April 18, 2002
* Silence on Sahabi
I was very disappointed at coverage or lack of coverage
of Dr.
Yadollah Sahabi's passing away on your site. I could
only find one picture and that was the extend of it. However, There was a lengthily
piece on Shaban, the brain or more appropriately the useless. Perhaps you may care
to elaborate to your readers the lack of coverage or even a message of condolences
to Dr. Sahabi's family and all Iranians whose life have been touched by this national
treasure who devoted 80 years of his honorable life to teach and fight for freedom
and liberty inside Iran. I find it hard to belief where BBC, a non Iranian news agency
devote part of its coverage to talk about the death of Dr. Sahabi, Iranian times
cared less to bring this important event to its readers.
Dr.Sahabi was an astute activist of Iran's oil nationalization movement led by then
popular prime minister Mohammad Mosaddeq who provoked the ire of shah's court when
he secured passage of a bill at the Majlis (Iranian Parliament) in 1951 to nationalize
all foreign oil facilities in Iran. A university professor, he was a well-credited
writer and the Majlis deputy of Tehran in the first round after the Revolution. A
pioneer scientist and who is credited for establishing department of Geology at Tehran
university, and Daneshsaray Aali among other institutions. A frontier and pioneer
in National freedom movement of last century whose peaceful and nonviolence slogans
brought messages of condolences from opposition to right wing politicians across
the board.
Abbas F. Saffari
REPLY: What you see in iranian.com is what people send in. No one has written
anything about Sahabi. Any volunteers?
-- Jahanshah
Javid
To top
* Shaboon could have helped Venezuela
It may be a co-incidence that on the day an elected leader in South America rides
a popular movement back to power after a coup that was backed by big business and
cultural elite in Venbezuela, I read an article about Shaboon Beemokh [Shaban]!
As I saw clips of US officials spreading sour grapes over the failure of anti-Chavez
coup on the Sunday talkshow circuit, it became very obvious that US government was
extremely unhappy with the man's return.
After all, he had befriended Fidel Castro and visited Tehran and Baghdad on friendly
terms. And worst of all, Chavez was the only South American leader (beside Castro)
to oppose US military invasion of Afghanistan. How could such a man be the third
largest oil exporter to the United States?
Inspite of early reports, it became apparent that the majority of people were not
happy with Chavez' removal from power which caused the outpour into the streets in
huge numbers and clashes with the anti-Chavez military. About two dozen people were
killed in streets which resulted in the intervention of Chavez's old military buddies
from his days as a commander of Venezuela's paramilitary units (green berets). These
were the forces that finally brought him back to power in short order.
So, as I contemplated the impact of Venezuelan oil imports on US economy and US government's
official reactions to Hugo Chavez' unexpected return (a "second chance to do
the right thing"), I couldn't help but imagine whether or not Chavez would have
joined the ranks of Dr. Mossadegh of Iran if the organizers of this failed Venezuelan
coup had hired Shaboon Beemokh as an adviser and used his services again!
To top
* He belongs behind the bars.
Dear Iranian.com,
Shaban
Bi-Mokh does not belong to your front page. He belongs behind the bars.
Dr. Mossadegh belongs to your front page.
Dr. Faatemi belongs to your front page.
Dr. Sahabi belongs to your front page.
Dr. Makki belongs to your front page.
Dr. Yar-Shaater belongs to your front page.
Dr. Khoda-Doost belongs to your front page.
.
.
.
.
.
Bi-Mokh does not belong to your front page. He belongs behind the bars.
M. Taslim
To top
* She broke the taboo
Thank you very much for publishing the article about Shaban
Jaafari. I think the Lady Author, Ms. Homa Sarshar, has a lot of stamina & courage.
She has done a great job & service to our contemporary history, that no body
dared to examine. The power of mass intimidation kept every
body silent. She broke the taboo, that is real PAHLAVANI.
The same thing goes to Mr. Kadivar & his conversation with Dr. Majidi. So
much we yet have to know about the our past. Nothing should be over looked. We owe
a lot of explanations to our children for the fiasco we brought upon them.
You are indeed doing a marvelous job. This way you are paying a bit of
your own debt.
You have all my support & respect.
Yours Sincerely,
H.Hakimi,
Norway
To top
* I plan to read the book
I have not read Homa Sarshar's book about Shaban
Jafari yet, but I don't think Mr. Jafari has said it all, just reading about his
interviews with Mr. Maybody. (I hope I have the spelling of his name, right.) I plan
to read the book and will write to Mrs. Sarshar when Iam finished reading it.
