The Constitution of Secular Republic of Iran

Share/Save/Bookmark

The Constitution of Secular Republic of Iran
by David ET
02-Feb-2009
 

(This article and discussions are continued in draft 2: //iranian.com/main/blog/david-et/2nd-draft-constitution-secular-republic-iran) 

 

In the earlier series titled  “Iran Constitutions: From Islamic Monarchy to Islamic Republic” I presented in detail the articles of both constitutions and concluded that:

Neither of the two constitutions are secular nor present the needs of Iran and Iranians today…..  However, putting aside the influence and the power of the Shia Clergy in both constitutions, one can not deny the evolutionary trend from the ultimate Monarchy to constitutional Monarchy in 1906 to a Republic in 1979 within the past 100+ years of Iranian history………The next step for Iranians in their political evolution is to completely remove religion from the texts of their future constitution”

Bearing that in mind and as a first step, here I have attempted to revise the existing constitution of Iran from an Islamic Republic to a secular republic.

The result is not intended be final but an important step in to creating a possible secular alternative available in future studies and formation of Iran’s constitution.

Here are some areas that the resulting constitution may lack or need improvement:

The secular constitution same as it the previous two constitution does not address potential Federalism which will need to be discussed in future and if necessary put in to provincial referendums.  Although the following secular constitution provides means for election of provincial councils and governors, however it does come short of determination of internal affairs of each province. It is important to note that if Iran ends up to be a Federal government, all the provinces and states, their governors and councils remain to be secular in internal affairs and fully committed to the territorial integrity and the constitution of the country.

The written constitution is in English due to author’s lack of access and knowledge of typing in Persian fonts. In the event this constitution ever gets translated there are two main points to remember that although it was derived from the constitution of Islamic Republic, but in addition to deletions of many of its parts such as Supreme Leader, Guardian Council and all of its religion based articles, in many areas the words and sentences were changed, edited, revised, deleted or added to comply with the author’s original intent which is stated in the preamble. I do hope that professional translators or lawyers or a team of Iranian law and English students as part of their school project take the task of translating this draft and to also post it on internet.

In research for other drafted constitutions, I came across few other constitutions which although with flaws but they also contain many positive points worth studying.

It is important to note that prior constitutions of Iran were shaped after constitutions of other countries but at this stage I believe since many articles of prior constitutions have already been tested , instead of revamping the whole existing system which usually end up in chaos and abuse by those who seek power in a vacuum, the future revised constitution can simply reform the existing working systems within the country.

Although the recent constitutions of neighboring Iraq and Afghanistan were formed during occupation by foreign forces and under totally different circumstances but the experience of the two countries as well as the Iranian revolutions of 1906 and 1979 are all proofs that in political vacuums usually the organized  religious and ideological forms take over, therefore it is important to be prepared with implementation of at least interim laws and a constitution that do not allow religious, ideological and autonomic control of the country’s future government and its future constitution.

In conclusion , here are few important suggestions to the readers:

Preamble of the constitution is important in understanding its intent

Reading the constitution in its entirety is important before drawing any conclusions because some areas of concern in one article may have been addressed at a different section.

This constitution may not be perfect but it has addressed the main issues of concern .

If the reader does not believe in a system of republic for future Iran, s/he still can  find many common areas of interest.

The future flag of Iran probably will be determined by the parliament, however the author has offered two options where in addition to the  Green, While and Red the following symbol is placed in center of the flag :

Lion and Sun without the sword    //www.geocities.com/hammihanirani/flag.jpg 

or :  Cyrus the Great (Kourosh) Cylinder containing the First Declaration of Human Rights (see top of the article)

Other relevant reading materials by author:

Iran Constitutions: From Islamic Monarchy to Islamic republic:

//iranian.com/main/blog/david-et/iran-constitutions-islamic-monarchy-islamic-republic-i-ii

Referendum Rabits:

//iranian.com/main/blog/david-et/referendum-rabbits

Solutions for Iran:

//iranian.com/main/blog/david-et/solutions-iran-road-map-unity-days

* * *

 Previous Constitutions of Iran:

1906/1907 Iran Monarchy Constitution:   Persian   English

//fa.wikisource.org/wiki/%D9%85%D8%AA%D9%86_%D9%82%D8%A7%D9%86%D9%88%D9%86_%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%A7%D8%B3%DB%8C_%D9%85%D8%B4%D8%B1%D9%88%D8%B7%D9%87_%D9%88_%D9%85%D8%AA%D9%85%D9%85_%D8%A2%D9%86  (Persian)

//en.wikisource.org/wiki/Iranian_Constitution_of_1906    (English)

1979 Islamic Republic Constitution:

//mellat.majlis.ir/CONSTITUTION/PERSIAN.HTM  (Persian)

//www.iranchamber.com/government/laws/constitution.php  (English)

* * *

Other drafted Iranian constitutions available on internet :

Iran Constitution Drafted by Kaveh Shirzad (Persian) //www.ghandchi.com/IONA/ConstShirzad.htm

Iran Constitution Drafted by Binesh Novin (Persian) //cfiwest.org/newhorizons/constitution/1.htm

Iran Constitution Drafted by Ardeshir Dolat (Persian) //www.ghandchi.com/IONA/ConstitutionModel.htm

Persian Constitution by Bahram Maskanian (English)  //www.venusproject.com/ecs/persian_constitution_chart.html

PRE-DRAFT

The Constitution of Secular Republic of Iran

PREAMBLE

We the people of Iran believe in the following principals: 

Territorial Integrity

We are one nation comprised of different regions, religions, cultures and languages. We proudly believe in and defend the territorial integrity of our ancient country Iran. Our government of the people shall not compromise the territorial integrity of our country.

Independence:

We determine our own destiny independently. Our country shall remain independent of any foreign forces. Our government of the people shall maintain our independence free of any foreign influences and controls.  We the people of Iran and our government shall respect the independence and integrity of other countries and shall not engage in internal affairs of other nations. Our government shall promote peace with all nations and countries of the world.

Separation of Religion and State:

We the people of Iran mutually respect our different religions and personal beliefs. Our government of the people will remain separate from any religious institutions and influences and shall not promote or oppose any specific religions or personal beliefs.

Freedom of Expression:

We the people of Iran have the right to openly express our views and opinions. Our government of the people shall provide all safety and securities for open and free exchange of views and opinions and it may not violate the rights to freedom of expression under any pretext or circumstances.

Gender Equality:

We the people of Iran, male and female are equal and have equal rights. Our government of the people shall provide all safety and securities to assure that gender equality is fully exercised and implemented

Human Rights:

We the people of Iran respect human rights and our government of the people shall assure that the human rights of all Iranians are respected and defended and it shall not violate our human rights under any pretext. Our government of the people shall comply with the basic principals of Universal Declaration of Human Rights, International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Convention on the Rights of the Child. 

Chapter I
General Principles


Article 1


The form of government of Iran is that of a Secular Republic.

Article 2


The Republic of Iran is a system based on beliefs in:

  1. Territorial Integrity, Independence and Sovereignty of Iran.
  2. Government of The People, By the People and For the People
  3. Full separation of Religion and State at all levels without any exceptions
  4. Freedom of Expression and Assembly
  5. Justice and fairness in legislations
  6. Implementation of the constitution and just laws
  7. Gender Equality
  8. Full respect for Human Rights.


Article 3

The government of Republic of Iran has the duty of directing all its resources to the following goals:

  1. The creation of a favorable environment for the achievement of the above principals.
  2. Raising the level of public awareness of above principals in all areas, through the proper use of the press, mass media, and other means;
  3. Free education and physical training for everyone at all levels, and the facilitation and expansion of career training and higher education;
  4. Strengthening the spirit of inquiry, investigation, and innovation in all areas of science, technology, and culture, by establishing research centers and encouraging researchers;
  5. The complete elimination of religion at all levels of government affairs of the country;
  6. The elimination of all forms of despotism and autocracy and all attempts to monopolize power;
  7. Ensuring political and social freedoms within the frameworks of the law;
  8. The participation of the entire people in determining their political, economic, social, and cultural destiny;
  9. The abolition of all forms of undesirable discrimination and the provision of equitable opportunities for all, in both the material and intellectual spheres;
  10. The creation of a correct administrative system and elimination of superfluous government organizations;
  11. Strengthening of the foundations of national defense by means of universal military training for the sake of safeguarding the independence, severity and the territorial integrity of Iran and maintaining peace with all nations and countries;
  12. The planning of a just economic system, in order to eliminate poverty and abolish all forms of deprivation with respect to food, housing, work, health care, and the provision of social insurance for all;
  13. The attainment of self-sufficiency in scientific, technological, industrial, agricultural, defense domains, and other similar spheres;
  14. Securing the multifarious rights of all citizens, both women and men, and providing legal protection for all, as well as the equality of-all before the law;
  15. Lack of intervention in the affairs of other nations except within the scope of  coordination with the United Nations
  16. Framing the internal and foreign policy of the country on the basis of peace with all nations of the world.

Article 4

In the Secular Republic of Iran, the affairs of the country must be administered on the basis of public opinion expressed by the means of elections, including the election of the President, the representatives of the National Consultative Assembly

(Parliament), members of Provincial Councils of governors, Provincial, City, Region, District and Village Councils, governors, mayors and alike or by means of referenda in matters specified in other articles of this Constitution.

Article 5

The Provincial Councils, the City, Region, District, and Village Councils and the likes of them - are the decision-making and administrative organs of the country. The nature of each of these councils, together with the manner of their formation, their jurisdiction, and scope of their duties and functions, is determined by the Constitution and laws derived from it.

Article 6

In the Republic of Iran, the freedom, independence, unity, and territorial integrity of the country are inseparable from one another, and their preservation is the duty of the government and all individual citizens. No individual, group, or authority, has the right to infringe upon the independence or territorial integrity of Iran under the pretext of exercising freedom. Similarly, no authority has the right to abrogate legitimate freedoms, not even by enacting laws and regulations for that purpose, under the pretext of preserving the independence and territorial integrity of the country.

