ETERAZ

Blank Check

Let me see if I understand what you are saying if I am a Bahii then I am not a human. I dont care what Israel dose to my race(human).

They are nice to us I don't care if they kill all the palastinian or the Arabs who cares about Arabs any way they are not Parsian or anything.But you are wrong  FRIENDO, we're all in this togather you mistreat one us you,re mistreating all of us.

Nema - Bahais find refuge in Israel

Your bashing Israel is not justified vis-a-vis Baha'i. Their spiritual center is located  in the beautiful city  of Heifa, and not in Iran. A place where Bahi'is enjoy an unrestricted access and sole sovereignty over their holy place. This magnificent center with its world renowned Bahai gardens is fully Protected and respected by the Israelis.

If  you are a Bahii, then you should like Israel for its contribution to the Bahii sect.

Hamvatan and Nema...why do

Hamvatan and Nema...why do you say such things without any basis? articles are regularly printed here cataloguing the crimes of the IRI and the plight of the Baha'is...I wrote one yesterday and all you had was scorn...it's sad...And although I have always shown my support for Baha'is and my disgust at their mistreatment it seems that SOME Baha'is believe they are the ONLY ones who suffer in this world - THEY SIMPLY COULD CARE LESS ABOUT the suffering of others - this is very sad and morally reckless...How can you expect others to sympathise with your suffering and maltreatment if you dismiss the suffering and persecution of others? Calling every one who disagrees with you 'leftist' or 'akhund' is exactly the same tactic employed by the extremists who persecute Baha'is...for instance, when they call them 'British spies' and other such nonsense... 

//iranian.com/main/blog/sadegh/irans-rebel-ayatollah

Ba Arezu-ye Movafaghiat, Sadegh

Nema

Many people feel the same way you do but sadly our intellectual left has decided that this problem is more pressing than Iran's problems. This is the same tactic used by the Akhoonds. The intellectual left would rather be in bed with the Akhoonds than USA because to them the Akhoonds are making decisions without foreign influence.

How about Bahai's of Iran, don't they suffer every single day

People of Iran are suffering every single day, who gives damn about Palestinians and Israelis, we are Persians, not Arabs, leave the Arab problems to the corrupt rich Arab nations, get a life and speak for your fellow Iranian, especially Bahia’s….

Yes I do...You're identity

Yes I do...You're identity is concealed, I wish mine to remain so as well...don't believe me, that's fine...denounce me as a liar if you prefer...it's of no consequence to me my dear...

Ba Arezu-ye Movafaghiat, Sadegh

Thesis

Do you to mind to share with us, which university to you attend, and what subject your thesis will be about?

No I write these for

No I write these for fun...my thesis is going to be far more theoretically substantial and published in journals and eventually as a book...this is all just lite-editorial/journalism...

Ba Arezu-ye Movafaghiat, Sadegh

Both sides are extremists

Anyone that tries to make Israeli/Palastine peace gets shot. Both sides demand everything and treat each other as less than human.

I AM CURIOUS, SADEGH

As a first-year Ph.D. student how do you find time to engage in so many extra-curricular activities?

Is writing these blogs part of your homework?

Again, you have shown some of the work you have done, as proof of you anti-IRI stance.

However, saying a few nice things here and there with ulterior motives is nothing new.

Listen to Ahmadinejad's speeches and interviews before his election and listen carefully to everything he says to get the votes. Then compare the things he said and the things he has done and is doing, now.

Also, Khomeini's "charisma" was based, primarily, on the promises he made to "Mostasz'afin." Have you ever heard what happened to those promises?

Did you know that most organizations which opposed the Shah actually fell for his promises and believed they would achieve some kind of democracy?

I know you "don't give a hoot" about what people say or think about you, so ignore this post, too.

Sadegh - you need a dose of reality

It is interesting that you derived your info from Israel's own sources - criticizing their own government (for whatever reason). However more interesting is the following post.

margbarIRI wrote the following:

What happened after Oslo? The Pals did not get what they want ( Israel
was to blame 70% and the Pals 30% lets say) so they resorted to much
deadlier violence, including suicide bombings against civilians, with
Arms supplied to them by who? The Israelis themselves. So the world
does not give a damn anymore but for bunch of lefties on the fringe of
things. Once they resorted to suicide bombings, our sympathies for the
Pals were no longer there.

