The Iranian


email us



Sehaty Foreign Exchange


February 13, 2001

Compare now and then

I do not wish anything less than a liberal democracy for Iran. However, I do not like the opinions expressed in Fariba Amini's article ["Thy father's sins"]. I feel that saying that the revolution was hijacked by the clergy, as that article said, is incorrect. I feel that some Iranian's say these "romantic" words in order to not take responsibility for their own actions.

After all when the revolution was happening, people were shouting Khomaini's name. Three million people greeted him when he arrived to Iran. I even remember the slogan: "Yaa roosary, Yaa toosary". I remember men chanting this slogan while laughing. As if it was a joke.

"Thy father's sins" also lists a series of "errors" and mistakes by the monarchy as reasons why Iranians are facing the present Islamic Republic. But just go down that list. Compare any item on that list with what has happened during the Islamic Republic. It has all been hunderds of times worst during the rule of the mollas.

If political disitents were sent to exile or jailed during Shah, during the Islamic Republic they were simply "stabbed to death" (Forouhar's, Bakhtiar..). No sweat. The Shah sent Khomeini and others to exile, but didn't send someone to stab them. Khomeini on the other hand would order the execution of 80,000 people without bleenking, just because they disagreed with him, including 9 year old girls, 13 year old boys, gays, religious minorities, battered women...etc.

It's been 22 years of countless horrendous crimes, much worst than what went on during Shahs period. However those don't seem to have led to a revolution. Have they? The changes made during Shah's period did not go deep enough. Democratic institutions were not allowed to grow and mature. He also did not work hard enough to eliminate the clergy's influence on Iranian politics. He also did not work hard to promote literacy among poor iranians.

However, the Pahlavi monarchy made many non-cosmetic changes in Iran. Pahlavi's support for football in Iran, building of parks, respect for women and voting rights for them, openness to the international community, privatization of land. Just compare Iran of the 1970's with countries such as Saudi Arabia!.

In anycase, monarchy is a thing of the past. That should not be revisited. However, it shouldn't be blamed as the sole reason why Iran is now controlled by fascists.



 MIS Internet Services

Web Site Design by
Multimedia Internet Services, Inc

 GPG Internet server

Internet server by
Global Publishing Group.