November 17, 2001
* Rushdie & Hitler
All I ask is why? Why put Salman Rushdie on
the cover of The Iranian online magazine? ["A
good person"] I don't think this magazine should tailor to anyone's
preferences, but this looks like a purpose provocation of emotions. It
is disturbing,as Rushdie is.
Rushdie can be classified as one of the several confused immigrants from
Asia. His family didn't leave for Pakistan when the nation was formed from
India. After his first visit to the United Kingdom, he came to the conclusion
that he obviously enjoyed the UK more than India (possibly the food, atmosphere,
people, etc.).
He decided to emigrate to the UK. This was his first step in creating
his "independence" from what he was. His second step was Midnight's
Children where in assessing the first years after the split, he slanders
both Gandhi and Nehru, the founders of the modern state of India. His second
step was removing previous links to his religious past. For this, he wrote
the book The Satanic Verses.
Regardless of his literary abilities, he is of a specific lot of writers
over the ages who have renounced their past in order to be viewed as acceptable
in their new surroundings.
Most, if not all, Jews have a problem with the work Mein Kampf
because of its demonization of Jews and its negative tone toward Jewish
people and their religion. Though all Iranians are not Muslims, the vast
majority are, and it makes just as much sense in putting Mein Kampf
or any other one of Hitler's works as the cover story of a Jewish magazine
as it does putting Mr. Rushdie's new book on the cover of The Iranian.
I would honestly consider the appropriateness of some cover stories before
posting them on this website.
Cheers,
Arya Abedin
Editor: Emphasis and bold lettering by author.
* Fumigation
From Shahriar Zangeneh's piece, "The
R-word"
"... the West should complete the fumigation of the region and in
the process earn an eternally grateful ally"!
Commentary anyone?
K. Maghsoodi
* Is speaking up un-American?
I read your response ["How
can you bear it?"] to my playful article titled "Under
bright lights"]. I don't see the connection between my article
and your enumeration of life amenities such as "realization of dreams,
sending our kids to college, buying a house, reaching the top of our profession",
etc.
I don't know about your background in Iran and your current means but
I can assure you that I and a large number of Iranian expats can currently
move back to Iran and create the same if not better economic means for themselves.
But that's not what it's all about. The reason we've stayed here in the
US and became naturalized citizens of this land, and proud Americans I might
add, is largely the level of freedom we have enjoyed here and the equal
protection that we've had under the laws of this land!
To suggest that speaking up against the current erosion of our social
freedoms and the equal protection under the law, is somehow un-American
and unappreciative is not only absurd but also dumb! How would you like
to be stripped off your right to an open trial with a jury of 12 ordinary
citizens and be judged secretly by a panel of military officers who could
convict you with 2/3 of their votes?
Your comments group with the same bunch back in the 1970's who thought
that speaking against the US involvement in the Vietnam war was un-American
and reason for packing your bags and leaving! We know who the history is
siding with on that one!
As for me, I plan to stay right where I am and participate in the political
process as a freedom loving citizen. And I won't bring myself down to ask
another freedom loving American to pack up and leave just because he or
she disagrees with me!
Cheers.
Ben Bagheri
* Desperation father of wrong choices
Reply to "Correction":
It is not unusual for one generation to try and correct the mistakes
of a previous generation. What would be unusual is if a generation can
avoid making the same mistakes. That's when you know you've learned something.
The mistake your fathers made was disliking the regime in power so much,
they were not too picky about what replaced it. They proclaimed, "anything
would be better than this!" until they fell from the frying pan into
the fire. If I read your article correctly, that's exactly the mistake you're
about to make.
Desperation is the father of wrong choices.
Haj Mirza Khan
* Look "within"? Where?
I noticed some interesting responses to my article, "Correction".
Thank you all for good thoughts, this is the real dialogue of civilizations!
(I hope Mr President is listening.)
Just had some comments: To Mr. Talaee ["Do
NOT make same mistakes"]: I don't believe I am making same mistake
as other generation by following a PERSON. If you read carefully, I said
clearly that this revolution is not about Reza or anybody else, it is about
democracy. As far as looking within, millions of my generation look "within"
every day and ask what can we do with our life? Can we go to some of the
best university in middle east? Can we go study in best university in US
and Europe?
