Voting from the heart

My miserable election day experience

Share/Save/Bookmark

Voting from the heart
by Meir Javedanfar
12-Feb-2009
 

Tel Aviv - Voting day has always been exciting for me. It started when I was a kid in Iran. Our local Kebab Restaurant (Kababi Najafi) was run by a member of the local Islamic committee. On voting days, he turned into a voting office. For us kids, it was a good chance to gather around and to play football. On such occasions, there were far more of us so it was twice the fun. The reason for the added numbers was because the streets were closed, due to fear of car bombs.

 

So instead of playing football between passing cars on the street, which on many occasions caused death or maiming of children (I was run over three times and nearly died during my first experience), we played football without the fear of Tehran's drivers. To us they were far more scary and real than car bombs.

I lived in Iran until I was 14, which meant I was too young to vote. In 1987 we moved to England. During my 17 years there, I never voted. This was because I was either too young, or moving around too much between Universities. Also, on a personal level, I didn't feel connected to the political system. The UK is a wonderful country, but politically, I never felt that I belonged.

This all changed when I moved to Israel in 2004. Politically speaking, I felt very connected here. After having left Iran, this was the first place where I felt at home. This country is no paradise by any stretch of imagination, however as an Iranian Jew, I was welcomed and treated as an equal. As a family we have never felt discriminated against, because of our background. Israel gave us opportunities to progress professionally and in terms of education. This made me feel both happy and guilty.

The guilt came from the fact that Israel's Ethiopian citizens have been left behind. In some cases, they still live in immigrant absorption centres, despite the fact that they have lived here for more than 10 years. Many Ethiopians have progressed, but many have also been left behind.

In the 2006 elections , Kadima who had backed the Gaza withdrawal was slated to win. I thought that the peace process has enough support, so I could afford the luxury of voting with my conscience. The party who I chose to vote for was called Atid Ekhad (one future).This is despite the fact that Shaul Mofaz, a fellow Persian whose family are also from Esfahan, was running for Kadima.

To me social justice was more important than the return of the Esfahani empire. Although that will always be the secret “agenda”. I remember teasing an Arab friend once. “Forget your fears of the so called Zionist conspiracy of taking over from the Nile to Euphrates. Once we Esfahanis have it our way, we will take over from Zayande Rood (famous river in Esfahan) to the shores of the Pacific ocean. They don't call Esfahan Nesfe Jahan (half the world) for nothing”.

Joking aside, for now Atid Ekhad was the party for me. Its stated goal was “bringing to Israel the remaining Jews in Ethiopia and strengthening integration efforts for the community”. Many of its members were Ethiopians.

On the 28th of March 2006, on the occasion of elections for the 17th Knesset of the State of Israel, I wasn't just walking to the ballot box, I was almost hopping and skipping. The excitement was wonderful. Here I was voting for the first time in my life, for a party that my conscience fully supported. As I was about to cast my vote, I even asked the voting supervisor to take a photo of the historic occasion. “You are a new immigrant, right?”, said the guy bemusedly. I guess he had seen it all before.

Atid Ekhad proved to be a failure. Only 14,500 people voted for them which meant that they could not even win one seat in the Knesset. I couldn't believe it. On the night when the results were announced, almost angrily, I asked an Ethiopian security guard “how could you guys let this happen?”. His reply which in a true Ethiopian manner was polite and in a calm voice was “we vote Likud. They are the ones who brought us out of Ethiopia. We are loyal to them”.

Friends had told me to vote with my brain, and that to vote for Atid Ekhad was a waste. But I refused to believe them. In this year's election, I was going to vote with my conscience. This time, for a Green party called Green Movement Meimad (GMM). Their platform which called for increased protection of the environment, social justice, and full support for the peace process was exactly in line which my thinking.

However, all of a sudden, the source of my vote, turned from my heart, to my head. Instead of just using my political knowledge, I started applying geometry. I realized that GMM have little chance of winning a single seat. So then next best party was Labour. To do that, I had to turn 45 degrees to the right. It wasn't easy, but realistic. Thats the end of it, I thought.

Then I heard Bibi and his talk of deposing Hamas. The Iraqi regime change experience was bad enough for the US. It would be absurd to let a leader who talks about a similar adventure come to power. Stopping him became my priority. This is when I realized that Ehud Barak had no chance of running against Netanyahu for the post of Prime Minister. So again it was time to get the protractor out. I decided to turn 45 degrees to the right again, to Tzipi Livni. She was the best moderate choice.