Article 7

Since the family is the fundamental unit of society, all laws, regulations, and pertinent programs must tend to facilitate the formation of a family, childcare and to safeguard the stability of family relations and children rights.

Article 8

The government of Iran is secular and there shall be no official religions or ideologies. The government of Iran shall remain independent of any religious institutions and influences. Government shall not promote any specific religions, ideologies or personal beliefs. In order to secure the Separation of religion and the state, the secular constitution of Iran strictly prohibits participation of any religious based groups and parties in all local, regional, provincial and national institutions of the government. This would also extend to anyone who holds a religious title or leadership, clergy and alike. Religion and religious groups will have freedom to practice their religion peacefully. Individuals within the government may have personal religious preferences but they can not enforce any religious laws and restrictions.

Article 9

Secular republic of Iran observes no official religions for the country, however believes in affirmation action to assure religious minorities with large populations in Iran have proper political representation and seats in the parliament. Secular in nature, everyone in Iran is treated the same, regardless of their religion or lack of it. All religions within the limits of the law and without limiting the guaranteed individual rights within the constitution are free to perform their religious rights, and to act according to their own canon in matters of personal affairs.  

Chapter II
The Official Language, Script, Calendar, and Flag of the Country



Article 10

The official language and script of Iran is Persian. Official documents, correspondence, and texts, as well as text-books, must be in this language and script with the goal of minimizing the use of foreign words including Arabic. In addition to Persian, the right to use regional and tribal languages in the press and mass media, as well as teaching of their literature in schools is protected.

Article 11

The official calendar of the country starts its year count , on the year of the declaration of human rights by King Cyrus the Great (2548 years ago) .Government offices will function according to the solar calendar with Iranian months starting the year on the first day of the spring (1st day of Farvardin) . The official weekly holiday is Friday.

Article 12

The official flag of Iran is composed of green, white and red colors with an emblem in its center to be determined by the Parliament.

(Author suggestion: Cyrus the great 1st article of human rights cylinder or Lion and Sun without sword )

Chapter III
The Rights of the People



Article 13

All the people of Iran, whatever ethnic group or tribe to which they belong, enjoy equal rights. Color, race, language, religion, gender and the like, do not bestow any privilege.

Article 14

All citizens of the country, both men and women, equally enjoy the protection of the law and equally enjoy all human, political, economic, social, and cultural rights.

Article 15

The government must ensure the rights of women in all respects and accomplish the following goals:

  1. Protecting and promoting equal rights with men in all areas of individual, family, social and government.
  2. The protection of mothers, particularly during pregnancy and childbearing, and the protection of children and their rights;
  3. Establishing competent courts to protect and preserve the family and the legal rights of both parents.
  4. The awarding of guardianship of children to qualified families, in order to protect the interests of the children, in the absence of a legal guardian.

Article 16


The dignity, human life, property, rights, residence, and occupation of the individual may not be violated.  

Article 17


The investigation of individuals' beliefs is forbidden, and no one may be molested or taken to task simply for holding a certain belief.

Article 18


Publications and the press have freedom of expression within the provisions of the law.

Article 19


Examination of the contents of, and non-delivery of , letters; recording and divulging of telephone conversations; disclosure of all forms of communications such as emails, telex facsimile communications; censorship, pruning or non-transmission of messages; tapping and bugging are all forbidden, unless when so ordered by the law in criminal matters .

Article 20


Political parties, societies, trade unions and religious associations may freely be formed within the scopes of law. No person may be prevented from joining, or compelled to join, one of the above.

Article 21

Unarmed assemblies and marches may freely be organized, and permits must be issued by the government.

Article 22

Every person is entitled to choose the employment he wishes, so long as it is not contrary to the rights of others. The Government is bound to create the possibility of obtaining employment and equal opportunities. 

Article 23


Every person is entitled to the enjoyment of Social Security. This covers retirement, unemployment, disability, being without a guardian, temporary disability, accidents, and occurrences giving rise to the need for universal health services, medical care and treatment and medicine through insurance. The Government is bound, in accordance with the laws, to use public revenues and the revenue drawn from individual contributions to provide the services and financial support mentioned above for every citizen of the country.

Article 24


The Government is bound to make available, free of charge, educational facilities for all through high school and technical schools, and to expand free facilities for higher education and career training up to the limits of the country's own needs and capacity.

Article 25


Every Iranian individual and family is entitled to a dwelling appropriate to need.  

Article 26


No person may be arrested except according to and in the manner laid down in the law. If someone is detained, the subject matter of the charge, with reasons (for bringing it), must immediately be communicated and explained in writing to the accused. Within at most 24 hours the file on the case and preliminary documentation must be referred to the competent legal authority. Legal procedures must be initiated as early as possible. Anyone infringing this principle will be punished in accordance with the law.

Article 27


No person may be ousted from his residence, or forbidden to reside in the locality of his choice, or compelled to reside in a particular locality, unless the law prescribes this.

Article 28


To ask for justice is the undeniable right of every individual. Everyone must be referred to the competent courts in search of justice. All members of the nation are entitled to have recourse to such courts within their reach. No one may be prevented from recourse to any court to which the law entitles to refer.

Article 29


In all courts, both parties to the claim are entitled to select a lawyer for themselves. If they do not have the capacity to do this, the means of a lawyer being appointed to act for them must be made available.

Article 30


A sentence to punishment and its execution must only be by the decision of a competent court, and by the virtue of law.

Article 31


Innocence is the basic principle.  No person is considered legally guilty, except after the guilt is established in a competent court.

Article 32

Any kind of torture used to extract an admission of guilt or to obtain information is forbidden. Compelling people to give evidence, or confess or take an oath is not allowed. Such evidence or confession or oath is null and void. Any person infringing this principle is to be punished in accordance with the law.

Article 33

Aspersion of the dignity of and respect due to any person who has been arrested or put in detention, or imprisoned by command of the law is forbidden in any form, and is liable for punishment.

Article 34

No person may exercise his own rights as means of constraining others or violating the public interest.

Article 35

Citizenship of Iran is the unquestioned right of all Iranians. The Government may not deprive any Iranian of his citizenship, except at their own request.

Article 36

Foreign nationals may within the limits of the law take up Iranian citizenship or permanent residency.

Chapter IV
Economy and Financial Affairs


Article 37


The economy of the Republic of Iran, with its objectives of achieving the economic independence of the society, uprooting poverty and deprivation, and fulfilling human needs in the process of development while preserving human liberty, is based on the following criteria:

  1. The provision of the basic necessities for all citizens: housing, food, clothing, hygiene, medical treatment, education, and the necessary facilities for the establishment of healthy individuals and families
  2. Ensuring conditions and opportunities of employment for everyone, with a view to attaining full employment; placing the means of work at the disposal of everyone who is able to work but lacks the means, in the form of cooperatives, through granting interest-free loans or recourse to any other legitimate means that neither results in the concentration or circulation of wealth in the hands of a few individuals or groups, nor turns the government into a major absolute employer. These steps must be taken with due regard for the requirements governing the general economic planning of the country at each stage of its growth;
  3. The plan for the national economy, must be structured in such a manner that the form, content, and hours of work of every individual will allow sufficient leisure and energy to engage, beyond professional endeavor, in intellectual, political, and social activities leading to all-round development of self, to take active part in leading the affairs of the country, improve skills, and to make full use of his creativity;
  4. Respect for the right to choose freely one's occupation; refraining from compelling anyone to engage in a particular job; and preventing the exploitation of another's labor;
  5. The prohibition of infliction of harm and loss upon others, monopoly, hoarding, usury, and other illegitimate practices;
  6. The prohibition of extravagance and wastefulness in all matters related to the economy, including consumption, investment, production, distribution, and services;
  7. The utilization of science and technology, and the training of skilled personnel in accordance with the developmental needs of the country's economy;
  8. Protection of a healthy environment in all land, air and water.
  9. Prevention of foreign economic domination over the country's economy;
  10. Emphasis on increase of agricultural, livestock, industrial and technological production in order to satisfy public needs and to make the country self-sufficient and free from dependence.

Article 38

The economy of the Republic of Iran is to consist of three sectors: state, cooperative, and private, and is to be based on systematic and sound planning. State sector include national resources and facilities such as oil, gas, water, power, major minerals, roads, railroads, central treasury, primary central bank, primary television and radio station(s). The precise scope of each of these sectors, as well as the regulations and conditions governing their operation, will be specified by law.

Airwaves of the country are public and can be used by private Radio, Television and other communication services by permission of the government. Foreign governments may not broadcast within the boundaries of Iran.

Article 39

Public wealth and property, such as uncultivated or abandoned land, mineral deposits, seas, lakes, rivers and other public water-ways, mountains, valleys, forests, marshlands, natural forests, unenclosed pastures, legacies without heirs, property of undetermined ownership, and public property recovered from usurpers, shall be at the disposal of the government for it to utilize in accordance with the public interest. Law will specify detail procedures for the utilization of each of the foregoing items.

Article 40

Everyone is the owner of the fruits of his or her legitimate business and labor, and no one may deprive another of the opportunity of business and work under the pretext of his right to ownership.

Article 41

Private ownership, legitimately acquired, is to be respected

Article 42

There must be no discrimination among the various provinces with regard to the exploitation of natural resources, utilization of public revenues, and distribution of economic activities among the various provinces and regions of the country, thereby ensuring that every region has access to the necessary capital and facilities in accordance with its needs and capacity for growth.

Article 43

The government has the responsibility of confiscating all wealth accumulated through usury, usurpation, bribery, embezzlement, theft, gambling, misuse of endowments, misuse of government contracts and transactions, the sale of uncultivated lands and other resources subject to public ownership, and other illicit means and sources, and restoring it to its legitimate owner; and if no such owner can be identified, it must be entrusted to the public treasury. This rule must be executed by the government with due care, after investigation and by furnishing necessary evidence in accordance with the law.