There were 50,000 Iranian students in US before revolution, the highest
number of foreign students! (Now, we are happy if we can study in Ukraine
or Armenia or Daneshgah-e-Azad!) Instead of studying and coming back to
build their country, some of them spent all their time supporting NOT a
democratic movement, but a fundamentalist religious movement! They have
high jobs today, and send ansar-e-hezbollah to shut us up when we are upset.
I don't know where else to look "within" to solve this.
To Chiva Tafazzoli ["No
shades in between"]: I and everybody are aware that this government
was put in BY the people-of the OLDER generation. But that is not enough
- we are also aware that it is neither OF the people or FOR the people.
That is only 1 out of 3 conditions, and therefore fails to be a democracy.
To Samar Shadkami ["Youth
in better position"]: I am not sure what you are saying. You
are 30 years old, and spent most of your life in Iran, and described the
same problems people like me experienced. So are you the young generation
or the old generation? We are the same generation I think! It is true,
you and I spent the best years of our life under Iraqi bombsand missiles,
watching our friends die, and almost dying ourselves.
Watching our friends lose hands and legs and suffer from Chemical attack.
We had no future and a lot of akhound telling us what to do. All I am
saying is that the previous generation were allowed to get on a plane, go
to the US with 1 dollar = 7 toman, and study in the best university. If
they wanted to stay in Iran, there were some of the best universities with
the best equipment and professors for them, and they could continue later
in the US. Many of those people took advantage of that, and still complained
by supporting NOT a democratic movement, but a backward Taliban movement,
and are now telling us to be "patient".
Like Mr. Talaee said, they went after a PERSON because they didn't like
to have a shah?!? They ended up with a worse shah. (How "mature"
do you need to be to understand that this was a bad idea??) I am sick of
them telling us now to be patient and 10 years is nothing in history. Easy
for them to say, because it is not their life. As far as freedom in Iran,
I don't know what you are thinking. If you believe there is freedom in
Iran, I invite you to go and talk to the people on trial behind closed doors
right now. If you can.
And as far as representing Iranian youth's opinions, neither you or I
can tell because Iranian youth are not allowed to speak. I only say these
things as my opinion, as one Iranian youth. I know many agree with me,
and I respect the many of those who do not. But none of us know how many
are on which side. Hopefully, we will find out one day- when we have a
democracy ! :-)
In the hope of that day,
Ahmad Javan
* The day when we do not need a leader
I, like many others, hate to kick the dead horse again and write about
monarchy. But for the sake of Iran and the remote possibility that some
may venture fishing in the muddy water , I had to write these few lines.
1- Please read The King and I (YAD'DASHT'HA-YI ASADDOLLAH ALAM) and especially
the introductory chapter by Alinaqi Alikhani. Please note that these sons
of slaves (GHOLAAMAANE KHAANAH-ZAAD) knew the constitutional monarch much
better than you and I.If you do not read it , you may regret it later.
Now , will you honestly accept a permanent and hereditary physician
and/or lawyer for you , your children and thereafters without even being
able to fire them? Then are the shahs and Valye Faghihs any different?
2- Please remember that the last four constitutional Shahs died abroad
with complete approval and jubilation of the people. All four of them had
sworn to Koran to uphold the constitution. Fool me once shame on you , fool
me twice, shame on me. How many more times shall we be fooled?
3- In regard to the exiled self proclaimed "RAHBARS" , funny
, YEKI RAA BE DEH RAAH NEMIDAADAN SORAAGHE KHAANAEH KAD-KHODAA RAA MEYGEREFT.Why
do we need a leader anyway ,especially when they have not even lived in
Iran for the last 25 years? The day when we do not need a leader is the
day that we are mature and free. Electing a campaigning person , yes.
A saviour on a white horse , no.
Peerooz
* Wonderful poem
Dear Editor: I just read the poem "Yaad
kon" by Sheema Kalbasi on your web site and I thought it was a
wonderful poem. It is unusual to express emotions by simple words. In "Yaad
kon", Sheema has been able to project her deep sense of emotion
to the readers very beautifully. We would like to see more of her poems
on your site.
