آیا واقعن ادعای کینگریج در موردخلق فلسطین اشتباه است؟


Share/Save/Bookmark

h.jahanshahi
by h.jahanshahi
17-Dec-2011
 

سالها پیش زهیر محسن یکی از رهبران سازمان آزادی بخش فلسطین (1979-1971) در گفتگو با یک روزنامه هلندی اعتراف کرده بود که درست کردن نام خلق یا ملت فلسطین یک ابزار سیاسی بوده است

نقل قول

«خلق فلسطین وجود ندارد. خلق کردن یک کشور فلسطین تنها ابزاری است تا مبارزه علیه کشور اسرائیل را بسود اتحاد عربی خود ادامه دهیم. در واقع امروز تفاوتی بین اردونی، فلسطینی، سوری و لبنانی وجود ندارد. امروزه ما تنها به دلایل سیاسی و تاکتیکی از خلق فلسطین سخن میگوییم چون منافع ناسیونالیسم عربی در این است که ما در جهت وجود یک خلق فلسطینی که وجود دارد عمل کنیم تا با صهیونیسم مقابله کنیم.» منبع

جای تعجب نیست که امروزه همه فلسطینی ها با زهیر محسن هم نظر نیستند ولی این نشان میدهد که سخن کینگریچ را هم نمیتوان چندان بی پایه دانست. خود من چندین ماه پیش مقاله ای خواندم که با تکیه به آمار و ارقام برگرفته شده از ادارات انگلستان که پس از فروپاشی امپراتوری عثمانی اداره منطقه را بعهده گرفته بود، نشان میداد که بخش بزرگی از فلسطینی های امروزی فرزندان کارگران مهاجری هستند که از اردن و سوریه و ... برای کار در مناطق ثروتمندتر یهودی به آن مناطق کوچ کرده بودند. اگر آن مقاله را پیدا کردم ترجمه خواهم کرد.

ولی متاسفانه نفرت از اسرائیل و آمریکا بخش بزرگی از ما ایرانی ها را در دیدن واقعیت ها ناتوان کرده است. هرکه ثروت و قدرت دارد شیطان است و هرکه ندارد فرشته ی بی گناه. چه ضربه ها که از این نوع ساده سازی هایمان نخورده ایم.


Share/Save/Bookmark

Recently by h.jahanshahiCommentsDate
روزگار نفت-1
-
Dec 01, 2012
حاضر و آماده
3
Sep 17, 2012
آینده اقتصاد چین از والستریت ژورنال
-
Sep 07, 2012
more from h.jahanshahi
 
h.jahanshahi

thanks Simorgh5555

by h.jahanshahi on

you're right, but I'm gonna ignore him

I think, he wants my death, because he has no power.
the question is, what would he do if he would have power?

that's freedom of speech

 

از همه شما دوستانی که کامنت گذاشتید سپاسگزارم

شاد و موفق باشید


Simorgh5555

H.Jahanshahi

by Simorgh5555 on

People like Pendare Nik kicked out the Zionists in their 'beloved homeland' only to be kicked out themselves or enter into forced exile themselves after their 'Great Revolution' failed. The country of their choice? Why, its the wicked imperialist USA of course! The country which they accuse of installing a puppet dictator and destroying their illusional democracy of Mossadeq in 1953. Nothing the Americans have done prevent people like Pendare Nik disembarking at New York Harbour with his/her arms spread wide eagle singing  the sonnet:

 "Give me your tired, your poor/Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free"

OK, I exaggerate-but for people like Pendar there will always be one priority: Palestine. Even if it means at the expense of their own people which he/she admittedly flushed down the toilet in 1979. 

 


h.jahanshahi

thank you all for your

by h.jahanshahi on

thank you all for your comments.

I'm not against the Palestinian state. But I can understand Israelis.
they think, how can we define our neighbors? people who hate us?

I think it's no good starting point

 

 


h.jahanshahi

pendare nik: "I can't wait to see you dead"

by h.jahanshahi on

I think I must ignore you because you're off topic again. I am not the topic here.

please "think before you act".

thanx!!

آرزوی مرگ دیگران پندار نیک نیست

 


default

It is election time...

by darius on

There should be no surprise in here,  He will change the history, rename the country, nuke people , invade or order to kill millions as long as he  can  divert the money flow to his account to favor some particular group. Is he alone? Not really, almost all  GOP( except Ron Paul) and many Iranians  are on their knees  busy kissing a...

Khers

آخ آخ، حالا سینه چاک‌های فلسطین خودشون رو تیکه پاره میکنند

Khers


به گور پدر هر چی‌ فلسطینی و اسرائیلی است.  به ما چه؟  سر به تنشون نباشه. 


MRX1

Gingrich is right.

by MRX1 on

Gingrich is right on the money on this one. There is nothing unique about the area that is called palestine. There is no such a thing as palestenian language, culture, history, identity, you name it. Arab nationalists know this very well.  They know all these borders are drawn by colonial powers and they mean nothing to Arabs. Arabs are waiting for the right time to reunify their Arab empire. Those of us who are old enough still remember that Iraq and syria came very close to merge as one nation in 1970's. 

unfortunately we live at the age of lies and political correctness so Mr. Gingrich's expressing truth about this subject will most likley back fire on him.


پندارنیک

"Wise guy"

by پندارنیک on

I'm sorry that you found my comment off topic...........you're one of those Zonists/Zionist elements who these days share their beds with the neocons that I helped to be kicked out of my beloved homeland more than three decades ago.......and here we meet again, sort of.............it's amazing how I was capable of keeping my feelings for your kinds intact................I can't wait to see you dead.

No expression of physical threat in any shape or form has been expressively or implicitly intended.


Bavafa

While the last 3 commentators are correct in their assessments..

by Bavafa on

It is worth noting that presenting history as Gingrich has expressed in regards to Palestinians, it is for one reason and one reason only and that is to court the Jewish lobby group (AIPAC) for their much of $$$$ and influence in the upcoming election.  Principals, truth and integrity is not any part of  traits Gingrich can proudly claim but a sell out to the highest bidder.

'Hambastegi' is the main key to victory 

Mehrdad


maghshoosh

No wonder Newt's considered a historian

by maghshoosh on

Regarding the latest piece of wisdom from Gingrich, it may be worth reading the opinion of Uri Avnery, 88-year-old Israeli writer and former member of their parliament, who served in the 1948 Israel's war of independence:

//zope.gush-shalom.org/home/en/channels/avner...


divaneh

It is as much of a nation as Israel

by divaneh on

Let's remember that Israel was also created about the same time and from immigrants.


Ari Siletz

Not an invented people

by Ari Siletz on

Perhaps an invented modern nation, much like other modern states that were formed after the fall of the Ottoman Empire, and the states that were formed after the fall of the Soviet Empire, and the modern state of Israel. Gingrich's selective use of the word "invented"  on the Palestinians alone is more suggestive of political pandering than an honest lesson in history.


h.jahanshahi

doostan lotfan tanha dar

by h.jahanshahi on

doostan lotfan tanha dar rabete ba neveshteye man comment begozarid!

  
دوستان لطفن تنها در مورد مطلبی که من نوشتم، کامنت بگذارید و نه مطالب دیگر

 مرسی!


h.jahanshahi

I see a wise guy

by h.jahanshahi on

but sorry, this is not my trash can


پندارنیک

I can see you drooling like my dog....

by پندارنیک on

Here's another one for you......they come in different batches, or is it bitches?


h.jahanshahi

that's right :-))

by h.jahanshahi on

that's right :-))


پندارنیک

Stateless, worthless blood.......

by پندارنیک on