Article 44

The preservation of the environment, in which the present as well as the future generations have a right to flourishing social existence, is regarded as a public and government responsibility. Economic and other activities that inevitably involve pollution of the environment or cause irreparable damage to it are therefore forbidden.

Article 45

No form of taxation may be imposed except in accordance with the law. Provisions for tax exemption and reduction will be determined by law.

Article 46

The annual budget of the country will be planned by the government, in the manner specified by law, and submitted to the National Consultative Assembly for discussion and approval. Any change in the figures contained in the budget will be in accordance with the procedures prescribed by law.

Article 47
All sums collected by the government will be deposited into the government accounts at the central treasury, and all disbursements, within the limits of allocations approved, shall be made in accordance with law.

Article 48

The National Audit Agency is to be directly under the supervision of the National Consultative Assembly. Its organization and mode of operation in the country’s capital and at the provincial capitals are to be determined by law.

Article 49

The National Audit Agency will inspect and audit, in the manner prescribed by law, all the accounts of ministries, government institutions and companies as well as other organizations that draw, in any way, on the general budget of the country, to ensure that no expenditure exceeds the allocations approved and that all sums are spent for the specified purpose. It will collect all relevant accounts, documents, and records, in accordance with law, and submit to the National Consultative Assembly a report for the settlement of each year's budget together with its own comments. This report must be made available to the public.

Chapter V
The Right of National Sovereignty and the Powers Deriving There from

Article 50

The powers of government in the Republic are vested in the Legislature, the Judiciary, and the Executive powers, in accordance with the forthcoming articles of this Constitution. These powers are independent of each other.

Article 51

The functions of the legislature are to be exercised through the National Consultative Assembly, consisting of the elected representatives of the people. Legislation approved by this body, after going through the stages specified in the articles below, is communicated to the executive and the judiciary for implementation.

Article 52

In extremely important economic, political, social, and cultural matters, the function of the Legislature may be exercised through direct recourse to popular vote by a referendum. Any request for such direct recourse to public opinion must be approved by two-thirds of the members of National Consultative Assembly.

Article 53

The functions of the Executive are to be exercised by the president and the ministers.

Article 54

The function of the Judiciary are to be performed by courts of justice, which are to be formed in accordance with the articles of law, and are vested with the authority to examine and settle lawsuits, protect the rights of the public, dispense and enact justice.

Chapter VI
the Legislative Power

Section One
National Consultative Assembly


Article 55

The National Consultative Assembly is constituted by the representatives of the people elected directly and by secret ballot. The qualifications of voters and candidates, as well as the nature of election, will be specified by law.

Article 56

The term of membership in the National Consultative Assembly is four years. Elections for each term must take place before the end of the preceding term, so that the country is never without a National Consultative Assembly.

Article 57

There are to be two hundred seventy members of the National Consultative Assembly which keeping in view the human, political, geographic and other similar factors, may increase by not more than twenty for each ten-year period. The Sunni Muslims, Zoroastrians, Jews , Bahai’s, Christians, Armenians of north and south of  Iran are each affirmed political representatives based on their percentage of population but no less than one for each. The limits of the election constituencies and the number of representatives will be determined by law.

Article 58

After holding of elections, the sessions of the National Consultative Assembly are considered legally valid when two-thirds of the total number of members are present. Drafts and bills will be approved in accordance with the code of procedure approved by it, except in cases where the Constitution has specified a certain quorum. The consent of two-thirds of all members present is necessary for the approval of the code of procedure of the Parliament.

Article 59

The manner of election of the Speaker and the Presiding Board of the National Consultative Assembly, the number of committees and their term of office, and matters related to conducting the discussions and maintaining the discipline of the Assembly will be determined by the codes of procedure of the Assembly.

Article 60

Members of the Assembly must take the following oath at the first session of the Assembly and affix their signatures to its text: I swear, by my own honor as a human being, to protect, as a just trustee, the honor bestowed upon me by the people, to observe piety in fulfilling my duties as people's representative; to remain always committed to the independence and honor of the country; to fulfill my duties towards the nation and the service of the people; to defend the Constitution; and to bear in mind, both in speech and writing and in the expression of my views, the independence of the country, the freedom of the people, and the security of their interests.

The use of the word God by the elected representatives and putting their left hand on their own sacred books while taking this oath is optional.

Members not attending the first session will perform the ceremony of taking the oath at the first session they attend.

Article 61

If the elections are not possible to be held in the time of war and the military occupation of the country, elections due to be held in occupied areas or country may be delayed for a specified period if proposed by the President of the Republic, and approved by three-fourths of the total members of the National Consultative Assembly. Until the new Assembly is formed, the previous one will continue to function.

Article 62

The deliberations of the National Consultative Assembly must be open and full minutes of them made available to the public by radio, television, internet and the official gazette. A closed session may be held in emergency conditions, if it is required for national security, upon the requisition of the President, one of the ministers, or ten members of the Assembly. Legislation passed at a closed session is valid only when approved by three-fourths of the members. After emergency conditions have ceased to exist, the minutes of such closed sessions, together with any legislation approved in them, must be made available to the public.

Article 63

The President, deputies and the ministers have the right to participate in the open sessions of the Assembly either collectively or individually. They may also have their advisers accompany them. If the members of the Assembly deem it necessary, the ministers are obliged to attend, whenever they request it, their statements are to be heard.

Section Two
Powers and Authority of the National Consultative Assembly


Article 64

The National Consultative Assembly can establish laws on all matters, within the limits of its competence as laid down in the Constitution.

Article 65

The National Consultative Assembly cannot enact laws contrary to the Constitution. 

Article 66

The interpretation of ordinary laws falls within the competence of the National Consultative Assembly. The intent of this Article does not prevent the interpretations that judges may make in the course of cassation.

Article 67

Government bills are presented to the National Consultative Assembly after receiving the approval of the Council of Ministers. Members' bills may be introduced in the National Consultative Assembly if sponsored by at least fifteen members.

Article 68

Members' bills and proposals and amendments to government’s bills proposed by members that entail the reduction of the public income or the increase of public expenditure may be introduced in the Assembly only if means for compensating for the decrease in income or for meeting the new expenditure are also specified.

Article 69

The National Consultative Assembly has the right to investigate and examine all the affairs of the country.

Article 70

International treaties, protocols, contracts, and agreements must be approved by the National Consultative Assembly.

Article 71

All changes in the boundaries of the country are forbidden, with the exception of minor amendments in keeping with the interests of the country, on condition that they are not unilateral, do not encroach on the independence and territorial integrity of the country, and receive the approval of four-fifths of the total members of the National Consultative Assembly.

Article 72

The proclamation of martial law is forbidden. In case of war or emergency conditions only akin to war, the president has the right to impose temporarily certain necessary restrictions, but only with the agreement of the four fifth of the National Consultative Assembly. In no case can such restrictions last for more than thirty days; if the need for them persists beyond this limit, the government must obtain new authorization from the Assembly.

Article 73

The taking and giving of loans or grants-in-aid, domestic and foreign, by the government, must be approved by the National Consultative Assembly.

Article 74

The granting of concessions to foreigners for the formation of companies or institutions dealing with commerce, industry, agriculture, services or mineral extraction, is absolutely forbidden.

Article 75

Government buildings and properties forming part of the national heritage cannot be transferred except with the approval of the National Consultative Assembly and the president; that too, is not applicable in the case of irreplaceable treasures.

Article 76

Every representative is responsible to the entire nation and has the right to express his views on all internal and external affairs of the country.

Article 77

The right of membership is vested with the individual, and is not transferable to others. The Assembly cannot delegate the power of legislation to an individual or committee. But whenever necessary, it can delegate the power of legislating certain laws to its own committees. In such cases, the laws will be implemented on a tentative basis for a period specified by the Assembly, and their final approval will-rest with the Assembly. Likewise, the Assembly may, delegate to the relevant committees the responsibility for permanent approval of articles of association of organizations, companies, government institutions, or organizations affiliated to the government and or invest the authority in the government. The government approvals shall not be against the laws and other general rules of the country and, while calling for implementation, the same shall be brought to the knowledge of the Speaker of the National Consultative Assembly for his study and indication that the approvals in question are not inconsistent with the aforementioned rules.

Article 78

Members of the Assembly are completely free in expressing their views and casting their votes in the course of performing their duties as representatives, and they cannot be prosecuted or arrested for opinions expressed in the Assembly or votes casts in the course of performing their duties as representatives.

Article 79

The President must obtain, for the Council of Ministers, after being formed and before all other business, a vote of confidence from the Assembly. During his incumbency, he can also seek a vote of confidence for the Council of Ministers from the Assembly on important and controversial issues.

Article 80

Whenever at least one-fourth of the total members of the National Consultative Assembly pose a question to the President, or a minister on a subject relating to their duties, the President or the minister is obliged to attend the Assembly and answer the question. This answer must not be delayed more than 30 days in the case of the President and ten days in the case of the minister, except with an excuse deemed reasonable by the National Consultative Assembly.

Article 81

  1. Members of the National Consultative Assembly can interrogate the Council of Ministers or an individual minister in instances they deem necessary. Interrogation can be scheduled if they bear the signatures of at least one-fifth of the members. The Council of Ministers or interrogated minister must be present in the Assembly within ten days after the scheduling of the interrogation in order to answer it and seek a vote of confidence. If the Council of Ministers or the minister concerned fails to attend the Assembly, the members who scheduled the interrogation will explain their reasons, and the Assembly has the option to declare a vote of no-confidence if it deems it necessary. If the Assembly does not pronounce a vote of confidence, the Council of Ministers or the minister subject to interrogation is dismissed. In both cases, the ministers subject to interrogation cannot become members of the next Council of Ministers formed immediately afterwards.
  2. In the event at least one-third of the members of the National Consultative Assembly interrogate the President concerning his executive responsibilities in relation with the Executive Power and the executive affairs of the country, the President must be present in the Assembly within one month after the vote of the interrogation in order to give adequate explanations in regard to the matters raised. After hearing the statements of the opposing and favoring members and the reply of the President, two-thirds of the members of the Assembly are required to obtain a vote of no confidence.

