Tuesday
August 28, 2001
* NOT refugees
The saying goes .. you don't kick a gift horse in the mouth!
It is very unfair to blame the unfortunate case of Shayan
on the Australian government. We seem to get our fact wrong here...
1) Australia didn't invite Shayan or his family,
2) They "illegally" entered Australia, bypassing official channels
devised for refugees,
3) They were given food and accomodation at reasonable standards,
4) Their case for being refugees was reviewed twice and rejected so they
are NOT refugees.
It is very regrettable that they have had to endure so much hardship
but let's not forget who's responsible for this. It's Shayan's family. You
might say they had to leave Iran, they had no choice, etc ... then it's
the Iran's government's fault... NOT Australia!
Keeping with this logic, you have potentially another 60 million Iranians
who have a hard life and have anti-establishment beliefs ... so can claim
"refugee" status, hey let's get them all out of Iran and let them
in Australia!
Hey... let's drop the finger pointing and take responsibility for our
actions.. 20 years ago, we stuffed up our own wonderful country and now
were eating its wood!! if you know what I mean...
Peace,
Azad
* I'm Iruni, dammit!
When I was growing up, I too struggled trying to speak Farsi just like
the children of our family friends ["Competing
with cousins"]. Both my parents are Iranian, but I guess it had
to do with my mother's adamant opinion that English would do me more good
in America than my knowledge of Farsi would. Her explanation took a long
time to sink into my thoughts.
I've heard both sides of the coin. When I first started speaking Farsi,
our Iruni neighbor remarked (in front of me) that I spoke like I was Afghan.
I'm Iruni, dammit! So I practiced with more passion. "Mamman, how
do I say this.... Mamman esmesh beh farsi chee hast?"
So slowly I learned enough to speak Farsi and carry a conversation well.
My Mom was right. Her idea was that if I learned Farsi enough to carry
a conversation and be able to communicate with my Iranian friends, and more
importantly family in Iran, then the communication barrier would be broken.
It's a hell of a lot harder for all of my cousins in Iran to learn English
than it is for me to learn Farsi. When I last spoke to my cousin she told
me that she wanted to get her doctorate in English, and she's sending me
letters in English.
Just yesterday I saw a young guy (about 16) working in a store. He had
a little accent when he spoke, I could barely hear it. Nonetheless, I asked
him where he was from. "Iran," was his response. When I asked
"Haleh shoma chetoreh?" he looked floored. During our short conversation
he asked me how I learned to speak Farsi so well. I believe the answer
to that question is one word. Persistence.
Mitra Gholam
* We are a new breed
This is in response to an article by a Persian woman who feels like she
can't claim a home ["Am
I homeless?"]. Although all of us Persians that have been raised
in the US are anything but a hundred percent Iranian, we all feel something
very inherently inside of us, a connection with every Iranian we meet, whether
they be the BMW- driving, Tehrangeles Persian or an old man in Shiraz, there
is sense of identification and connection felt between two people from the
same land.
However, I don't believe that most of us will feel our homeland in Iran.
Those of us, like myself, who have never even seen the country, cannot
help but realize that walking on Iranian soil will fall short of giving
us all the answers. I do believe that being in an area where everyone and
everything speak the language and culture of our mothers will contribute
to a sense of belonging that has never been known.
However, an isolation that can cut through the heart will also exist
for us Persian-Americans who visit Iran. The isolation is born by being
surrounded in an environment free of the beliefs and cornerstones that have
been embedded in our personalities. Freedoms of speech, equality, and capitalism
have all influenced us as Americans.
These points are generally accepted among the Iranians in the US. So
if these premises exist, then where is our home? I have thought about the
"home" notion for quite some time. Visiting Barcelona, Spain,
and I initially felt more at home than I had in the US. This fascinated
me, and the only conclusion derived was that it was a passionate culture
and thus I related.
However, it still did not feel completely "right". I have
plainly rejected the pursuant of a "home country" because I have
realized that we are bicultural, and correspondingly, there is no country
that is clearly homogeneous in its biculturalism.
The truth is, we are a new breed: the Iranian-American breed. The challenge
before us is the constant effort towards understanding this and reconciling
the dichotomy. We are made up of two cultures that are on opposite sides
of the spectrum.
One of the most important moments in my life was the day I decided to
love the Iranian side of me: the irrational, passionate, poetic, and expressive
side. We are at an advantage, we have opposing qualities that create amazing,
well-rounded people. So in labeling a country or place as a home, perhaps
we can never do that, but maybe that disposes us to be more receptive to
the world.
Mary Abolfazli
* Hard not to sympathize
After reading Pejman's plea ["PERRRRRSIAN"],
it is hard not to sympathize with him and not to echo his voice. For those
of you who are not familiar with, or even to refresh your memory , please
read ["Sharhe-Hal"]
and ["Everything"?] again. It is about the life time services
of the most valuble living Persian to our culture, language and literature.
