Negative consequences of isolating the regime in Tehran


Leaders in the west and outraged Iranian opposition groups hoping to topple the regime through regime isolation (ie, "regime crippling sanctions") should think twice about such measures.

I will be called a regime apologist by some, or even worst by closet-war-advocates, but bare with me a few minutes and read these two articles before passing judgment:

* latimes: U.S. and EU fail to isolate Iran
China, Russia, India and Turkey move into the lucrative void left by U.S. and EU sanctions that aim to halt Iran's nuclear program.

* latimes: Iran hard-liners skirt sanctions
Merchants linked to the Revolutionary Guard are using front companies and third parties to do business. Some are even profiting directly from the sanctions.


In our quest to punish the regime for its behavior we are economically isolating Iran and Iranians from the liberal democracies that are the western world. In the long term this could destroy the very middle-class that made the June uprising of '09 possible. It could help to cement the tyrannical regime's reign over the Iranian people, prolonging its shelf life. And naturally IRI is forced to deal with non-western powers, moving Iran further towards questionable regional actors like Russia and China.

We should set aside emotions and think rationally for a moment and ask ourselves, are we on a correct course? Do these sound like good policies that will benefit both Iranian and western countries? Or are they feel good measures that will fail to solve any imminent crises (nuclear program), retard progress on the democracy front and even worse, bring us closer to another major military conflict...


Recently by MOOSIRvaPIAZCommentsDate
Messianic Regime
Apr 28, 2012
Mujahedin (MEK) is everywhere! And they are amazing!
Apr 11, 2012
Bibi Netanyahu's religious fanaticism
Mar 06, 2012
more from MOOSIRvaPIAZ


by Q on

Please, we know are pro-war as you told NPR on live radio. But are you seriously delusional enough to think it will stop right after a few "surgical attacks" ?

marhoum Kharmagas

Surgical attack can't do $#!+!

by marhoum Kharmagas on

Iranian system compared to Iraq or the Pahlavi time is much less concentrated. This somewhat distributed system has its vulnerabilities and strengths, fortunately surgical attack won't do $#!+ to it!


hence why surgical attacks are the only answer

by mahmoudg on

thanks for proving my point.


koo gooshe shenava


I fear many of us are too invested in fighting the regime that we are missing the big picture here.

Mola Nasredeen

Good observations about the effects of sanctions on Iranian

by Mola Nasredeen on


"Businesspeople say that the situation means consumers are paying skyrocketing prices for housing, food and transportation, and that independent merchants are losing ground to those inside the political establishment.

Meanwhile, in Tehran's sprawling Grand Bazaar, well-connected conservative merchants linked to the Islamic Coalition Party, which is close to Khamenei, have used their business and financial connections with China to ignore sanctions, said Kamran Vakil, an official at the Iranian Union of Mineral Products Manufacturers and Exporters, a private-sector trade association."

Thanks for the links.