Article 82

Whoever has a complaint concerning the work of the Assembly or the executive power, or the judicial power can forward his/her complaint in writing to the Assembly. The Assembly must investigate his complaint and give a satisfactory reply. In cases where the complaint relates to the executive or the judiciary, the Assembly must demand proper investigation in the matter and an adequate explanation from them, and announce the results within a reasonable time. In cases where the subject of the complaint is of public interest, the reply must be made public.

Chapter VII
Councils

Article 83


In order to expedite social, economic, development, public health, cultural, and educational programs and facilitate other affairs relating to public welfare with the cooperation of the people according to local needs, the administration of each village, division, city, municipality, and province will be supervised by a council to be named the Village, Division, City, Municipality, or Provincial Council. Members of each of these councils will be elected by the people of the locality in question. Qualifications for the eligibility of electors and candidates for these councils, as well as their functions and powers, the mode of election, the jurisdiction of these councils, the hierarchy of their authority, will be determined by law, in such a way as to preserve national unity, territorial integrity, the Republic of Iran, and the sovereignty of the central government.

Article 84


In order to prevent discrimination in the preparation of programs for the development and welfare of the provinces, to secure the cooperation of the people, and to arrange for the supervision of coordinated implementation of such programs, a Supreme Council of the Provinces will be formed, composed of representatives of the Provincial Councils. Law will specify the manner in which this council is to be formed and the functions that it is to fulfill.

Article 85


The Supreme Council of the Provinces has the right within its jurisdiction to draft bills and to submit them to the National Consultative Assembly, either directly or through the government. These bills must be examined by the Assembly.

Article 86


Provincial governors, city mayors, divisional governors, and other officials, also elected by the people every four years must abide by all decisions taken by the councils within their jurisdiction. The election dates for provinces, cities, divisions and villages are every four years and determined by the council.

Article 87


In order to ensure equity and cooperation in chalking out the programs and to bring about the harmonious progress of all units of production, both industrial and agricultural, councils consisting of the representatives of the workers, farmers, other employees, and managers, will be formed in educational and administrative units, units of service industries, and other units of a like nature, similar councils will be formed, composed of representatives of the members of those units. The mode of the formation of these councils and the scope of their functions and powers, are to be specified by law.

Article 88

Decisions taken by the councils must not be contrary to the criteria of Constitution and the laws of the country.

Article 89


The councils may not be dissolved unless they deviate from their legal duties. The body responsible for determining such deviation, as well as the manner for dissolving the councils and re-forming them, will be specified by law. Should a council have any objection to its dissolution, it has the right to appeal to a competent court, and the court is duty-bound to examine its complaint outside the docket sequence.

Chapter IIX

The Executive Power

Section One
The Presidency


Article 90


The President is the highest official in the country. His is the responsibility for implementing the Constitution and acting as the head of the executive.

Article 91

The President is the commander of all armed forces

Article 92


The President is elected for a four-year term by the direct vote of the people. His re-election for a second term is permissible only once.

Article 93


The President must be elected from individuals possessing the following qualifications: Iranian parents; born in Iran, Iranian nationality; no prior criminal or fraud record; belief in the constitution of the Secular Republic of Iran.

Article 94


Candidates nominated for the post of President must declare their candidature officially. Law lays down the manner in which the President is to be elected.

Article 95


The President is elected by an absolute majority of votes polled by the voters. But if none of the candidates is able to win such a majority in the first round, voting will take place a second time the second Friday after the results were announced. In the second round only the two candidates who received the most number of votes in the first round will participate. If, however, some of the candidates securing most votes in the first round withdraw from the elections, the final choice will be between the two candidates who won greater number of votes than all the remaining candidates.

Article 96


Responsibility for the supervision of the election of the President to be constituted by law.

Article 97


The election of a new President must take place no later than two months before the end of the term of the outgoing President. In the interim period before the election of the new President and the end of the term of the outgoing President, the outgoing President will perform the duties of the President.

Article 98


In case any of the candidates whose suitability is established in terms of the qualifications listed above should die within ten days before polling day, the elections will be postponed for two weeks. If one of the candidates securing greatest number of votes dies in the intervening period between the first and second rounds of voting, the period for holding (the second round of) the election will be extended for two weeks.

Article 99


The President must take the following oath and affix his signature to it at a session of the National Consultative Assembly in the presence of the head of the judicial power

"In the presence of the people of Iran, I swear that I will guard the constitution of the Secular Republic of Iran; that I will devote all my capacities and abilities to the fulfillment of the responsibilities that I have assumed; that I will dedicate myself to the service of the people, the honor of the country, and the support of truth and justice. I will protect the freedom and dignity of all citizens and the rights that the Constitution of the secular republic of Iran has accorded the people; in protecting the frontiers and the political, economic, and cultural independence of the country, I will guard the authority vested in me by the people as a sacred trust, and peacefully transfer all the power to whomever the people may elect after me."

Article 100

The President, within the limits of his powers and duties, which he has by virtue of this Constitution or other laws, is responsible to the people and the National Consultative Assembly.

Article 101

The President is obliged to sign legislation approved by the Assembly or the result of a referendum, after the related legal procedures have been completed and it has been communicated to him. After signing, he must forward it to the responsible authorities for implementation.

Article 102

The President may have deputies for the performance of his constitutional duties. With the approval of the President, the first deputy of the President shall be vested with the responsibilities of administering the affairs of the Council of Ministers and coordination of functions of other deputies.

Article 103

The President or his legal representative has the authority to sign treaties, protocols, contracts, and agreements concluded by the Iranian government with other governments, as well as agreements pertaining to international organizations, after obtaining the approval of the National Consultative Assembly.

Article 104

The President is responsible for national planning, budget, employment affairs and may entrust the administration of these to others.

Article 105

In special circumstances, subject to approval of the Council of Ministers, the President may appoint one or more special representatives with specific powers. In such cases, the decisions of his representative(s) will be considered as the same as those of the President and the Council of Ministers.

Article 106

The ambassadors shall be appointed upon the recommendation of the foreign minister and approval of the President. The President signs the credentials of ambassadors and also receives the credentials presented by the ambassadors of the foreign countries.

Article 107

The award of national medals and decorations is a prerogative of the President.

Article 108

The President shall submit his resignation to the National Consultative Assembly and shall continue performing his duties until his resignation is accepted and his duties are assigned to first deputy or until the new president is elected.

Article 109

In case of death, dismissal, resignation, absence, or illness lasting longer than two months of the President, or when his term in office has ended and a new president has not been elected due to some impediments, or similar other circumstances, his first deputy shall assume, the powers and functions of the President. The Council, consisting of the Speaker of the National Consultative Assembly, head of the judicial power, and the first deputy of the President, is obliged to arrange for a new President to be elected within a maximum period of fifty days. In case of death of the first deputy to the President, or other matters which prevent him to perform his duties, or when the President does not have a first deputy, the Speaker of the Assembly shall assume this responsibility until, election.

Article 110

During the period when the powers and responsibilities of the President are assigned to his first deputy or the other person in accordance with Article 131, neither can the ministers be impeached nor can a vote of no-confidence be passed against them. Also, neither can any step be undertaken for a review of the Constitution, nor a national referendum is held.

Section Two
The President and the Ministers


Article 111

Ministers will be appointed by the President and will be presented to the Assembly for a vote of confidence. With the change of Assembly, a new vote of confidence will not be necessary. The number of ministers and the jurisdiction of each will be determined by law.

Article 112

The President is the head of the Council of Ministers. He supervises the work of the ministers and takes all necessary measures to coordinate the decisions of the government. With the cooperation of the ministers, he determines the program and policies of the government and implements the laws. In the case of discrepancies, or interference in the constitutional duties of the government agencies, the decision of the Council of Ministers at the request of the President shall be binding provided it does not call for an interpretation of or modification in the laws. The President is responsible to the Assembly for the actions of the Council of Ministers.

Article 113

The ministers shall continue in office unless they are dismissed, or given a vote of no-confidence by the Assembly as a result of their impeachments, or a motion for a vote of no-confidence against them.

The resignation of the Council of Ministers, or that of each of them shall be submitted to the President, and the Council of Ministers shall continue to function until such time as the new government is appointed.

The President can appoint a caretaker for a maximum period of three months for the ministries having no minister.

Article 114

The President can dismiss the ministers and in such a case he must obtain a vote of confidence for the new minister(s) from the Assembly.

Article 115

Each of the ministers is responsible for his duties to the President and the Assembly, but in matters approved by the Council of Ministers as a whole, he is also responsible for the actions of the others.

Article 116

In addition to instances in which the Council of Ministers or a single minister is authorized to frame procedures for the implementation of laws, the Council of Ministers has the right to lay down rules, regulations, and procedures for performing its administrative duties, ensuring the implementation of laws, and setting up administrative bodies. Each of the ministers also has the right to frame regulations and issue circular in matters within its jurisdiction and in conformity with the decisions of the Council of Ministers. However, the content of all such regulations must not violate the letter or the spirit of the law. The government can entrust any portion of its task to the commissions composed of some ministers. The decisions of such commissions within the rules will be binding after the endorsement of the President.

The ratification and the regulations of the government and the decisions of the commissions mentioned under this Article shall also be brought to the notice of the Speaker of the National Consultative Assembly while being communicated for implementation so that in the event he finds them contrary to law, he may send the same stating the reason for reconsideration by the Council of Ministers.

Article 117

The settlement, of claims relating to public and state property or the referral thereof to arbitration is in every case dependent on the approval of the Council of Ministers, and the Assembly must be informed of these matters. In cases where one party to the dispute is a foreigner, as well as in important cases that are purely domestic, the approval of the Assembly must also be obtained. Law will specify the important cases intended here.