Dr.Ehsan Yarshater has been crusading for years to use Persia and Persian
in English correctly , instead of Iran and Farsi. He is the most eligible
authority to render an opinion on this subject and yet his voice has not
been heard.
Is there any wonder then, if our Gulf is called Arabian and our country
sounds like and often mistaken for Iraq, when we do not listen to our learned
elders?
Peerooz
* It requires goodwill
I am an Egyptian person, and I cannot agree with you more that peace
in the Middle East is the best solution for all the parties involved including
Iran.
However, peace does not mean stopping periodically the fights between
Israelis and Palestinians or the Arabs. It requires goodwill to radically
solve problems that initiate wars. Israel refuses to give the Palestinians
the rights to live as a nation, and then asks them to remain quite and not
even to protest or...
I think Iran and Middle Eastern countries in particular should make the
U.S. -- as the only super power now in the world -- see where problems come
from, so that a just settlement could be achieved.
Ali Rafea
* Pretending to be a hero
I don't understand what Moji Agha is trying to achieve with his tasteless
unilateral argument with a journalist, insulting him each time, calling
himself a Persian, a Sufi, a self-assigned defendant of other nations?!
["Think
wider"]
Am I understanding correctly, that he is talking about the Islamic regime
in Iran when saying "Have you seen the young yet genuine democracy
that your government is trying to sabotage"! What is he talking about?!
Comparing this regime to Mossadegh's? If that's what he means then fine,
I will not bother responding to him. I have been and seen many of the victims
of that "democracy". (Even the regime itself doesn't pretend to
be democratic, they hate the term!)
I guess the Israeli journalist is a gentleman who is trying not to be
ignorant by responding to this abusive person but he shouldn't. "If
you want to debate, let's do it"?! Just ignore him sir. No one is obliged
to get engaged in a conversation with anyone else especially such a person
-- don't. There is no use to that. Mr Agha is calling the man "deeply
racist journalist", what is the evidence for that? The quote he had
the other day from him, didn't show us any such evidence.
He is pretending to be a hero who is not scared of being assassinated!
I am sorry but who the hell are you to be worth such a hassle! I am serious,
is Mr Agha trying to get credit from the regime? Who are these people? Are
we from two different countries or planets?!
Let me stop here, this must be another agent provocateur of a dictatorship
who has the worst record itself. I am almost suffocating with frustration
with our "haalo rooz" on one hand and such fellow countrymen on
the other hand. I am looking for a little common sense "Az divo dad
maloolam".
Your faithfully,
Hassan Shamloo
* Israel took iranian.com
I have come to conclusions that Israel is monitoring "our"
communications at least on this site. There are more than one or two reasons
and I know what Zionists are capable of; therefore I am not in a position
to put myself at a risk.
I put OUR in quotations because this site used to belong to Iranians.
Unfortunately, not any more.
I hardly ever come to this site any more This used to be my favorite
site. I used to get all of my information about my country, Iran, from this
site. But Israel took this one from us also. Believe it or not the Israeli
Embassy is watching you.
John
* IT IS NOT HATRED
This is in response to, "Why
so much hate?"
You are wrong, in fact very very wrong if you believe that most of the
Iranians who have expressed their views on this site about the policies
of Israel are hateful of Jews. In fact, it is Jews who in their efforts
to silence any comment or criticism on the policies of Israel claim anti-Semitism
each time.
The majority of decent people do not have any prejudice against Jews
or anybody else. Let me inform you that some of the most vocal and eloquent
defenders of Palestinians are Israeli Jews.Yes, Israeli Jews, who have come
to realize the enormity of the injustice inflicted on these defenseless
people.
Consider this for a moment: we as Iranians or as Muslim, allow ourselves
to comment on anything, our regimes, our religion, even some of our customs,
particularly concerning women's rights, and rightly so. The inability of
the majority of the people of Jewish faith to comprehend and react to the
injustices being inflicted on the Palestinians in their name, is the cause
of the criticism, IT IS NOT HATRED, certainly they claim it to be hatred
because it allows them to bury their heads in the ground and DENY, DENY,
DENY.
And, as for your Jewish friends, obviously they have done a good job
of explaining to you the situation on ground zero from their prospective,
have you done any research of yourself on this matter? And please don't
look for news concerning this part of the world on CNN, New York Times
and Washington Post, maybe The Guardian and The Independent
(London) would be a good places to start.
How many Palestinian friends do you have? Ah, but we Iranians share the
Israeli view, about Arabs, them with their backward culture and religion,
our enemies and...
Karim Goadri
* Excusing Israeli atrocities
I do NOT remember the last time I read such an inane piece of trash that
masqueraded as political commentary ["Understanding
outrage"]. Oh wait, yes I do... yesterday's edition of The
New York Times. But that's another story.