Thanks,
Shahriar Etemadi
* Not a new country
The Persia/Iran debate ["Cultural
continuity"] is silly, but then some like the same run-of-the-mill
clothes only if they bear a pricey marque de maison.
I am not sure what is worse, Mr. Khadivar getting the date of Persia/Iran
decree wrong or Peeroz getting the date right but misconstruing the "decree"
altogether. For the record: Prior to 1935 and since that time, the Iranians
have always called their homeland "Iran." The 1935 "decree"
was in fact a circular sent to the foreign diplomatic and consular missions
in Iran asking them to henceforth refer to the country as Iran in their
parlance. The decree/circular did not create a country without any heritage
or identity, it simply brought the rest of the world up to speed.
On the subject, here is a passage from Mission for My Country by H.I.M.
Mohammed Reza Shah Pahlavi Shahanshah of Iran (McGraw-Hill, 1960), p.15:
I still clearly remember an incident when, as a young Crown Prince,
I was at school in Switzerland. Our milkman asked me one day which country
I came from, and when I told him Persia, he said: 'Oh yes, I have heard
of Persia, That's in America!'" Long afterwards [an Iranian visiting
an Indian reservation in Arizona] was introduced to a warrior resplendent
in feathers and war paint, who asked [the visitor] in perfect English:
"What is your country?'" "I come from a far-off place called
Iran or Persia," answered [the visitor]. Immediately, the Indian's
face brightened, and extending his hand in salute, he said in excellent
Persian: 'Salaam alaykum! Hal-e shoma chetore? Greetings, how are you."
Guive Mirfendereski
* Put out the fire they started
A Muslim spokesperson will not have enough clout for the job.The U.S.
is the main cause and direct blame of anything nasty happening around the
world.The U.S. has to learn to pay for oil , just like every other country
in the world.After the ww II,the Brits realised this and pulled out of the
middle east and were replaced by the yanks.Since the war they have bombed
more than 20 counties around the world.They start the fire and surely they
need to put it out.
For the past 11 yrs, the U.S. has been the driving force behind U.N.
sanctions against Saddam Hossein and the 22 mil. Iraqi people.Estimates
vary, but the World Health Organization and UNICEF studies certify that
sanctions are responcible for the death of more than a million Iraqi civilians,
including more than half a million children. Genocide is taking place right
now , every day, in Iraq, by the very power that claims to set the standard
for democracy, freedom and justice.
Attacks on civilians can never be accepted. However, it must not be
forgotten that although the era of colonialism has long been over, the U.S.
countinues to further its own interests by commercially exploiting developing
countries. It has been intervening in the local politics of independent
nations not to help them but to secure its own global interests. Arms are
supplied to countries in civil war, military groups have trained using U.S.
capital and U.S. experts. This is what happened in Afghanistan and with
Osama bin Laden. Why are American politicians averse to diplomacy? Violence
will only creates more violence >>>
FULL TEXT
Farhang Asfarpour
* Opposing Jane Fondaism
Leyla Momeny's opinion piece "Opposing
John Wayneism" about anti-war dissidents in America, is in my
opinion, a flawed contribution. For one, readers not resident in the USA
might well be left with the impression that the supposed "anti war"
movement in America is far larger and more influential than it is in fact.
Although it is true as Momeny reports that anti war activists have emerged
in the wake of the American counter attack on the Taliban and their "guests,"
their numbers have been fairly small. In the San Francisco Bay Area for
example--certainty one of the most left of center spots in America-the largest
demonstration against the war gathered around 5,000 people. I can assure
you, as a long time resident, that is minor by San Francisco standards whose
residents consider demonstrations a hobby. By contrast at the start of the
American/British-Iraq war in the early 1990s, around 200,000 people demonsatretaed
on a single day in this city against the war. Hopefully this adds some perspective
when one considers the level of American opposition to the war in Afghanistan.
I can assure you when President Bush gets a majority approval rating in
San Francisco, a city where Republicans are an endangered species, it constitutes
a mandate from America's liberals and radicals.