You can be sure that, not only in Israel, but many others peoples around the world who came to same conclusion.

also wrote;

by MargbarIRI (not verified) on Mon Aug 18, 2008 01:45 PM CDT

The answer is very simple. The Israelis have a democracy and free press. They report on their
governments mistreatment of the Pals on a daily basis. They constantly
report on how a minority of settlers within their own country have
hijacked their policies towards the Palestinians. The Israelis have
human rights groups operating within Israel and the territories that
can give cameras to the Pals so they can record the mistreatment.

Tell me, can Sadegh or you go to the IRI, give the Iranian
population cameras to record what is happening to the Iranians on a
daily basis? Can you form human right groups to petition the IRI
government on its abuse of the general population, treatment of
minorities, lack of due process, lack of free press, lack of accounting
and freely operate in the IRI like the Israeli left does?

I have yet read your (intellectual) reply to these facts.I would appreciate to read your view about his/her challange for you to see that Iran and IRI will have a similar policies.

the subject of the Palestinians is just a periphery to the central argument of where the real power lies. In the hand of Government or the people's hand. It is about two societies. Ahkoondahs who provide only LIP SERVICE their protection of human right, as long as it involved OTHER people's right (ie Palestinians), not heir own people. And that of the Israelis who PRACTICE the concept of human right, extended even to those who's leaders are their avowed enemies 

Instead of shedding crocodile tears for the Pals, and anti-Israeli mantra, perhaps the Israelis can teach the others a lesson or two about self criticism and government's accountability to its own constiitunecies.

Mar bar IRI, please read

Mar bar IRI, please read Fred's comments and then tell me in all honesty where there is a shred of decency or argument...

Anyway, I am sorry that the debate took the turn it did and became a nasty and bitter exchange...hopefully next time we will all avoid reaching a similar impasse...

KB thank very much for your words of support...

Ba Arezu-ye Movafaghiat, Sadegh

MargBarIRI, this was a funny comment

You must not be very familiar with Fred's "work" if you think Sadegh is being anything near "unfair and elitist".

Why don't you read what Fred writes and try to apply the same standards to him. You will see enough "unfair" accusations and "elitist" language to last you a whole life time!!!

Great Post Sadegh

Thanks for the post. Another great one.

Ignore the few who criticize you. The truth is there for all to see except our Zionist friends who manufacture their own truth.

 Cheers

Sadegh

Thanks for posting your other blogs. I understand where you are coming from but I still disagree. I also disagree with your charictarization of Fred. Its unfair and elitist considering what others on the opposite side of the political spectrum do on this site to the Freds of this world. Again, Thanks.

Monda jan thanks very much

Monda jan thanks very much for your kind words...I appreciate it more than you can imagine...

Ba Arezu-ye Movafaghiat, Sadegh

Monda jan thanks very much

Monda jan thanks very much for your kind words...I appreciate it more than you can imagine...

Ba Arezu-ye Movafaghiat, Sadegh

Fred, marbarIRI, Asghar,

Fred, marbarIRI, Asghar, Kurdish warrior, and other guys, great responses to these sadegh and Q characters. These IRI apologists, Iran and U.S hater anti semites. As we see these days with the vicious attack by the IRI officials on the Israeli people since one of them came out and say we are friends with Israeili people, and all IRI murderors are calling the Israeili people all kinds of names which shows their true intentions of being not only anti government, but anti people themselves,...this sadegh guys posts an article about settlers actions in Palestine.

See the timing? Don'e ever get fooled when these people say they have problem with the governments only, these people are cold hearted, clash of civilization initiating Islamic fundamentalists apologizers.

Great Post Sadegh, as usual

Sadegh jon I LEARN from you! In fact your pieces are some of the first I look for when I'm here. I cannot fathom what it must be like to speak your mind as clearly and as passionately as you do, only to get bomborded by ignorant arrogance and in some cases pro-violence psudo intellectualls.

Please don't take their criticisms too much to heart by confronting every nonsensical judgment that they have to offer. SAVE YOUR ENERGY FOR YOUR FUTURE POSTS, INSTEAD!

I am looking forward to reading more of your views.

what happens happens...i'm

what happens happens...i'm not afraid of those fanatical pigs i.e. the IRI...

Ba Arezu-ye Movafaghiat, Sadegh

Sadegh: Why don't you post

Sadegh: Why don't you post those great articles here on this site???