How utterly OFFENSIVE and reprehensible can one be to suggest that the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict is an equal conflict with both sides on equal
footing and on equal moral ground-like two siblings fighting with each
other. That's what the author of this article seems to imply-'yes both
sides have grievances', 'yes both sides are equally to blame', bla bla
bla bla bla.
To formulate the conflict in these terms is to forgive and excuse Israeli
atrocities against the Palestinians. In fact at one point he even says
that punishing Israeli atrocities would only lead to further violence.
Boy that's a great line of logic, Mr. Amir.
Let me ask you something: would you go to an Armenian who's great-grandparents
were murdered by the Turks in the Armenian genocide and say, "Well
both sides suffered heavy losses" and "both sides were to blame
for the conflict"?? I dare you to go to an Armenian and say such
a thing. They'll floor you faster than Jackie Chan in fast forward.
You should be ASHAMED of yourself for trying to gloss over and dilute
Israel's daily atrocities against the Palestinian population. To even
suggest that the Israelis and Palestinians are on equal moral footing is
wrong and unacceptable.
NN
* Forcible conversion
Corr Chris "Where's
the evidence?" is stating the well fabricated history as written
by Muslim fanatics. If he reads any books written on Iranian history by
"independent sources", for example from Russian or English books,
he will note the Arab atrocities and forcible conversions in Iran and other
places.
What he says about Jazieh and minority rights in Islamic Iran is a sick
joke. Jazieh was so high that a lot of Iranians had to convert to Islam
because they simply could not afford to pay the infidel's tax. However,
later on the Arab rulers who were not happy with the loss of income because
of these new conversions insisted on payment from newly converted non-Arab
Muslims. "Conversion" under financial pressure is forcible conversion
too.
Iranains rebelled against Arab occupiers many times. Babak, Maziar,
Ostaadsis and many others who were defeated and killed together with all
their followers. All because they did not want to convert. In one incident
the Arab ruler of Rey wanted to see blood stream from Iranian blood, but
the blood was not streaming no matter how many people they killed. So they
had to add water to satisfy this good Muslim's thirst for blood.
Even the Arab people of Mecca were forcibly converted after the prophet
entered the city with his army. Islam has been propagated by the sword
and kept by force. Only recently the Taliban in Afganestan have arrested
some aid workers for "propagating Christianity" because they had
a copy of the Bible. This kind of behaviour has been the norm in the past
1,400 years throughout the Islamic world.
Finally, I am very well aware of what the Persian emperors did. However,
first they did not do it in the name of Allah! And second, who said that
they were perfect?! But third, Iranians were much better off under their
own emperors than under the Arab emperors.
Kaveh Ahangar
* Persian KHARS
Dear Ham Vatan, Farid, ["Racist
remarks"]
Thank you for your comment about Persians being KHAR that they did not
see what a good life they had & opted for Khomeini & the so-called
REVOLUTION.
I admire your courage to call the bunch of them KHAR. That is exactly
what they were & some still are.
Best regards,
Hashem Hakimi
Norway
* Sad spectacle
Response to Azam's letter "An
Iranian can never be khar":
It is truly shocking to get a letter from someone who preaches everyone
that an Iranian can never be khar and then makes such disgusting racist
remarks about someone's wife. You just put that label (khar) on yourself,
lady.
That was a sad spectacle. In Iran we call this "Bijanbegi"
(not having the slightest sense of humor), and "Bihormati" (not
having an ounce of dignity or respect). If you are such a red-blooded Iranian,
the first thing you should know is that insulting someone's wife in our
culture is a big NO-NO, whomever they might be. And what business is it
of yours why he married an Indian?
I have read all of Mr.
Salari's featured articles to this day. I find his anecdotes to be very
sincere, very humble, and very entertaining. For what it looks like, he
is a very successful man and obviously a very intelligent one.
Atleast, he is sincere enough to share his family pictures and stories
with the rest of us. What makes his articles so readable is because they
are not stuffy. He makes more fun of himself than anything else when he
elaborates on his everyday-life comic adventures, which are a breath of
fresh air.
And, for the record, Azam khanoom, we are not all in the habit of putting
down other nations just because we think they don't add-up to our level.
You should be ashamed of yourself. If you're suppose to be the typical Iranian
woman (which I am sure you're not), that explains why some of our guys chose
to take an alternative route.
Sam
* IRIB
Greetings from Spain.
I am very interested in knowing the program schedule of the IRIB 2 but
after several hours of looking for it I have not been able to find it. Can
you help how to find the program schedule? Where I can see the program,
type of program and the language they broadcast. This is an information
for an international satellite magazine and for me is very important to
find out it because to find the job I have to give them this information
correctly.
Lopez
|