Tuesday
August 14, 2001
* America is no paradise
As usual, Setareh Sabesti has written a beautiful article ["No
walls"]. However, the contents of this partiucular beautiful article
are a product of fantasies. As Moja Agha wrote in his letter ["If you're
rich"], you are free in America as long as you mind your own business
and do not endanger the power structure.
Sure, you are free to read what you want or dress as you wish, but it
is very naive to think that one has complete freedom. You are free to do
as you wish as long as your action does not affect established rules of
society designed by power struecture.
I am not suggesting that things in Iran are much better, but that does
not mean that America is a paradise. The U.S. government does allow the
foreigners to come here and make money and mind their own business, but
as an Iranian I am always aware that I am still viewed as a foreigner and
a guest in this counry, even though I might be a citizen or possess a Green
Card.
Mrs. Sabeti forgets that some 60 years ago, the wonderful U.S. government
put its Japanese citizens in California in concentration camps. The same
thing could easily happen to Iranians or any other minority group in this
country. Racism stills exists in a visible way. I have lived in this country
for 13 years and just last week some guy in the street called me an outsider
and asked me to get out of the town where I live.
Furthermore, those who control the power sturcture will never allow the
newcomers to really be in charge.They let them make money and live a quiet
life, but they will never give them power. And for the money they make,
most of the foreigners have to work extremely hard, sometimes two jobs.
Nobody in America would give anybody anything for free. Everybody is an
individual and is responsible for himself.
Also, Mrs. Sabeti talks about lack of phony pleasantries in America.
That might be true in Maryland, but in California there is sure a lot of
fakeness and phony pleasanteries. Again, I don't suggest there are no phony
pleasenteries in Iran, but that does not suggest that that kind of behavior
does not exist in America.
As far as the relationships with neighbors are concerned, at least if
there was a problem between two neighbors in Iran, they would try to discuss
it first. In the Great U.S. of A., the first thing a neighbor would do was
to call his lawyer and sue his neighbor.
Setareh Sabeti is a very capable writer, but she ignores a lot of things
in her essay.
Ali-Reza Kasra
* In fairyland
I have been an admirer of Setareh Sabeti's writings for sometime and
have made sure not to miss any of her stories in the past. Her insights
into issues that impact Iranians both here and at home are accurate and
precise most parts. However, this time she has lost my vote by having
gone a bit too far. She has stepped into a delusional land by writing "No
walls". So, I agree to disagree with in her assessment of her sweet
adopted country.
She wrote "Here in America you can live a whole life on a street
and not know the person who lives across from you"; she went on to
conclude "this indeed is a blessing if you give it a chance."
Well, I am at a loss as how to respond to her views on this subject.
Most of us grow up in Iran with our neighbors, who become part of our
immediate family. In fact, where I grew up in Tehran, people knew each other
in vicinity of a mile if not more. Majority of them would form a support
group and chip in to help if one needed help in a time of despair, or on
a jubilant occasion.
She also stated "Here we are all linked by one thing alone and that
is our mutual respect for law." Surly she can't be serious. Is it respect
for the law or fear of the law? Let's distinguish between these two closely
related but far different issues. Do you really think when you are driving
on a highway with no cars within sight at 55 MPH, you are respecting the
law or fearing the law? Do you really believe "respect for the law
is the most precious link that bond people in this country?" Well,
if your answer is yes; then, you must be living in a fairyland.
Perhaps you may care to elaborate this phenomenon for the readers. Why
the respect for law is only extended to the American people and not to any
other nations if they choose to claim their sovereignty? Why American people
who are so concerned about respecting each other's right, won't they question
their government when in it commits some of the most heinous crimes in the
world in the name of American people?
If you had commented on political freedom in this country, I would have
agreed with you. It is an undeniable fact that this is perhaps one of the
few countries that you can express your thoughts and voice your opinions
freely. But, I can't agree with your analysis on "No
walls". So, let's agree to disagree.
Abbas Saffari-Fard
* I drew it
I liked Siamack Baniameri's article ["Where
is it?"]. I thought it was funny... :o)
So I
drew this... hope you like it.
Jayron Zolfaghari
* Doesn't exist
I read the article by Siamack Baniameri entitled "Where
is it?". The author goes to great lengths (without any need) to
look for the so-called G-spot and makes a big deal out of it as if it is
the biggest question remaining to be answered about human sexulaity. All
he has to do is grab a first-year medicine anatomy book look up G-spot
in the index and he will quickly find out that such an organ (or body part)
does not exist.
The author claims he needs a machine or something that measures pleasure
(orgasm) while making love to his partner. He fails, however, to realize
that feelings of pleasure, joy, sadness can not be measured easily and
may even be impossible to measure.
I wonder if the author uses a machine every day to measure his happiness,
sadness or excitement. If the answer is no, why does he need an "Orgasmonometer"?