Article 118

Allegations of common crimes against the President, his deputies, and the ministers will be investigated in common courts of justice with the knowledge of the National Consultative Assembly.

Article 119

The President, the deputies to the President, ministers, and government employees cannot hold more than one government position, and it is forbidden for them to hold any kind of additional post in institutions of which all or a part of the capital belongs to the government or public institutions, to be a member of the National Consultative Assembly, to practice the profession of attorney or legal adviser, or to hold the post of president, managing director, or membership of the board of directors of any kind of private or public company. Teaching positions in universities and research institutions are exempted from this rule.

Article 120

The assets of the President, the deputies to the President, and ministers, as well as those of their spouses and offspring, are to be examined before and after their term of office by the head of the judiciary , in order to ensure they have not increased in a fashion contrary to law. During the term of public service, all of their business trades must be disclosed and subject to investigation.

Section Three
The Army


Article 121

Army of the Republic of Iran is responsible for guarding the independence and territorial integrity of the country, as well as the order of the Republic.

Article 122

The Army of the Republic of Iran must be an secular Army, i.e., only committed to the people, and no religion or ideologies and all the heads of army must be individuals who believe in the objectives of the Secular Republic and are devoted to the cause of realizing its goals.

Article 123

No foreign citizens will be accepted into the Army or security forces of the country.

Article 124

The establishment of any kind of foreign military base in Iran, even for peaceful purposes is forbidden, except the forces of United Nation in specific cases and for limited periods with the approval of the National Consultative Assembly.

Article 125

In time of peace, the government must utilize the personnel and technical equipment of the Army in relief operations, and for educational and productive ends and the Construction, while fully observing the criteria of laws and justice and ensuring that such utilization does not harm the combat-readiness of the Army.

Article 126

All forms of personal use of military vehicles, equipment, and other means, as well as taking advantage of Army personnel as personal servants and personal chauffeurs or in similar capacities, are forbidden.

Article 127

Promotions in military rank and their withdrawal take place in accordance with the law.

Article 128

The government is obliged to provide a six months program of military training, with all requisite facilities, for all its citizens, in such a way that all citizens will always be able to engage in the armed defense of the Republic of Iran. The possession of arms, however, requires the granting of permission by the competent authorities. 

Chapter IX

Foreign Policy

Article 129

The foreign policy of the Republic of Iran is based upon the rejection of all forms of domination with the goal of the preservation of the independence of the country in all respects and its territorial integrity and the maintenance of mutually peaceful relations with all nations.

Article 130

Any form of agreement resulting in foreign control over the natural resources, economy, army, or culture of the country, as well as other aspects of the national life, is forbidden.

Article 131

The government of the Republic of Iran may grant political asylum to those who are subject of human rights violations and seek it unless they are regarded as traitors and saboteurs according to the laws of Iran.

Chapter X
The Judiciary


Article 132

The judiciary is an independent power, the protector of the rights of the individual and society, responsible for the implementation of justice, and entrusted with the following duties:

  1. Investigating and passing judgment on grievances, violations of rights, and complaints; the resolving of litigation; the settling of disputes; and the taking of all necessary decisions and measures in probate matters as the law may determine;
  2. Restoring public rights and promoting justice and legitimate freedoms;
  3. Supervising the proper enforcement of laws;
  4. Uncovering crimes; prosecuting, punishing, and chastising criminals; and enacting the penalties and provisions of the penal code;
  5. Taking suitable measures to prevent the occurrence of crime and to reform criminals.

Article 133


In order to fulfill the responsibilities of the judiciary power in all the matters concerning judiciary, administrative and executive areas, The president shall appoint any substitute for retired, ill or deceased members of the Supreme Judiciary Council well versed in judiciary affairs and possessing prudence and administrative abilities as the head of the judiciary power for a period of maximum 10 years who shall be the highest judicial authority.

Article 134


The Judiciary Council is responsible for the following:

  1. Establishment of the organizational structure necessary for the administration of justice.
  2. Drafting judiciary bills appropriate for the Secular Republic of Iran.
  3. Employment of just and worthy judges, their dismissal, appointment, transfer, assignment to particular duties, promotions, and carrying out similar administrative duties, in accordance with secular laws.

Article 135

The courts of justice are the official bodies to which all grievances and complaints are to be referred. The formation of courts and their jurisdiction is to be determined by law.

Article 136

The Minister of Justice owes responsibility in all matters concerning the relationship between the judiciary, on the one hand, and the executive and legislative branches, on the other hand. The Judiciary Council may delegate full authority to the Minister of Justice in financial and administrative areas and for employment of personnel other than judges in which case the Minister of Justice shall have the same authority and responsibility as those possessed by the other ministers in their capacity as the highest ranking government executives.

Article 137

The Judiciary Council is the ultimate reference in interpretation of constitution and the laws and decisions by the courts, ensuring uniformity of judicial procedure, and fulfilling any other responsibilities assigned to it by law.

Article 138

The conditions and qualifications to be fulfilled by a judge will be determined by law

Article 139

A judge cannot be removed, whether temporarily or permanently, from the post he occupies except by trial and proof of guilt, or in consequence of a violation entailing his dismissal. A judge cannot be transferred or re-designated without his or her consent, except in cases when the interest of society necessitates it, that too, with the decision of the Judicial Council. The periodic transfer and rotation of judges will be in accordance with general regulations to be laid down by law.

Article 140

Trials are to be held openly and members of the public may attend without any restriction; except in cases of private disputes when either of the parties request not to hold open hearing.

Article 141

The verdicts of courts must be well reasoned out and documented with reference to the articles and principles of the law in accordance with which they are delivered.

Article 142

The judge is bound to endeavor to judge each case on the basis of the codified law. A Judge may not refrain from admitting and examining cases and delivering judgment.

Article 143

Political and press offenses will be tried openly and in the presence of a jury, in courts of justice. The manner of the selection of the jury, its powers, and the definition of political offenses, will be determined by law.

Article 144

No act or omission may be regarded as a crime with retrospective effect on the basis of a law framed subsequently.

Article 145

Judges of courts are obliged to refrain from executing statutes and regulations of the government that are in conflict with the laws and outside their competence of, the executive power. Everyone has the right to demand the annulment of any such regulation from the Court of Administrative Justice.

Article 146

Whenever an individual suffers emotional or material loss as the result of a default or error of the judge with respect to the subject matter of a case or the verdict delivered, or the application of a rule in a particular case, the defaulting judge must stand surety for the reparation of that loss in accordance with the law, if it be a case of default. Otherwise, losses will be compensated for by the State. In all such cases, the repute and good standing of the accused will be restored.

Article 147

Military courts will be established by law to investigate crimes committed in connection with military or security duties by members of the Army, the Gendarmerie and the police. They will be tried in public courts, however, for common crimes or crimes committed while serving the department of justice in executive capacity. The office of military prosecutor and the military courts form part of the judiciary and are subject to the same principles that regulate the judiciary.

Article 148

In order to investigate the complaints, grievances, and objections of the people with respect to government officials, organs, and statutes, a court will be established to be known as the Court of Administrative Justice under the supervision of the Judiciary Council. The jurisdiction, powers, and mode of operation of this court will be laid down by law.

Article 149

In accordance with the right of the judiciary to supervise the proper conducting of affairs and the correct implementation of laws by the administrative organs of the government, an organization will be constituted under the supervision of the Judiciary Council to be known as the National General Inspectorate. The powers and duties of this organization will be determined by law

Article 150

Complete list of all prisoners with their whereabouts, case numbers and terms of imprisonment must be available publicly. 

Article 151

No individual may be punished or imprisoned for their religious, ideological and political views even if they may be in opposition to the government or constitution of the republic of Iran.

Chapter XI
Radio and Television


Article 152

The freedom of expression and dissemination of thoughts in the Central Radio and Television of the Republic of Iran must be guaranteed in keeping with the Secular criteria and the best interests of the country. The appointment and dismissal of the head of the Radio and Television of the Republic of Iran rests with a council of 3 representatives, each assigned by the President, the Judiciary Council and the National Consultative Assembly.

Article 153

Private Media and Radio, Television stations are allowed to operate within the framework of the law.


Chapter XII
Supreme Council for National Security


Article 154

In order to safeguarding the national interests and preserving the territorial integrity and national sovereignty, a Supreme Council for National Security presided over by the President shall be constituted to fulfill the following responsibilities:

  1. Determining the defense and national security policies within the framework of law and the general policies of the Government and the National Consultative Assembly.
  2. Coordination of activities in the areas relating to politics, intelligence, social, cultural and economic fields in regard to general defense and security policies. 

The Council shall consist of: heads of three branches of the government, chief of the Supreme Command Council of the Armed Forces, the officer in charge of the planning and budget affairs, ministers of foreign affairs, interior, information and the highest ranking officials of the each of Armed Forces.

Commensurate with its duties, the Supreme Council for National Security shall form sub-councils such as Defense Sub-council and National Security Sub-council. Each Sub-council will be presided over by the President or a member of the Supreme Council for National Security appointed by the President. The scope of authority and responsibility of the Sub-councils will be determined by law and their organizational structure will be approved by the Supreme Council for National Defense. The decisions of the Supreme Council for National Security must be in accordance with the laws and shall be effective after the confirmation by the President.

Chapter XIII

Revisions and Amendments to the Constitution

Article 155

Revision and Amendments of the Secular Constitution of the Republic of Iran, whenever needed by the circumstances, can be done in the following manner:

(To be completed)

14 Bahman, 2547

02 February, 2009

Share/Save/Bookmark

more from David ET
 
David ET

Moving to Draft 2

by David ET on


default

secularism in Iran (to Persia)- BTW thanks ET

by Anonym7 (not verified) on

Persia says: "What secularism/ Iran will remain under theocracy foevever."

