

Would he have closed them? The question should be, would such publications be allowed in the first place? Would they have received permission to press and criticise whoever they want? I think the answer is a resounding NO. The control over all media was suffocating and the prisons were full of those even slightly daring to criticise.

"Were the courts in that time any better than they are now?"

No. Remember Gole Sorkhi? There were many more without any independent press to report them.

"Would fewer student demonstrators have died if the Shah was the one giving the orders?"

Probably. We will never know how the current regime will react if there is a very serious threat to its existence. To Shah's credit, he left the country and one reason he did that was to avoid further bloodshed. Would the current lot do the same? Would the likes of Messbah and Rafsanjani give way to others. Very very doubtfull indeed. They'd rather take the country through a bloody civil war than concede and inch of power.

"Let's ask questions without any taarof. Let's find answers."

The best answer is already happening. Peaceful struggle for reform is our only hope. To that end we should all endeavour

Yashar Mameghan


 MIS Internet Services

Web Site Design by
Multimedia Internet Services, Inc

 GPG Internet server

Internet server by
Global Publishing Group.