Further, as Momeny's article implies much of the supposed anti war protests
are actually multi issue affairs ranging from opposition to the death penalty
to opposition to globilization. To call them "anti war" protests
grants them far more consistency and coherence then they deserve. At best,
the war has only been a catalyst for a group of permanent dissidents to
vent their favorite causes. And of course there is always the reunion factor:
activists from the 1960s frequently show up at such protests to relive the
"good old days." Indeed, these veterans of the 1960s have been
predicting the return of a mass anti war movement for over 30 years now
without I might, add much to offer in the way of proof. But there is the
same old reunion every few years, when ever even one American soldier is
deployed in a combat role >>>
FULL TEXT
William Baker
* Ajami = deaf
In comment to the letter "Dubai:
Closest thing to home", in the work, it states that the "Iranians"
of Dubai are referred to as Ajami. There must be clarification here. Ajami
DOES NOT equate Persian in the Arabic language. Farsi (Arabic) = Parsi
(Persian) = Persian (English). Rather, ajami literally means one who is
deaf in Arabic. All non-Arabic speaking populations are called Ajami.
Hence, Iran used to be referred to as Ajam also. I wouldn't encourage
other Iranians to refer to themselves as "deaf", which is a word
deriving from an Arabocentric Era.
I have been to Dubai; it's nice, but I wonder where the allegiences
of "Iranian" Emiratis stand on, say, for instance, the issue of
the disputed islands between Iran and the UAE (Tonb-e-bozorg, Tonb-e-kuchak,
and Abu Musa)?
Cheers,
Arya Abedin
* What are we?
"Where are you from?" my students ask when they see me for
the first time. Especially Iranian or Arab students. It is "the eyes"
I think!
I say to my Arab students (having to answer this many times):"No,
I am not Arab". They very promptly say:"Iranian?" and usually
follow this with some Persian phrase that I can't understand.
I say to my Iranian students:"I am part Iranian" on which they
glow and happily start chatting in Farsi. Words that I most of the time
don't understand!
Shame on me! But what is expected of someone like me? Mother Yugoslav,
father of Iranian origin who never lived in Iran and me living in the UK,
married to an Iranian who calls himself Persian and is a practising Sunni
Muslim!
More confusion!!! Arabs don't like Iranians, religious Iranians are not
keen on Sunnis or non-religious Iranians, non-religious Iranians are not
keen on any religious Iranians but somehow, in my classroom I can see my
Iranian student's eyes sparkle when they hear of my origins. And somehow,
I feel privileged to have such diversity in my life.
But I ask myself very often when people say "IRANIAN" are they
aware themselves at that moment how many different perceptions of what "Iranian"
is, exist! My father was Iranian, I am Iranian, my husband is Iranian,
my baby boy Ali is Iranian, but all of us have completely different identity
with the Iranian culture and the Iranian people. Or perhaps, this is wrong.
Perhaps, we are not Iranian, we just wish we are.
We are, in fact citizens of different countries and so, in the process
of losing our roots, we are trying to root ourselves back by stating our
affiliation to Iran or to a particular religious (or not) movement.
Why can't we just be PEOPLE with memories that make us belong somewhere
in our hearts, just like looking in the photo album, but instead this photo
album is our heart that has no pictures, just feelings that we KNOW belong
somewhere. Far away perhaps, for many of us, but they make us cry and make
us sing and make us happy and make us hope that one day we will return.
Return WHERE?
Dr. A. Stones-Abbasi
London, UK
* Positive changes
I read Mr. Yahya Kamalipour article, "Media
village", with great interest. All the more as the film industry
was never considered as seriously as today with the development of multimedia
tools and their applications which allow things such as streaming video
on the Net. As for Cinema which I personally like to defend as opposed to
other entertainment forms is barely a Century old. Is Cinema an Art form
or not is debatable. The United States has certainly most contributed to
the development of the Industry. Hollywoods Golden Age dominated by major
Studio's such as the Big Five that is MGM, Paramount, the 20th Century Fox,
The Warner Bros, RKO, as opposed to the little Three Universal, Colombia
and United Artists (the latte sunk to one film Michael Cimino's "Heaven's
Gates") marked the Age of Big Studio's and monopoly. It is to the credit
of America's Edison (even if France equally disputes the creation of the
Cinema as an entertainment due to the frères Lumières) to
have raised this Industry to a major Art Form. One of my favorite passtimes
as many yougsters was watching films.