In true sense Iran is much more secular than 30+ years ago because Iranians are much more secular than before. It is just a matter of time before the government reflects people's desire.
Have you been to Iran lately? Thirty years ago we had hundreds of thousands attending Friday prayers in major Iranian cities, that is all but gone!
If the ultra right reactionaries in U.S and Israel leave Iran and Iranians alone, that process will take place even faster and will be irreversible.


default

Dear David ET

by true persian (not verified) on

With all due respect, Persia no longer exists. I think you are doing a great Job of introducing to us what a secular Iranian constitution should be like, but Iranians have proven that they are more interested in a theocracy. Majority of Iranians voted for a theocracy in 1979 after the Islamic revolution and have been giving legitimacy to the theocratic regime by voting for their puppet presidents and parliaments. What we need is an evolution to change that kind of mentality. Evolution takes hundreds if not thousands of years.
Than you.


default

Iranians are Arabs

by true persian (not verified) on

I disagree. Persia does not exist. The proof is that the Iranians embraced the Arab culture in 1979 and then they actually voted for the "Islamic Republic" and they have been voting for the Islamic presidents eversince. People say not much when their brothers and sisters are being imprisoned , maimed, tortured, raped and beheaded in Iran. Do you call this the persian spirit that existed in real Persia long ago.

Iran has embraced the Arab culture as much as Egypt, Syria and other countries in the region,except that the Iranians are more Arab than the Arabs themselves. Where in the Arab world you see the craziness that is going on in Iran right now? Which Arab country rather than Iran creates,supports terror groups in and out of the country? Hamas, Islamic jihad, Hezbollah. You name it. All supported by the Arab government of Iran elected by Arab people of Iran. There is no such thing as Iranian people and true Persians unless you are a real intellectual athiest like myself. Persian cup of tea pot doesn't make you Iranian. Your thoughts and actions count.The thoughts and actions of people in Iran makes them more Arab than the Arabs themselves.


David ET

Jahanshah

by David ET on

You also brought up  : "welfare measures, social justice, and spread of
secularism and gender equality even in a form of ministry for these purposes.
Also, I suggest mandatory and proportional participation of women in all
government institutions-- say, a  half of members in parliament, cabinet,...must
be women. "

There are articles in this draft addressing the equal rights of women and
beyond that I personally I am not much for affirmative action for 50% of Iranian
population. Such measures may be needed fir small populations just as it is
allowed for religious minorities political presentations.

I think if laws are implemented , there should not be a reason why women will
not be involved in the state affairs. In fact looking at the high percentage of
females in Iranian Universities, I see no reason why they won't even occupy more
than 50% if they desire.

Of course if and when there are discriminations they will have enough laws to
rely on to change the specific circumstances .

Affirmative actions often can lead to reverse discrimination .

As for social guarantees there are articles that are addressing that such as
:

Article 23      Every person is entitled to the
enjoyment of Social Security. This covers retirement, unemployment, disability,
being without a guardian, temporary disability, accidents, and occurrences
giving rise to the need for universal health services, medical care and
treatment and medicine through insurance. The Government is bound, in accordance
with the laws, to use public revenues and the revenue drawn from individual
contributions to provide the services and financial support mentioned above for
every citizen of the country.

Article 24     The Government is bound to make
available, free of charge, educational facilities for all through high school
and technical schools, and to expand free facilities for higher education and
career training up to the limits of the country's own needs and capacity.

Article 25       Every Iranian individual and family
is entitled to a dwelling appropriate to need. 


article 37   The economy of the Republic of Iran, with
its objectives of achieving the economic independence of the society, uprooting
poverty and deprivation, and fulfilling human needs in the process of
development while preserving human liberty, is based on the following criteria:

  1. The provision of the basic necessities for all citizens:
    housing, food, clothing, hygiene, medical treatment, education, and the
    necessary facilities for the establishment of healthy individuals and
    families
  2. Ensuring conditions and opportunities of employment for
    everyone, with a view to attaining full employment; placing the means of work at
    the disposal of everyone who is able to work but lacks the means, in the form of
    cooperatives, through granting interest-free loans or recourse to any other
    legitimate means that neither results in the concentration or circulation of
    wealth in the hands of a few individuals or groups, nor turns the government
    into a major absolute employer. These steps must be taken with due regard for
    the requirements governing the general economic planning of the country at each
    stage of its growth;
  3. The plan for the national economy, must be structured in
    such a manner that the form, content, and hours of work of every individual will
    allow sufficient leisure and energy to engage, beyond professional endeavor, in
    intellectual, political, and social activities leading to all-round development
    of self, to take active part in leading the affairs of the country, improve
    skills, and to make full use of his creativity;
  4. Respect for the right to choose freely one's occupation;
    refraining from compelling anyone to engage in a particular job; and preventing
    the exploitation of another's labor;
  5. The prohibition of infliction of harm and loss upon others,
    monopoly, hoarding, usury, and other illegitimate practices;
  6. The prohibition of extravagance and wastefulness in all
    matters related to the economy, including consumption, investment, production,
    distribution, and services;
  7. The utilization of science and technology, and the training
    of skilled personnel in accordance with the developmental needs of the country's
    economy;
  8. Protection of a healthy environment in all land, air and
    water.
  9. Prevention of foreign economic domination over the country's
    economy;
  10. Emphasis on increase of agricultural, livestock, industrial
    and technological production in order to satisfy public needs and to make the
    country self-sufficient and free from dependence.

I think as a developing country that is the extent that the constitution may
guarantee and beyond that we will be denying other economic solutions which
should be left open to discussion and trials.

I look forward to your further inputs ...


David ET

I always feel very sorry for hopeless people

by David ET on

Persia still exists because unlike many others who have long been gone ,she "never" surrendered to "never" ...

Just as Lalehs (Tuplis) of Gilan province will always blossom in many springs to come...

and as long as we enjoy the aroma of our Persian teapots ...

and as long as we have our Asbahaye Sarkash (wild horses), we can send your shotors (camels) back to where they came from... 


default

Shotor binad dar khab panbeh

by persia (not verified) on

Shotor binad dar khab panbeh daneh. What secularism/ Iran will remain under theocracy foevever. Not only the majority of iranians but also all left and socialits of the world love the Iranians mullahs.


LalehGillani

Great Ideas!

by LalehGillani on

“Next time, it is probably better to discuss one chapter of the constitution at a time.”

“I wish this would be published as an article on the first page where more people would see it.”

I agree. These are all great suggestions. If there is room on the first page to publish intimate accounts of passionate dreams, why not publish a draft of our future constitution that will give that lady the freedom to have more public dreams?

(Sorry I just couldn’t resist the temptation…)


David ET

As we fall in to second page of the blogs ...

by David ET on

I promise to continue this topic in next blog shortly and after I have
made the revisions discussed and then leave the rest for further discussion.

Laleh: I too agree with your concern and felt it from beginning but chose to leave it for discussion . At the same time I think
rather than quickly dropping this , it is best to discuss and then either drop
or revise it. For example we can remove the sentence about Family as a unit of
society as it serves no legal purpose anyway. But lets not forget the only thing
that the next sentence states is to "facilitate"... . I personally see no harm in
that. So at least just for now I make partial revision subject to more
discussion if I may... but lets talk more , as I am felxibale and have no specific bias on the subject, but I think a family of a child and his/her need government facilitations.

I also fully agree that it is best to summarize the constitution however as first step
it was important to try to cover as much areas as needed and then some
reformatting and house cleaning will be in order!

So I will revise the draft in areas discussed and repost it with another
summary introduction .

Next time, it is probably be better to discuss one chapter of constitution
at a time , 

 Jahanshah:  Issue of Flag , may need to be just left to future
parliament etc and just take the symbol out completely. On  second though I am
not too crazy about the Lion and Sun considering that it does reflect a sense of
animalistic hostility and friction which does not seem appropriate for future.
It is different times and we must look in to future and set new and higher
values . As for cylinder of human rights may simultaneously reflect ideological
or imperial visions which again is not the intention. So its best to focus on
more important issues . How about a sonbol (Hyacinth) flower
for a change. It has much history, meaning and shows our past and future spirit
...! I will reply to other subjects of your concern that I still have not addressed in future comments.


DW Duke

Publication

by DW Duke on

I wish this would be published as an article on the first page where more people would see it.  This is triggering a great discussion. 


DW Duke

Thanks Teapot

by DW Duke on

Ok, I see what happened now, it was a rogue judge.  Every once in a while we see a judge "lose it."  There was one in Nevada about a year ago.  Sometimes they crack under pressure.   I saw a judge flip off an attorney in open court one time because the attorney make a joke about the judge not being able to get out of jury duty.  The judge meant it as a joke but they have been sanctioned for that kind of thing.   

You are right that it is a slippery slope.  While the Constitution won't address the detail of every law, it is for the legislature to make sure that rights are protected by enacting the appropriate laws and they can't be based on religion.  Then if the judge applies the law correctly, there should not be a problem and if she does not, then there is always the right of appeal. 


default

Sweet David, Thank you for

by teapot (not verified) on

Sweet David, Thank you for hte compliment. I love tea and can't live without it:)

Would you be kind enought to write "a Part II" as a follow up to this wonderful discussion?


default

DW Duke: Thank you for

by teapot (not verified) on

DW Duke: Thank you for explaining the details of these types of courts, however, what are the potential for abuse of this kind of courts when the IRI produces more than 10,000 mullah per year and according to some estimates, there are more than 500,000 mullahs operating in Iran and interfer in every aspects of citizens private life. It is slippery slope in a society like Iran and in my humble opinion should not exist until the government has more time to educate people on the rule of law and respect for them.

Here is the case in Germany.

Paving the Way for a Muslim Parallel Society

recent ruling in Germany by a judge who cited the Koran underscores the dilemma the country faces in reconciling Western values with a growing immigrant population. A disturbing number of rulings are helping to create a parallel Muslim world in Germany that is welcoming to Islamic fundamentalists.