If he needs a machine to find out whether he is giving pleasure to a woman
then maybe having a measuring device is not the problem.
B. Peyvandi
* Women, children not property
Give me a break. Anyone who really believes that Betty Mahmoody, author
of "Not without my daughter", was at fault in her dire situation
is deluded ["Won't
last with a non-Iranian man"]. The woman traveled to Iran to please
her husband. She believed she was to be there for 2\two weeks. He tricked
her.
Women and children are not property. She was treated poorly by Mahmoody's
family, and she did what she knew had to be done. She got her daughter
out of there and back to a country where she could make her own choices.
If I was forced to remain in a country where I was not welcome nor given
any freedom, I might appear to be crazy as well. Any mother or father in
similar circumstances would be within their rights as human beings to do
the same thing she did. She put her daughter first.
Pamela Sue Starrett
* Reminded me of a film
Mr. Roozbeh Shirazi,
Your article ["Alhambra
is great"] reminded me of scenes straight out of a film by Egyptian
director Youssef Chahine, called "Destiny" in which he recalls
the story of Averoes, the writer and scientist which takes place partly
in Andalusia.
I recommend you to see this film about the free minded writer in an age
when Europe was living under religious inquisition, and Andalusia was torn
between political rivalry and religious intolerance.
The film is also a hommage to Hollywoods golden age of cinema, in that
it is at the sametime a musical, a peplum (that is swords and sandles movie)
and also a comedy at the same time. It can be purchased from amazone.com.
Darius Kadivar
* Iranians in Islamic invasion of Spain
In regards to Mr. Foad's letter "Flamenco?
Persian?",
Thanks for clarifying your points and correctly criticizing this very
common habit among Iranians. By the way, it is quite correct that Islamic
armies invaded Iran and converted Iranians. It is also true that Islamic
armies invaded Spain as well, but that does not make the invasions neccessarily
Arabic!
The invading Muslim armies could not extend as far as Spain by just
relying on Arabs. It is only common sense that they recruited the population
of the newly conquered territories, and these new recruits took their respective
cultures to the new lands.
In fact, many of the commanders of the Islamic invasion of Spain were
Iranian, among them people with names like Rostam and Behzad! Since you
seem well interested in the subject, please refer to Prof. S. Shafa's new
book, "Persians in Islamic Spain".
I cannot comment at all about the music, since I have no knowledge of
it whatsoever! Nevertheless, I would have to agree that Flamenco has obvious
Berber and Gypsey influences. Still, in many cases, it is not that absurd
for a single man to have taught a kind of music to a nation.
For example, St. Ambrois, an early church father and the bishop of Milan,
invited two magi to Milan and asked them to compose pieces of worship music.
Their compositions are known today as "Ambrosian Chants" and
they form the back-bone of Medieval church music, and by extension, Western
classical music, which has deep roots in Christianity.
I thank Mr. Foad again and hope, along with him, that people start expressing
their ideas without prejudice and bias.
Khodadad Rezakhani
* Someone to talk to
Looking for an Iranian lady friend for my mother who is an Iranian lady
in her late 60's (though she will not admit her age). My mother lives in
Manhattan and is very, very lonely. Her main interests are fashion, sewing,
and to keep up to date with events in Iran. She misses her homeland and
family, and although she will not admit it, her mind and heart are with
Iran.
I would love for her to find a nice Iranian lady to go out to coffe shops
and chat. It breaks my heart to see her so lonely. She is Muslim but not
interested in religion, and does not care at all what religion you are as
long as you are Iranian.
Email contact
* Sinatra in Tehran
Frank Sinatra gave a memorable concert in Tehran Iran in 1973, during
the Shah's reign. He even drank a glass of water after a breath-taking performance
after which he called it "Persian Vodka", provoking laughter among
the stadium crowd. That was his sense of humor.
Could you find pictures related to that event? His concert is mentioned
in a tribute book written by Nancy Sinatra. If you have any clue, I'd appreciate
the feedback.
Regards,
Darius Kadivar
* Immigration / travel issues
I know a man, Iranian, has lived here in the U.S. for about twenty years.
(I do not know how he first got a visa, can only imagine that he has illegally
lived in this country many years.)
He has parents who live in Teheran. He may or may not want to return
to Iran. If he does, what does he need to do? He has a child here in the
U.S. but is not married to the U.S.-born mother (the son was also born in
this country.)
He tells the mother of his U.S.-born son that none of them can visit
his parents in Iran unless she marries him. The mother of his child would
like to know about the legalities of her and her child visiting the Iranian
grandparents with or without the Iranian father. And if he would be part
of the visit, can he return to the U.S. ?
I am the grandmother. Oregon-born, I have lived in northern California
for many years and would like to help out my daughter and grandchild as
far as their knowing the facts of visiting Iran.
As far as the Iranian father, I do not know what questions to ask nor
whom I should contact re: current information on travel and/or repatriation
to Iran?
Gayle Caldwell
|