The IranianUnique Travel

 

email us

US Transcom
US Transcom

Shahin & Sepehr

Sehaty Foreign Exchange

Advertise with The Iranian

    Letters

    Wednesday
    December 30, 1998

    The shah made mistakes. But who doesn't?

This is a response on the letter "Another Shahanshah? No thank you." I was only six-years old when the revolution took place. I left Iran nine years after witnessing a horrifying war and having both my parents jailed and tortured at Evin "university." Both my parents were "purged" and many other members of my family experienced the same ordeal. Let me tell you my mother was a midwife and in my family there were teachers, doctors and engineers. On top of that we were denied to get a passport and leave the country. In those days of war, blood and long lines for basic necessities of life, I was always reminded of the days when Iranian singers and dancers entertained people with our rich culture.

Let me save you from any prejudgment. I am not a monarchist. No member of my family enjoyed favor with the previous regime. We were as apolitical as one could be. We were Iranians who were not SHI'ITE Muslims. Since 1979, that has been a crime in Iran. I am not writing this to defend monarchy or the late Shah. I am here to remind my distinguished countryman that he is wrong to assume that everything was terrible in pre-1979 Iran and that everything was fine between 1979-80.

The Pahlavi regime committed many crimes. But which government doesn't. Compare the shah's regime to anywhere else in the area. Was the Pahlavi regime more corrupt and unjust than those in Iraq, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, or even Turkey and Egypt? Can anyone name any government in all of the Islamic world that was any better than the shah's regime. I think perhaps it was the best of all evils. The shah missed many opportunities to advance our country towards democracy and a true "Great Civilization" but don't democracies commit mistakes?

The shah ended feudalism in Iran, introduced modern education and women's liberation. Iranian art, culture and historical pride was rejuvenated in post-1925. Read history, in 1925, Iran was the MOST BACKWARD country in the Middle East. It lacked an educational system, a judicial system, a national army and central authority. Jews, Christians, Zoroastrians, Baha'is were forced to live in their own quarters and forbidden to engage with the rest of the population. There was no guarantee of life and property for them. The achievements of Cyrus, Darius, Ardeshir and many other great pre-Islamic Iranian thinkers and rulers had all been forgotten. Who revived the pride in being Iranian? Iranian people did but it was under Pahlavi leadership.

YES, there were countless injustices and mistakes. Let's, however, compare that 55 years to the first 12 months of the Islamic Republic. The courageous men of Iranian armed forces were shot by hundreds. Religious freedom for all disappeared. Singers, painters, musicians fled or were killed. Women were packed in mournful clothes. In Shiraz, Islamic militants destroyed archaeological remains of pre-Islamic Iran. They told our people that for 2,500 years EVERYTHING was bad, horrible, a waste. A nation had been a bad child for 26 centuries. They forgot to remind us that we were the cradle of first monotheistic faith, human rights, religious tolerance, the Suez canal, beautiful architecture in Isfahan, Shiraz and on and on. From and international destination we became a nation of overnight executions, and terrorism. Not only the name of Iran was degraded, the faith of Prophet Mohammad suffered a blow from which it will take it centuries to recover.

To blame the previous regime for current ills is understandable but not legitimate. If you didn't like certain things why not try to move towards progress instead of turning back the clock. Following a molla is going back 15 centuries. Those who responded to Khomeini's call made a mistake. Instead of being apologetic they talk of how "wonderful" things were for 12 months and then they were betrayed. And all this is the shah's fault that they were misled and out-smarted by a molla from Qom.

M. Jalili
hjalili@eden.rutgers.edu


Copyright © 1997 Abadan Publishing Co. All Rights Reserved. May not be duplicated or distributed in any form