She didn't know it, nor did she even expect it. She had good intentions. Perhaps it was a mistake. In fact, it was most certainly a mistake. The best thing to do would be to wipe the slate clean.

Last week, in the middle of the storm, Christa Datz-Winter, a judge on Frankfurt's family court, was speechless. But Bernhard Olp, a spokesman for the city's municipal court, was quick to jump in. Olp reported that the judge had been under emotional stress stemming from a murder that had been committed in her office 10 years ago, and that she was now planning to take a break to recuperate. He also mentioned that she was "outraged" -- not about herself or her scandalous ruling, but over the reactions the case has triggered.

The reactions were so fierce that one could have been forgiven for mistakenly thinking that Germany's Muslims had won the headscarf dispute and the controversy over the Mohammed cartoons in a single day and, in one fell swoop, had taken a substantial bite out of the legal foundations of Western civilization.

The ensuing media furor came from both sides of the political spectrum. The left-leaning daily Die Tageszeitung ran a story on the case titled: "In the Name of the People: Beating Allowed," while the right-wing tabloid Bild called it "An Outrageous Case!" The same unanimity across party lines prevailed in the political realm. "Unbearable," was conservative Bavarian Interior Minister Günther Beckstein's ruling, while Lale Akgün, a member of parliament of Turkish origin and the Social Democratic Party's representative on Islamic issues, commented that the Frankfurt judge's ruling was "worse than some backyard decision by an Islamist imam." Even the deputy head of the Green Party's parliamentary group, Hans-Christian Ströbele, noted that a German judge is obligated to uphold German law.

The original purpose of the case was not to carry the clash of cultures into the courtroom. Instead, the case brought before Frankfurt's family court was that of a 26-year-old German woman of Moroccan origin who was terrified of her violent Moroccan husband, a man who had continued to threaten her despite having been ordered to stay away by the authorities. He had beaten his wife and he had allegedly threatened to kill her.

But German law requires a one-year separation before a divorce can be completed -- and exceptions for an expedited process are only granted in extreme situations. When the woman's attorney, Barbara Becker-Rojczyk, filed a petition for an expedited divorce, Judge Christa Datz-Winter suddenly became inflexible. According to the judge, there was no evidence of "an unreasonable hardship" that would make it necessary to dissolve the marriage immediately. Instead, the judge argued, the woman should have "expected" that her husband, who had grown up in a country influenced by Islamic tradition, would exercise the "right to use corporal punishment" his religion grants him.

The judge even went so far as to quote the Koran in the grounds for her decision. In Sura 4, verse 34, she wrote, the Koran contains "both the husband's right to use corporal punishment against a disobedient wife and the establishment of the husband's superiority over the wife."

A disturbing pattern of rulings

Put plainly, the judge argued that a woman who marries a Muslim should know what she's getting herself into. In Germany, no less. Leading German feminist Alice Schwarzer argued that this was tantamount to a "softening of our legal system" that is "by no means a coincidence." Germany's only minister of integration at the state level, Armin Laschet, a member of the conservative Christian Democratic Union (CDU) from the state of North Rhine Westphalia, sees the Frankfurt ruling as the "last link, for the time being, in a chain of horrific rulings handed down by German courts" -- rulings in which, for example, so-called honor killings have been treated as manslaughter and not murder.

//www.spiegel.de/international/germany/0,1518...


LalehGillani

Let’s Continue this Discussion

by LalehGillani on

Please consider making the revisions as discussed on this thread and post the proposed constitution again and again. Many of us still haven’t had time to read all the articles.

Regardless of where this thread takes us, the importance of this topic can’t be over emphasized. We must have a voice in shaping our future.

Iranian legal scholars, political activists, and leaders are listening… Have your voice heard!


LalehGillani

Characteristics of an Effective Constitution

by LalehGillani on

In my humble opinion, the future constitution of Iran must be brief and precise.

Why brief? The constitution must be brief because it is only a foundation upon which all other laws are established. If the constitution becomes too lengthy, it loses focus and effectiveness. It turns into a legal rambling full of holes.

Why precise? Obviously, it must be precise so that there are no doubts about its intention and protection.

Given these two principles, once the constitution attempts to tap into private aspects of life (such as family), it loses its brevity, its focus, and its precision. In other words, it opens a can of worms: What is family? Why is it the fundamental unit of the society? What other units are there which might be able to replace this unit? Why only this unit needs protection and regulations to promote it and safeguard it? Can we name all other units of the society that need the same treatment?

My uneasiness with Article 7 stems from the unanswered questions that it poses the can of warms that it opens…


David ET

Jahanshah

by David ET on

Thank you for kind words. I too hope that iranian.com while maintaining its independence, take a more responsible role for Iran and Iranians.

I try to address your comments the best I can:

Article 2 The Republic of Iran is a system based on beliefs in:

  1. Full separation of Religion and State at all levels without any exceptions

Article 17 Investigation of individuals' beliefs is forbidden, and no one may be molested or taken to task simply for holding a certain belief. 

Article 20 Political parties, societies, trade unions and religious associations may freely be formed within the scopes of law. No person may be prevented from joining, or compelled to join, one of the above.

Article 21 Unarmed assemblies and marches may freely be organized, and permits must be issued by the government.

Above articles provide freedom of expression private and public within the scopes of the law (eg. : not encroaching on right of others, being peaceful etc).

Ashura march falls within this category, but acts of self beating by chain, etc will not be permitted since beside self injury , such public show of violence will encroach on right of those who observe it. 

Considering that 98% of Iranians are Muslim public Azan will be permitted although it may wake up those who do practice it.

We should respect people's beliefs and continue to educate as well as insulate the government from religion.

HIJAB

PREAMBLE Gender Equality: We the people of Iran, male and female are equal and have equal rights. Our government of the people shall provide all safety and securities to assure that gender equality is fully exercised and implemented

Article 14 All citizens of the country, both men and women, equally enjoy the protection of the law and equally enjoy all human, political, economic, social, and cultural rights.

Article 15 The government must ensure the rights of women in all respects and accomplish the following goals:

  1. Protecting and promoting equal rights with men in all areas of individual, family, social and government. 

Hijab is a form of clothing and right of a woman to wear if she chooses to, but her right will be protected if she is being forced by family or others to wear it.

EDUCATION

Article 3

  1. Free education and physical training for everyone at all levels, and the facilitation and expansion of career training and higher education;
  2. Strengthening the spirit of inquiry, investigation, and innovation in all areas of science, technology, and culture, by establishing research centers and encouraging researchers;
  3. The complete elimination of religion at all levels of government affairs of the country;

Article 24 The Government is bound to make available, free of charge, educational facilities for all through high school and technical schools, and to expand free facilities for higher education and career training up to the limits of the country's own needs and capacity.

Although public education will fall under the umbrella of ministry of education (a secular entity) but  I agree with you that it is best to specifically state that the public education shall remain secular. I will make modification. Thank you for noting that. 

I address remainder of your comments separately.


DW Duke

Reply to Teapot re: German Judge

by DW Duke on

I am not aware of the case in Germany to which you are referring but note that the key in the UK article is the voluntary submission to the tribunal under the Arbitration Act.  We have that in the California and most other states.  Often in contract disputes the parties voluntarily submit to the jurisdiction of an arbitrator.  For example, in real estate contracts or in business contracts there is often a clause that says in the event of a dispute the parties will submit the matter to arbitration.  When they do this the arbitration award is binding on the parties and in many instances is not even appealable.  But before the tribunal can even take jurisdiction, the parties have to agree to it.  They cannot be forced to submit to the jurisdiction unless they so choose.  (We have court ordered arbitration but it is not binding on the parties unless they agree in advance or they fail to request trial de novo.)  That is how it is in England and I am sure it is that way in Germany as well though I would be interested in seeing the actual case to which you are referring. 

Note also, that Beit Din (for Jewish Law) and other religious arbitration services also have that jurisdiction but the parties must consent to give the tribunal jurisdiction before they can be bound by the decision of that tribunal.   


Yachov

This is a good discussion

by Yachov on

This is a great discussion.  I am happy to see this dialogue.   


Jahanshah Rashidian

Thank you David

by Jahanshah Rashidian on

Dear David,

I appreciate your subtle job to prepare a preamble for a constituion for a secular republic in Iran. I know to prepare such a text needs enormous endeavours. Although I am not an expert and have not read your piece more than once, let me reflect several points which seem important:

Regarding “freedom of religious practices” my question is if public practice of religion is unlimited free or not ?— I think of Ashoura mourning, public Azan, and other public rituals and in a further extend, Islamic hijab. 

You suggest a prohibition of religion influence in affairs of government. National Education System is also a task of any government, then why you did not mention a secular system of education freed from any theological lesson, gender segregation, or any religious influence?

What is your suggestion to the religious institutions which have been gathering donation to finance shrines, mosques, preachers, and so on? Are any constitutional law or clause to lead to confiscate their funds and turn their funds and locals back to people. We know in a secular Iran these Islamic institutions can be supported by corrupt Sheiks or Islamic states that cannot stomach a secular state in the region. Is any constitutional way to controle their Islamist activities in a secular Iran? Or all is coverd by the notion of "freedom of religion"?

You gave the Parliament power enough to be the second representative institution, which is ok. I like also more power for the state to protect people through welfare measures, social justice, and spread of secularism and gender equality even in a form of ministry for these purposes. Also, I suggest mandatory and proportional participation of women in all government institutions-- say, a  half of members in parliament, cabinet,...must be women. 

About the flag: I am not personally against the emblem, but it seems if a particular ideology is launching a campaign to foster a nationalist identity to all Iranians regardless their ethnic and ideological differences. I am not sure if such a campaign leads to unity of all Iranians. Furthermore a constitution allowing any flag with an ideological emblem has no democratic reputation.