E.Haerri (Farahpour)
To top
* Verbal incitement to terror
After Sept.11, while calling for "mass deportation" of Muslims, Syndicated
Columnist Ann Coulter stated that America "should invade their [Muslim] countries,
kill their leaders and convert them to Christianity."
Correct me if I am wrong, but isn't a blind (disabled) cleric serving a life sentence
for similar "verbal" incitement to terror. Why is Ms Coulter not facing
similar charges ?
M. Asadi
To top
* Exceptional Fisk
I am delighted to read Mr. Fisk article [Fear
and learning in America]. At least for once from a so called civilized world,
you hear someone who understands the problems in the Middle East and discusses them
with forthrightness and depth.
Brits themselves have had their finger in the kettle for a long time and still
do to a more limited scale. I watch BBC international news on the East coast but
I unfortunately don't see any better coverage than their US brethren.
It is sad to see Britain, with the exception of Mr. Fisk and a few other lonely
reporters, and US are hand in hand planning, arming and financially supporting Israel's
government aggression toward Palestinians.
I hope future historian will address this systematic aggression by the hand of
Israel and her blind supporters. I hope one day movies, documentaries are made and
books are written, similar to the plight Jew in the 40's, about injustices dealt
to Palestinians.
Respectfully.
Foad
To top
* Absurd exaggeration
Edward Said's contribution [Palestinians
will not go away] relies upon an absurd exaggeration: that the American media
is ignoring the views of responsible Palestinain spokespeople. The specific target
of Said's criticism is CNN but it clear that he implies this an issue througout the
USA media. Indiviiduals familair with the American as it exists today and not a couple
of decades ago, will probably quickly dismiss Said's inflated critisim--indeed inflated
to a degree that it bordes on a lie. Readers unfamilair with current USA media however
might take a respected academic like Said at his word. So for the record it should
be understood that respected Palestinian and Arab journalists, intellectuals, diplomats,
academics, etc. as well as ordinary people from the OT, regularly appear on CNN,
MSNBC, NPR, PBS, etc. as well in print in leading American nespapers and magizines.
In addition, Jews sympathetic to the Palestinians alse frequently appear in the USA
media.
Further, 99.9% of the Palestinian and Arab spokepeople who appear in the American
media present a united front leaving no one in doubt about what the "party line"
is. Only a select few like Prof. Ajami ever raise a criticism of the accepted Palestinian-Arab
claims. Prior to the first Intifada, frankly Said would have had an arguement i.e.
the Palestinian viewpoint wasn't given equal time with the Israeli one. Today, only
the most paranoid would believe that. In my own opinion, Said's criticism is so far
removed from reality that it is either drivien by ideologic preconceptions that are
imposed on the evidence no mater what it says or Said's real problem is that the
American media doesn't feature Edward Said and therefore it must (he believes) be
ignoring the Palestinian arguement.
Finally, I would again renew a request directed at Palestinian spokespeople and representives
like Prof. Said to expalin why suicide bombing is becoming the accecpted tactic of
combat by Palestinains? Why have we not seen a similiar wave of suicide bombings
among other peoples suffering from depression, militrary rule, and povetry. Not among
the peoples of Chipias, Mexico or Central America, or Tibet, or the Balkans, or among
the Kurds, etc. Acts of terrorism for sure but hardly any (if any) suicide bombings.
Unless that is accounted for Said et. al. are only offerign rationalizations and
not explainations.
William Baker
To top
* Arabs have themselves to blame
Several resolutions passed by the UN against Israeli treatment of Palestinians
have been ignored by Israel, with American backing. As the second most militarised
power in the world, Israel gives no qualms about the Arabs. It dictates to them what
kind of defence capability they should have, by blocking its allies--mostly Western
industrialized countries--from selling sophisticated arms to Arab countries. At the
moment, the Arab countries control the world's supply of fossil energy that powers
the economic machines of these countries. As such they should have commanded enough
clout to silence Israeli attempts to dictate to them.
Sadly, all these Arab leaders and their bureaucrats seem capable of thinking about
is their pockets, similar to most African leaders and their bureaucratic cronies
whose level of intelligence is only capable of taking them from their national coffers
to their pockets, and from their pockets to foreign banks to build foreign economies
at the expense of their own! They fall prey to the divide and rule machinations of
the allies of their number 1 enemy. Rather than developing their own workforce, they
waste money on expensive imported skills for almost every facet of work. They lack
the ability to foresee the danger in importing labour from their archenemy's allies,
thereby exposing their secrets to the bedrooms of their enemy, to their own chagrin
and destruction.
