Friday
April 13, 2001
* We deserve it
What a nice God ["Quit
whining"]! If my God were to write such a letter to us Iranians,
I think he would be more direct and a little harsher. I think we'd deserve
it.
Hamid K
* Khamenei
In my opinion the Iranian
of the year should be Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. For better or for worse
he has had the single most important impact on Iranians as a whole. Through
his backing of the ruling establishment and efforts aimed at maintaining
the status quo in Iranian politics, and also through the powers bestowed
upon him by the constitution, he has managed to affect all of us in some
shape or form.
It is also my assumption that he will continue to do so for as long as
the constitution is kept in its present form, where the Velayat-faghih and
Guardian Council feed off of each other evading any form of checks and balances
of power.
Part of the magic of democracy is the pluralism and sense of accountability
that is inherent in such a system of government. When the lack of such concepts
and the absence of a system of checks and balances is guaranteed by the
constitution, one branch of government becomes more powerful than the rest
and is more prone to authoritarianism and at times abuse of power.
Granted, people like Akbar Ganji and others like him may come and ruffle
the feathers of the ruling establishment from time to time, but until the
constitution is not changed, NOTHING WILL CHANGE.
A.D.
* Saltanat talab
I am sorry to say that the tone of your article ["Organized
corruption"], I mean, using informal words like, molla, "enemies
of Islam" and such, shows that you have written the article in a nervous,
confused state and the reader gets the sense that you are one of those "Saltanat
Talabhaa" who are absolutely hated by ALL Iranians.
I am also sorry for The Iranian that spreads these kinds of articles,
bringing it's reputation under a big question mark!
Hope all people who love Iran will try to think REALALISTICALLY and IDEALLY,
instead of wasting time, telling old stories that all Iranians are really
tired of hearing.
MB
* Excellent
Excellent article ["Organized
corruption"]. I always enjoy reading your commentaries, and articles.
Have you thought of writing an article as to why the Iranian people always
look for an strong leader to follow blindly?
Shahryar
* Unusual shallowness
I have always seen at least one reason why an article or story was published
in iranian.com. But this story baffles me ["Just
Breathe"]. It reminds me of stories that were published in "Zan-e
Rooz". Actualy I take that back, those stories always had some adventure
in them. I guess both have an unusual sense of shallowness.
The introduction
to this story is much more interesting than the story itself. I am not
a professional criticque, but I bet this peice of writting lacks most of
the required structure of what makes a story. Again, it's more of a shallow
essay than a story. Maybe it is fitting of Tehrangeles.
B.
* Provoking expression
I read the letters in response to your article about "Not
without my mom". I must say at the time when I read the article
I did not think too much of it and did think it was rather childish. But
now that I have read the responses I must congratulate you in achieving
what every editor/journalist in my opinion should aim for; "provocation
of expression of opinion".
It is nice to belong to a nation that has so much feeling to express
even if a great deal of it has to come from their guts. I look forward to
reading more outraged letters in response to your future articles.
Saied Ghazi
* If we could be more tolerant
After reading several letters in this section I noticed many extreme
words like "I was disgusted ... shame on you..." or "Now
that I read this I don't even want to relate to this magazine" or things
like "a molla is a molla: all Iranians should hate mollas..."
There is a lot of intolerance in the feelings portrayed here. It seems
that we want to stick to one idea, person, or group, and we don't want to
tolerate anything else. I understand the sense of insecurities that we all
feel. However, if we relax our restrictions a bit, respect each other's
opinions, and challenge each other without suppressing our opponents in
thought, then we may achieve better solutions to our problems.
Babak
* Don't apologize
"Oh no!" I thought, "Not a parody on 'Not
without my mom'" BUT, I was glad to see the piece and, hey, maybe
it's not what the mainstream Pahlavi supporters like to see. It was still
FUNNY.
The most important thing is how in the world do you come up with those
pictures? My mother and I stared at Mahvash's
picture for long moments and wondered at history and how amazing life
is, in general.
Keep up the good work and don't write an apology. If we had to shut up
everytime because of objections from the staunch right and its annoyingly
squeeking wheels (that I hope would just rust and come to a screeching halt),
we wouldn't have this free press which serves all FREE MINDED Iranians and
Iranian -Americans. HEY! SHAME ON THE CLOSED MINDS! (That's my slogan for
the year).
Bahar Jaberi
* What's so bad about humor?
I write this in reply to many people who seem to have had the sad experience
of feeling tricked or disrespected with the April Fools article in Iranian.com
["Not
without my mom"].
Come ON people! What is so bad about humorous articles, funny images
and cartoons? After all there are so
many cartoons about chadori women on The Iranian and no one has
ever claimed being disrespected on behalf of all the believers of the chador.
I want to congratulate you on your free medium and wish this one Iranian
publication that seems to be able to stand on its feet without the threat
of being shut down by religious conservatives inside or outside Iran. I
hope it continues its success story!