Isn't it interesting that you have nothing to hide and you criticize the IRI and even travel to Iran without any fear??? I find that fascinating given regime's track record on murdering dissidents inside and outside of Iran.

I guess you're much braver than the rest of us...!!!????

Thanks Anonymous-Today

Thanks Anonymous-Today jaan, sound advice...very much appreciated...

Ba Arezu-ye Movafaghiat, Sadegh

allbright and all the other names you write under

This is obviously only a small sample - I have hundreds of posts and can't waste my time going through them all for someone who is simply trying to make me look a fool and failing miserably.

Start off here - here are posts regarding human rights violations inside Iran as documented by Human Rights Watch and others...

//www.eterazonline.com/search/label/human%20rights

//www.eterazonline.com/2008/08/documentary-blindfolded-witnesses.html

//www.eterazonline.com/2008/08/iranian-interior-minister-caught-out-on.html

//www.eterazonline.com/2008/08/three-university-students-released-from.html

//www.eterazonline.com/2008/07/crackdown-of-student-movement.html

This is a search on tags for 'Iranian dissidents' - includes discussion and article on the heroic Ahmad Batebi

//www.eterazonline.com/search/label/Iranian%20dissidents

//www.eterazonline.com/2008/08/lecture-by-abbas-milani-nuke-kooks-and.html

//www.eterazonline.com/2008/08/star-students-of-islamic-republic.html

There are many many others...go and look for yourself, unlike you I have nothing to hide...

Ba Arezu-ye Movafaghiat, Sadegh

Irandokht aziz

I never said that I will write an article. Occupied with issues could also mean to discuss articles or blogs. However now that you mentioned it and that you seem to be fan, you’ll be the 1st one to know once I publish one ;)
Ps Sadegh is def proud of you..

Dear warrior

I'm occupied with issues to do with our country instead.. Do you really think that writing couple of articles about Palestine on this site is really a contribution to Iranian.com

It's wonderful that you are working on issues about our country. I can't wait to read your articles on Iran!

IRANdokht

Sadegh aziz

YOU seem to be the expert on issues regards Palestine not me...I'm occupied with issues to do with our country instead.. Do you really think that writing couple of articles about Palestine on this site is really a contribution to Iranian.com ...If that's case, you are sad person..I feel sorry for people like you...

Two Wrongs doesn't make it right! Anyway...

Why comment about Iran in the post about Isreal? I tend to agree with the comment that no matter what the topic is, some manage to insert an anti-Iranian comment in there. And I think it is not to allow proper discussion of the topic they don't like. That is not fair to the other readers. But, I think this lessen the impact of their message and makes them look too biased. I tend to take their comment about Iran lightly than the others. I don't trust their agenda. Har nokta makony darad.

Peace

Sadegh,

don't be on the defensive. The people who are attacking you are not interested in a civil conversation. They wouldn't know civility if it reached up and kicked them in the pants. All they want is muddying the conversation and to character-assassinate. You are under no obligation to provide them with squat. You can't convince them of anything. This is an ideological war and no one should delude themselves that they can engage their nemesis in a rational conversation. They are fanatical and as such they think they have a monoply on truth, on Iranian-ness, on Iran and everything. And they are mostly philistines; the Shaholies and necon-oallhies. And yes, there are more than few Hezbaollhies on this site too. There's no shortage of vulgarians of various stripes on this site. My recommendation is write your pieces, speed-read the ones worth responding (and I don't mean just the complentary ones) and let the rest bark at what they want. It's good for your blood pressure and will not corrode your faith on writing for this site. Be cool, bro.

dear Sadegh

...have also spoken about the unlawful imprisonment of dissidents...only the other day I posted a story on the three students from Amir Kabir who were imprisoned for criticizing the regime

Can you provide us with the link to those articles on your site?? Thanks.

to: Kurdish warrior

However I wonder if he, who supports Palestinians so much will ever write about Hamas, Islamic Jihad and their supporters, on how they treat their own people in GAZA (beatings, killings and their Sharia law)...I really WONDER and can't wait to see an article about that.. After all Mr Sadegh and Q seems to be an expert on these issue......

You will never see them write anything critical of Hamas or Islamic Jihad...Their agenda is crystal clear and it has nothing to do with justice or fairness.