I'd like to draw attention on the following website //www.reelclassics.com/
dedicated to Hollywood classic films which nurished me and in that I am
much debted to Iranian television and movie theaters before the revolution.
Films notably American have influenced generations worldwide. However to
this day may it be remembered that the first film producer in the World
is India with no less than 300 films per year. The films are nevertheless
unequal and hardly exported, though recently with new coming Indian filmmakers
"Bollywood" is if not replacing Hollywood establishing its reputation
in the Far East. As for Iranian Cinema it has most probably acquired its
highest reputation paradoxically under the current Islamic regime. Mohsen
Makhbalbafs latest film "Khandahar" is probably the first Iranian
film (Though on an Afghan subject) to have attracted no less than 800 000
seats in the first two weeks in Paris. Cannes film festival no doubt was
the first International film festival to have privaledged films worldwide
and despite its excesses has been a formidable trampoline for Middle Eastern
and third World Country films. Other film festivals have raised attention
such as the Venise Lion d'Or as well as the Berlin film Festival (even if
the German film industry has not made a major comeback since the seventies).
It should be noted that the Kish film festival has also made a certain echo
and it is to the credit of todays Iranian Cinema Industry.
Positive changes were made in this respect thanks to the work of Iranian
film makers and co-productions with foreign distributors despite the strong
degree of censorship which must have contributed to a creative challenge
on the part of the film makers. Mr. Kamalipour raises the question of globalisation
American media and thus the "American way of life". This is not
new however the reverse is also true with film festivals held in America.
"Sundance" independant film festival as well as Canadian film
festivals have contributed to the viewing non American Films. The succes
of "The Fabulous Destiny of Amelie Poulain" a rare French film
directed by Jean Jacques Jeunet have proved that small budget films with
subtitles can have their audience even in North America.
What has certainly changed in the West however is the transition of what
was considered as an Industry to an independant Art form. Obviously not
all productions are masterpieces, nevertheless the Cinema industry has evolved
especially with the introduction of video on the Web which allows broadband
broadcasting to private homes. This is certainly a technological breakthrough
that can represent a threat for the traditional Cinema Industry. The pleasure
of going to movies and sharing emotions with others is a unique experience
that cannot be felt on television or home Cinema. The excesses of this trend
are seen with the multiplication of channels as well as shows such as "Cast
Away" which now have their derivatives in Europe with more or less
success. I believe that traditional Cinema must continue even if Television
and tomorrow private Media networks can contribute to publicising films
in general and encourage the urge of going to the Cinema.
Regards,
Darius Kadivar
* Uplifting
Susan Warda's article, "So
Iranian... So American", was very uplifting in a time of great
confusion. Please publish more like that.
Regards,
Ian Forry
* Disgraceful and distasteful
The picture
of Mr. Mahdavi-Kia that has been dubbed by Hadi Khorsandi is a disgraceful
and distasteful attempt at making humor. At the same time he is putting
down one of our best athletes for his personal agenda.
I would suggest that you act more sensitive with regards to our heros
and remove this from your site.
Regards,
Tourang Birangi
Houston, Texas
* Keep Blasevic
Iran lost this time but in every loss there is a lesson to learn. This
time we started the qualifiying games with having practiced only for 6
months. Although we had one of the best coaches in the world, but the reality
is that he is a human like others. He can not do miracles. I think 6 months
is not enough to prepare a team for important games such as WCQ games.
When France was eliminated in 1994 world cup games, their coach said, "Give
me four years and I will take France to the final and we will become a world
champion." And they didit through four years of hard working along
with a good plan. What I want to say is that let's not loose Mr. Blasevic.
Let's keep him. This man can prepare our team for world cup 2006 and I will
promise you that Iran can get unbeleivable result in those games. Let's
not forget about the team and then hire a coach and try to put the team
toghether in 6 mothns. This approach will never get us the results that
we want and deserve.
Although this campaign was unsuccessful, it was not neither the players
nor the coach's fault. They both did a good job. They did more than what
was expected from them. We, all Iranians are proud of you. We love all of
you and will be our heros for years to come. Blasevic built up a fantastic
team within the time period that he had.