Sheema Kalbasi
* Taking it so personally
I cannot believe some of these negative responses regarding "Not
without my mom". These people should get a grip; what happened
to their sense of humors??? Why are they taking this JOKE so personally???
Did this prank press a button or what??? I thought this was the funniest
joke I have ever read on your site. Thank you for making me laugh so hard!!!!!!!!
Sayeh Velayati
* Buch of morons
I am totally disappointed in your professionalism in reporting such an
idiotic April Fools story ["Not
without my mom"]. I do not think it one bit funny, I rather think
that is sad that a bunch of idiots and morons are running your newspaper.
Why don't you learn to be more careful of what you're making fun of?
After all there are many Iranians who do wish something major could happen
in Iran for the better of our country.
Hay, "no skin off your nose", after all what an idiot like
you cares what happens to our people in Iran, so long as you can sit on
your fat ass and write BS about Mr. Pahlavi or any other person. Thank you,
And by the way, don't bother sending yours truly any of your BS in the future.
S. J. Jowkar
* Dug your grave
I have respected The Iranian online so much that I have told all my friends
about it, until now, with the article by Shaban Bamokh ["Not
without my mom"]. Your selection is a disgrace and shameful. Please
discontinue my service at once. You have dug your future grave.
Negar Khoshkharam
* Most Iranians are like you
In spite of the fact that I don't have enough time, I had to respond
to your ugly April Fools piece ["Not
without my mom"]. Actually, I was very happy when I saw your email,
because I thought that your news is true. But when I opened the site and
looked at the stupid photo (somebody
who looked like a woman), I found that, again, I have been taken in.
Now, I can understand why Iranians, with such a history and clever people
are in such a disaster. It's a shame that you are Iranian. If you were in
Iran and saw the living conditions of the people you would never have sent
such a stupid message to others.
I think instead of sending such foolish articles to others, you better
think about more important matters. Like why our people are in such a situation?
Why some thieves (akhounda) are governing us in the new millennium?
Why? Because the majority of Iranians are like you, cool. Nothing is
important for them. I wish your newspaper and site were a place for increasing
and improving liberty. Please don't send me such news again.
Behrouz Ehsani Moghaddam
* Best anti-monarchists can come up with?
What a distastefull, unfunny and obnoxious April Fools joke this was
["Not
without my mom"]. Doesn't anyone at your site have the decency
not to publish garbage like this? Is this the best the anti-monarchists
can do these days?
Mr Quincy Irani
* Saved Persepolis, but not Bahais
Ms. Amini's letter, "Saving
Persepolis", brings all patriotic Iranians a great sense of joy
to know of the numerous countrymen who care so much about our heritage.
After reading about Mr. Nosratollah Amini's act of courage I was so overwhelmed
by pride. But that did not last very long. Once again, I was reminded how
our National Front compatriots only reminisce the of part of history that
they want us to remember.
Mr. Amini, a nationalist, did not care to protect the rights of other
religions. National Front leaders never showed any courage to save the lives
of people associated with the Shah or members of Bahai Faith. This is in
sharp contrast to the record of Reza Khan. Reza Khan, later Reza Shah, built
the foundation of a moden state and allowed many Qajar courtiers and religious
minorities participate in serving our Iran >>>
FULL TEXT
H. Michael Jalili
* Veghahat
In response to Fariba Amini's letter, "Saving
Persepolis": After the 1979 revolution, there were some talks about
the destruction of all pre-Islamic monuments (and traditions). But some
of the wiser mollahs like Talleghani stopped this nonsense.
At the top of the list was, of course, Persepolis. But the main move
against Persepolis was organised by Dastgheib (Imam Jomeh of Shiraz) and
not by Khalkhali,
as Ms Amini claims! Khalkhali was in Tehran and was too busy executing people
>>>
FULL TEXT
Babak Babakan
* Adab az keh aamookhti?
Mr. Babak Babakan ["Veghaahat"]:
I don't know who you are and I wish not to know. It seems to me as your
letter indicates, you have lived in a Western democracy for a while. But
you have not learned one bit on how to have a polite dialogue with one of
your compatriots, especially a lady. You use the word "Vaghih"
and assume that I am lying. This line of thought is unacceptable among civilized
people. And I consider myself one civilized person. Let others judge you
>>>
FULL TEXT
Fariba Amini
* You make us look bad
I read your lame excuse for an article ["The
hell with romance"] and here are my comments:
1. Lay off categorizing all Iranian men as being incapable of romantic
behavior. Just because you have difficulties with it doesn't mean we all
do. You know, there are Freudian roots for what you're experiencing, pal.
You should check it out. I am sure it is nothing you don't already know,
but don't be ashamed to admit it.
2. Stop thinking with your other head, and you'll be surprised of the
outcome. That MIGHT happen if you grow up and start thinking with your brain
- chalk doesn't count! >>>
FULL TEXT
Sina Sina
|