A Post-Montazeri Iran

Share/Save/Bookmark

Masoud Shafaee
by Masoud Shafaee
08-Nov-2010
 

The New York Times reports:

The web sites of the clerics, Grand Ayatollah Yusuf Sanei and Grand Ayatollah Asadollah Bayat-Zanjani, who are both “sources of emulation,” the highest clerical rank in Shiite Islam, were first reported blocked by news sites linked with Iran’s political opposition movement on Sunday. The official site of a third top cleric, Grand Ayatollah Ali-Mohammad Dastgheib, was reported blocked early last month.

As I wrote back in January in World Politics Review:

For the past seven months, countless parallels have been drawn between the current uprising gripping Iran and the events that ultimately led to the demise of the Pahlavi monarchy some 30 years ago. Whether or not the comparisons are accurate, one irony that cannot be escaped is that the regime is facing increasingly vocal dissent from the very clerical class that brought it to power. In fact, as the Islamic Republic deviates more and more from its theocratic roots and transforms into a military dictatorship, it risks alienating the very marjas who have given it legitimacy since its inception.

It appears that as the New Right continues to consolidate its stranglehold on the regime's institutions, a moral resistance is beginning to take shape within Iran's clerical class against, rather tellingly, the Islamic Republic. A reiteration, indeed, of how very far removed the Iranian regime of the previous thirty years has become from what now rules Iran.

On a related note, Grand Ayatollah Dasthgheib, who lashed out against Khamenei a year ago, has stated that "the person of the Velayat-e faqih has no right to interfere in the affairs of the people," in response to a question posted to him from a worshiper on his website. It has never been more apparent of how distant Khamenei -- who was only elevated to Ayatollah overnight so that he could succeed Khomeini -- has grown from the country's most respected clerics. It was just August of last year, in the immediate fallout from the contested election, when an anonymous letter was circulated within the clergy labeling him a dictator and demanding his removal.
If Khamenei is able to maintain his grip on power from an increasingly encroaching executive and paramilitary, then the absolute latest the Islamic Republic will face its next turning point will be upon his death, when a new Supreme Leader will have to be chosen. If an ultraconservative aligned with the New Right (like Mohammad Taqi Mesbah Yazdi) is pushed through, then expect the final turning of the key in what can clearly now be called the Iranian coup of 2009.

And should that come to pass, then a pervasive spiritual and Islamic resistance to the new ruling class -- not unlike that which galvanized Iran against the Shah -- would certainly fall within the realm of possibility.

Share/Save/Bookmark

Recently by Masoud ShafaeeCommentsDate
Stuck between brothers
-
Nov 03, 2011
As Saudi Troops Enter Manama, Tensions With Iran Rise
1
Mar 16, 2011
Clear Shift
4
Feb 21, 2011
more from Masoud Shafaee
 
Cost-of-Progress

Every time

by Cost-of-Progress on

in the last few years, there's been a percieved rift among the turbaned "leaders", they have been able to mend their differences and maintain the crushing grip they have held on the country and her poor and ill-informed people.

One would have to admit that this a very clever bunch that uses religious ideology as an effevtice means to not only stay in power, but flourish as well. 

All that said, if the powers that be did not want this bunch to stay, they would have been gone by now. When the time is right - that is when they do not serve the purpose for which they were installed - another bunch will take the reign.

As always, it is the common people who pay the price. As long as Iranians are slave to their hard-core superstituous beliefs, it will remain what you see now in some way, shape and form....that is until the oil runs out. Then it will be just like Afghanistan.

CoP

____________

IRAN FIRST

____________


Anonymouse

Who would be an alternative to Mesbah Yazdi?

by Anonymouse on

From what I've read and gathered the focus of many, including Rafsanjani, is to replace the "person" of Vilayat Faghih with a "council", presumably the Guardian Council itself.

Over the years as differences appeared, Khamenei installed new bodies and councils to deal with that particular problem but then those bodies remained in power and added to the ever increasing bureaucracy.  Talk about "big government"!

As much as people like to dismiss Rafsanjani he has remained a political force, so much so that he is the Chief of Guardian Council.  So he is definately a possibility to succeed Khamenei.

On the other hand, when I've talked to some ordinary Iranians in Iran when this subject of next Supreme Leader comes up, they dismiss it non chalantly.  They like to refer to his replacement as replaing Pope in Vatican which doesn't really affect anything.

I think his death will be an interesting news item and change to witness and analyze but doubt if it makes much of a difference.  I believe it is the Iranian economy itself which is now enguled in self-production and over-production (of junk) and isolation from the world economy that will do Islamic Republic in. 

Everything is sacred


comrade

Never late to learn

by comrade on

I can only learn a lot more from this good blog if our friends @ IC who are from opposite sides within IRI start debating. It seems they are smart enough and not willing to expose the rift. I wish the Opposition was nearly as bright.   

Never increase, beyond what is necessary, the number of entities required to explain anything.