We have Asian cup coming up in two years and the next world cup in four
years. Let's keep Blasevic and give him all that he needs to build a good
team. Let's try to put them in a relaxing environment away from side perssures.
Then we will have a team that has something to say in international battles.
They can be one of the best in the world and this comes from the bottom
of my heart and i believe in it.
Please think about this. It will give the result we want.
At the end I wish the best for every one of our players and Mr. Blasevic.
Mr. Blasevic please don't leave us. Stay and help us to build a strong team.
Even if you leave us, which we don't like at all, just remember something,
we all love you. You will remain a hero in our hearts.
Thank You
Best wishes for "TEAME MELLI"
Lets just say it one more time, "MELLI POOSHAN PIROOZ BASHID."
GHORBOONE HAMEYEH BACHEHAYEH TEAME MELLI.
Babak Monajemi
* Mage meeshe vel kony?
salam koby joon, ["Kobra
Khanom"]
eeeeeeee,,mage mishe ke vel kony bery?? mage daste khodete?ma hesaby
aadat kardim be to,,be harfaat,,be nasaayehet,,hala beryyyy?? man taze
ba harfaat ehsaas mikardam ke aamaadegy baraaye ezdevaaj va moghaabele
ba moshkelaat daram,,,,eeeeeee,,,yadam rafte bood ,,man shohar daram,,heheheh,,,bebiiiiiin
az esghe to ,,paak shoharamo yadam rafte bood. bayad begy be ma ke chy shode???
khodaii nakarde moshkele khaanevaadegy baraat pish omade?? az ma khaste
shody?? hoghoogh behet kam midan?? chy shode akhe?? kholase bia va dobaare
ozvy az khaanevadeye ma besho... jaane man bargard...goftam jaane man,,,,,,
mibosamet,,
Maryam
* Ease the loss
I like to notify the friends and fans of Moji
Agha, that he recently lost his mother. A message of sympathy to <mojiagha@qwest.net> would help ease
the loss, as we all have to go through loss of our loved ones, while we
live away from homeland.
Mojgan Rahmani M.D.
* Promote jaffari faith
Yesterday while i was searching the web about mumin brothers and sisters
in different parts of the world i came across your address so i thought
of mailling you.before going any further let me introduce my self. i am
R.SAJAD HUSSAIN 26 year old engineering graduate from kashmir(INDIA). i
think we should know as well as keep in touch with one another so as to
know what all we need to do to protect as well as promote fiqa jaffari from
attempts that are being made to distroy us.time and again i had been writting
to different leaders of our community perticularly to mujtahid's in iran
about different hardships that our brothers and sisters have to face perticularly
through the hands of hardliner sunni's. but i have come across a little
sucess.
see for yourself how our brothers are treated in pakistan, how talibans
in afghanistan are masacerring our brothers,take the case of iraq although
we are in a majority there but still tourtured, have you ever thought about
all this? why this is happenning ? what measures we need to take to stop
all this? take the case of jews see how isreal is helping them through out
the world,i shouldn't say but still i salute them for their concern for
their community.compare their concern for their community with our's. we
stand no were. hope to hear from your side very soon.
With regards,
Sajad
* Ali Reza Ghaderian
I am hoping you will take time to reply to this email. I am trying to
locate a person by the name of Ali Reza Ghaderian. His father was mayor
of Isfahan about 20 years ago. Ali came to Maine in the United States to
attend the Oak Grove Coburn School. I was his English teacher and he lived
with our family for three years. Our boys have considered him an older brother.
Now that our children are married and have a family they have inquired about
him. We were in touch for quite a few years but I think he moved. His family
owned a kitchen cabinet company.
Any help you can give concerning how I can locate him would be helpful.
Thank you so much,
Susan Morris
* Ahmad Moradkhani
My name is Mehdi and i am looking for a lost friend , Ahmad Moradkhani
who lives (lived?) in Germany. Anyone with information about him please
let me know.
Mehdi Moradkhani
* I just want to know
I have been searching for twenty-three years to find out if my husband
is still alive.Is there any anybody can help me? Please, I have had enough
crap from both counties. I just want to know. I will never stop looking
for him. Death is the only way I will stop!
Thank-You,
Marilyn McQuilkin
|