Once again, thanks for your efforts. Hopefully, the owner of this site will post such articles on the front page to be more debated, if not, please blog it again. Such a text has enormous psychological and courageous effects among the people of Iran and brings fruits among the opposition. 


David ET

reply

by David ET on

Teapot: see the last sentence of Article 9 :

Article 9   Secular republic of Iran observes no official religions for the country, however believes in affirmation action to assure religious minorities with large populations in Iran have proper political representation and seats in the parliament. Secular in nature, everyone in Iran is treated the same, regardless of their religion or lack of it. All religions within the limits of the law and without limiting the guaranteed individual rights within the constitution are free to perform their religious rights, and to act according to their own canon in matters of personal affairs.  

I will change it to "individual and human rights" and also add extra sentence to clarify this further about your earlier point. Feel free to revise it and post here.

On a seperate note what a wonderful ID you have chosen : Teapot!

Rosie: We have been stuck in the pasts for WAY TOO LONG and those who don't want us to excell , everytime there is voice of hope try to devide us by brining up the pasts that many of us did not even live !

Indeed! After we DARE  to dream, we will  ENVISION our dreams and AFFIRM that "yes we can too" , then we SEEK WAYS to make it a REALITY. 

The last step actually I think is the easiest one , because once it is internalized there is no way going back. We Iranians must dare to believe in ourselves again and then nothing and noone can stop this irreversibale paradigm shift.

 Zion put it so elequently : "The sky would be the limit for all she can achieve that day."


Zion

Hope to see a day...

by Zion on

... when Iran joins the world again with a constitution like this. The sky would be the limit for all she can achieve that day.


default

A German judge last year did

by teapot (not verified) on

A German judge last year did not allow a battered woman to divorce her husband. He argued that for Muslim woman wife punsihment/abuse is part of her culture. The ruling was reversed because it was publicized by the media.

BERLIN (AFP) - A German woman judge has refused a Moroccan-born woman permission to file for divorce by interpreting the Koran as allowing husbands to beat their wives.

In UK:

UK’s first official sharia courts
//www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/crime/art...


DW Duke

Teapot

by DW Duke on

This is the reason individual rights are critical in any form of government.  There is never an excuse for spousal or child abuse and advanced nations have laws to prevent this.  Where religion conflicts with individual rights, the compelling interest favors individual rights.  Shariah law has to give way to human rights and that is the great conflict facing much of the world going forward but human rights will prevail.  There will be a balancing process but the balance will mitigate in favor of humanity and not in favor of extreme religious idealogy.


default

David jan: There are also

by teapot (not verified) on

David jan: There are also other religious rights. For example, husbands according to Sharia have the right to hit their husbands. This is a religious right given to a muslim man by some interpretation of Sharia.

Also don't forget about the relgious right given to those who are victims of crimes, the "Ghesas" is a relgious right.

I guess any of the Sharia laws even stoning, sigheh polygamy, pedophilia (age of marriage being 9 for girls)inherants laws, divorce laws can be considered as religious rights afforded to men. These relgious right are obviously inhumane. Some Ayatollah can challenge the secular laws by arguing that his religious law are being violated and under freedom of religion, one can argue that he is right; however, any relgious law that is harmful to the psychological well being of families in the larger society should take a back seat to the laws and provisions provided in the constitution and legislated by the elected body.


rosie is roxy is roshan

Marathonman, not presumptuous, good idea.

by rosie is roxy is roshan on

we would need to get rid of the current dictatorial regime before a new constitution is considered. If this government is removed by some miraculous means, the people who come to power likely will want to change the constitution to something that would be similar to their own belief, just like you suggesting a constitution which conforms to your belief.

It works both ways. The more people envision a secular parliamentary government and what that would be like the more they will find ways and courage to achieve it.  Despite there being all kinds of  flourishing areas of thought and reserach in Iran today the fact is there also was a braindrain and they could use the expat community's brains too. Also there is no reason the expat community should be isolated from the process if they don't want to be. When (not miraculously) time comes for a Constitution it will be representative and that means voters should have input, why shouldn't these types of brainstorming be part of that input?

One of the things I always admired about David's series of blogs is that they are proactive and future-oriented. I think any activity on the site that is collaborative, proactive and future-oriented (as long as it is pacificist in nature) is a lot more healthy and productive than arguing and bickering and lamenting the past and being morose about the future.

If we dream the future we don't know if our dreams will come true but if we DON'T then there are no dreams to come true.

Roxane


David ET

Teapot

by David ET on

I first did not understand what you meant but then I got it. I guess an example of what you are referring to is a family deciding not to offer medicine to their sick child based on their religious beliefs etc.

I will try to add an expanded version of it in the next draft...

Good observation

Talking about children, although the preamble addresses commitment to convention on the right of the child and children are mentioned in couple of areas but I think there may be need for more specific articles regarding constitutional rights of children.

and yet we should be VERY careful not to give too much power to government over the parents but only make sure that their rights are proected versus adults, parents and government and possibly an article giving them special place and priority!


David ET

Laleh

by David ET on

Laleh: You bought up another great point. The wording: Full guarantee and legal protection of human rights is much better. Also lets not forgot that this is all in English and the translation to Persian is where real importance of legal implications would lie.

As for article 7, can you be more specific what specific part of it you disagree with?

Since the family is the fundamental unit of society, all laws, regulations, and pertinent programs must tend to facilitate the formation of a family, childcare and to safeguard the stability of family relations and children rights. 

1- Is unit of "society" family or not ?

2- Should "laws, regulations, and pertinent programs" facilitate formation of families, childcare and safeguard stability of relationships and children rights or  make it more difficult?

PLEASE NOTE THAT THE FAMILY SPECIFICS IS NOT DEFINED IN THE CONSTITUTION.

and there are plenty of articles that protect individual rights.

Anyway I dont see this as intrusion of government in to family but facilitating and protecting it. If I am wrong please be more specific , how it can be misconstrued .

Dear Laleh I hope you stay with us on this journey :-)

To readers:

Feel free to take the draft and create your own based on it ! all of it , certain chapaters , certain articles , sentences or words.

I may not exactly know what you mean until you actually show me your version :-)


David ET

Captain

by David ET on

 Thanks again and great points you brought up. Lets review them together:

Article 93: The President must be elected from individuals possessing the following qualifications: Iranian parents; born in Iran, Iranian nationality; no prior criminal or fraud record; belief in the constitution of the Secular Republic of Iran.

You addressed possible minimum age of 40. I do see a point about EXPERIENCE but before we rush to a decision lets consider few points:

- Iran has a young population

- President has an executive role (Like a CEO) and Parliament makes the laws. So how about a younger smart energetic CEO for a nation of many youth?

- There are many geniuses among Iranian population. Some get featured here on this site!

How about minimum age of 30?

*****

Article 41: Private ownership, legitimately acquired, is to be respected

You brought up adding the words protected and promoted. I think adding the word protected is a great idea. As for the word "promoted", I am not sure!  Giving the government the role of promoting one view over another in the body of constitution may give too much power  to the state. In future Iran there will be different parties who may get elected by people who may have different economic ideas in mind. I personally think some things need to be left to be decided and tested by people and their parties than forced upon them. Giving the government the propaganda role of promoting one ideology versus another may not be a good idea.

The intention of this draft is not to enforce a specific thinking but to allow all thoughts to flourish, be discussed, and then  implemented if decided by people and their representatives and if not successful another can be chosen.

I believe Constitution provides the necessary environment   

*****

Article 38: Airwaves of the country are public and can be used by private Radio, Television and other communication services by permission of the government. Foreign governments may not broadcast within the boundaries of Iran.

Article 152 : The freedom of expression and dissemination of thoughts in the Central Radio and Television of the Republic of Iran must be guaranteed in keeping with the Secular criteria and the best interests of the country. The appointment and dismissal of the head of the Radio and Television of the Republic of Iran rests with a council of 3 representatives, each assigned by the President, the Judiciary Council and the National Consultative Assembly.

Article 153 : Private Media and Radio, Television stations are allowed to operate within the framework of the law.

If the government is the representative of the people I personally have no issue with having a central Radio/Television IN ADDITION to private ones. After all the representatives of people also need to be able to express their points and if there is no censorship that also in a developing country allows promotion of cultural and national subjects versus giving it all to commercial stations. The experience of many European Nations who in addition to freedom of private media have state run TV/Radio has shown that this is not necessarily a bad idea. In a system of checks and balances the concept that we have of state media may be different than when it is by the government of the people and especially that having this station does not prevent other public and private stations to operate.

I am not sure what you mean by  Article 2 of the preamble being in contrast of article 38.

Government permission is a necessary requirement for maintaining order for demonstrations, Media etc ....but givernment is only limited to the power granted to it by law and can not prevent freedom of expression voluntarily without violating the constitution and law.

But I do think if needed additional wording may be necessary.

and yes I too agree about deletion of the word supreme but we also need to find substitute words .

I will post different chapters of the draft  for further discussion over time and alter as deemed necessary after discussion.

Before this blog falls off the featured list in less than 24 hours,  I shoudl note that I am only expressing my views to show what I am thinking but I am not insisting that I am necessarily right. In fact your inputs are exactly what I am hoping for...

Thank you all for taking the time to read and your great contributions and suggestions....


default

I like an addendum on the

by teapot (not verified) on

I like an addendum on the human rights issue.

Human rights trumps all religious rights (or lackthereof) of all religions practiced in the country. Or, religious rights are not recognized legally if they negate or contradict human rights..something to that effect.;-)


LalehGillani

Article 7 - Undue Power

by LalehGillani on

As a private citizen, I don’t want to see the government defining what a family is (the fundamental unit of the society) and how a family ought to be formed. Article 7 is giving the government undue power over people.

What I consider a family might be at odds with government’s notion of what a family ought to be. How do we reconcile this difference? My answer to this question is simple: We take the government ought of my family’s business.

However, I do recognize the need for legal protection of children’s rights. Iranian citizens regardless of their age must be equally protected under the law.