Ninty degrees away from my conscience, I went to cast my vote today. As cast my vote, I broke into a sweat. Tzipi Livni is a far better politician than Bibi, but she was not my first choice. She was my third. And now my body had joined my heart in protesting. It goes to show, that even when you have a full range of choices, it doesn't mean that you pick the one you ideally want.

Unlike 2006, my voting experience today was a miserable one. I don't even want to imagine how I will feel if Likud wins. I know how President Ahmadinejad will feel. He will be happy.

Meir Javedanfar is a Middle East Analyst at Tel Aviv-based MEEPAS, www.meepas.com

Share/Save/Bookmark

Recently by Meir JavedanfarCommentsDate
Is Rafsanjani Up To Something?
9
Sep 25, 2012
The Price of Chicken
3
Aug 08, 2012
Analysis of Iran - IAEA Agreement
2
May 22, 2012
more from Meir Javedanfar
 
Bavafa

To Jaleho - so true

by Bavafa on

The best response I have ever seen in the comment section of the Iranian. COM . I share exactly the same sentiments, many thanks.

Mehrdad

P.S. Enjoyed the joke just as much


default

Ethiopeans vs Palestinians?!!!

by Mehrnaz (not verified) on

Mr Javedanfar, I concur with Jahelo that "I am sorry that you do not have the same humanistic attitude that you feel for the Ethiopians who have brought all the way from Africa" towards the native Palestinians whose lands and homes have been stolen, continue being stolen and perish in circumstances of humiliation, poverty, disease, loss and no hope. Do you not see the contradiction, or are the black Etheopians token gestures, to cover up the colonial racism at the heart of the Zionist project?

Your joke about a land stretching from Zayandeh-rud to the shores of the Pacific Occean, would not be a joke the other way round.

I must say, despite Livni's murderous part in the recent genocide of the Gazans, (she too must be tried for war crimes) I do hope that Natanyahu would not form a extreme right coalition and I do not agree with you that Ahmadi-Nedjad wishes differently. Nearer the truth, what do you feel about the prospects of a US/Iran peace-making?

I do sincerely hope there will be peace with the Palestinians and that their humanity is recognised by your people and government because that is the only way you will preserve your own humanity and there will be a future not only for the Palestinians, not only for others in the region, not only for Iranians but also for Jewish people in israel/Palestine to live in peace and harmony and respect alongside their native neighbours, whose destiny is tied up and at one with the destiny of the people of the region, and not in superior and hostile opposition to it. That day, I will salute you for voting for a Green Party of a land clean of blood and no longer occupied.


default

all I know about these candidates

by bitaraf (not verified) on

was from this TV program:

//www.thedailyshow.com/video/index.jhtml?vide...

they have 47 political parties? sounds like the Iranians in LA!

but seriously, it was really hard to believe that Livni is the more moderate candidate! especially after seeing her in action!

Jaleho that was a funny little joke!


Jaleho

Since you're an Israeli who went to Britain,

by Jaleho on

and and Isfehani who seem to like jokes, here's one for you:

An Israeli arrives at Heathrow airport. As he fills out the entry form, the immigration officer asks him:

"Occupation?"

The Israeli promptly replies: 

"No, just visiting!"

 

And, you said:

"It goes to show, that even when you have a full range of choices, it doesn't mean that you pick the one you ideally want. "

With all due respect, there is no difference between your second choice of Livni, and your nightmare Bibi, neither your first choice, where the Ethiopian friend of yours correctly reminded you that they would vote Likud, as it was Likud bringing them to Israel in the first place.

These are all abreviated in the nature of Israel as a state, and they all represent the same thing: "Occupy a land from its  rifghtful owners and gather Jews or even t invent some Jews who are willing to get some money and cheap housing from the state to live in the stolen land and homes of others. That is, populate the land of Palestinians to create a majority of non-Plaestinian Jews, a devious policy which soon is bound to fail anyway, yet it is the central core of Israeli state and its expantionist soul.

I am sorry that you do not have the same humanistic attitude that you feel for the Ethiopians who are brought all the way from Africa, for the Palestinians whose homes and gardens are being usurped to make room for others.


Maryam Hojjat

Mr. Javedanfar

by Maryam Hojjat on

I am so glad you feel at home in Israel.  Israel is always friend of IRAN, that is what I like to think.  I love Israelites.


default

Zionism is Terrorism

by XerXes (not verified) on

lol, their sign is a candle holder.lol

Zionists are scary people, their system must change to democracy