Today, Israel has the capability of wiping out at will all of its Arab neighbours.
That's why it disregards with impunity, every UN resolution aimed at bringing stability
to the region. Leaders who lack long-term vision for their countries and peoples.
They live in today for today, and nothing else but today. Rather than uniting under
the Arab League, like the OAU, the League has become the bedroom of foreign spies,
thus lacking independence in their decisions. The only forward-looking leader who
could help them stand up to their enemy and its allies, got sidetracked by greed,
pride and arrogance, and wasted its resources fighting his own Arab brothers rather
than working together to unite and strengthen their defence.
Like our African leaders and their cronies, I ask: how stupid can a people be?
Like their own camels, they allow themselves to be used like beasts of burden to
fuel other people's economies and way of life, only to be dumped merciless when they
are no longer needed. For I predict that in the next 25 years, mostly all of the
industrialized world will cease their dependency on fossil fuel, and you Arabs may
end up being worst than some of the least developed countries we know today, except
for your leaders and their cronies who stockpiled foreign banks with their people's
money. They see progressive members of their citizens as threats to their status,
and boot them out of their own countries, much to the joy of those countries that
benefit from their status quo.
I call on Arabs to rise to the occasion and unite for their own sake. Enough of
foreign power bootlicking.
Bestway Zottor
To top
* My money buys the bullets
To the Washington Post
Dear Editor:
How appropriate that Israel's latest refugee camp massacre in Jenin happened around
April 15th when we Americans pay taxes every year. Fellow Americans should take a
moment to reflect that 3 billion dollars a year goes to Israel as aid.
That means every person in Israel gets $500 per person every year courtesy of
you and me, the American taxpayer. Israel takes this money that we've worked so hard
to earn and uses it to buy tanks and helicopters from us and uses those weapons against
innocent people. I do not want to have anything to do with killing innocent people
anywhere in the world, for any reason. How do I, as a law-abiding taxpaying citizen
of this great country, not feel partly responsible for the atrocities occuring, when
it my money that buys the bullets.
Sepehr Haddad
To top
* No one deserves this
As a concerned individual, I am appalled by what I see done to Palestinians and
the little reaction from people here.
It is absolutely shameful how people can condone such treatment of poor Palestinians.
More over, Israel has the audacity to commemorate the Holocaust while at the same
time treating Palestinians with the same hatred and animosity. It is the same as
South Africa.
There is a rally organized by Jewish leaders to support Israel and by calling Arafat
a terrorist, give Sharon a green light to push Palestinians out of West Bank by killing
or misplacing them as they did in 1948 from their villages. Every ignorant and coward
politician will be there to show support and get the votes and contribution later.
There is no JUST policy in the US, as an example Cuba is vilified, yet China that
is occupying Tibet, killing people for organ parts is a major trading partner and
is "ENGAGED".
The Iranian community all over the US should organize themselves and demand a better
treatment of Palestinians and ourselves.
The politicians only know votes and money. We pay taxes just like anyone else, portion
of our taxes help Israel kill Palestinians. If we are not united like the Jewish
community, they will incite the US government to blame everything on Iran as they
have been doing for the past 25 years.
Everyone says Arabs have lousy leaders, it is time we as Iranian citizens of this
nation demand our rights as citizens and find some courageous leaders to voice our
concerns. Send emails and letters to politicians, echo the massacres done by Israeli
army in the West Bank. We need to show the Palestinian's miserable existence.
No one deserves to be treated this way, we should defend any race or creed under
siege.
I hope to see some reaction from Iranians in the USA. It is time to crawl out of
the holes we dug up and hid for the past 25 years from the shame of the revolution
and voice our concerns about mislabeling and mistreating innocents.
Bahram Hashemi
To top
* Gutless U.S. news media
Dear Mr. Hodges, [Misreading
U.S. intentions]
With regard to your article of April 18, 2002, in the Iranian, my impression is
that it is you, and your cohorts who are probably receiving your research grants
from sources who tell you what to write, who have been misreading the U.S. population
intentions. How is it possible, you may ask yourself, that U.S. population whose
primary intention is to help EVERY human groups on this earth, is against Palestinians
who are being massacred by a bunch of murderer Israelis (a very small segment of
that country, in that)?
You being a professor and researcher, I assume, should know better that the massacre
that is taking place in Palestine is not what US population wants or desires. The
only reason that it is taking place is the gutless U.S. news media who do not report
it accurately to U.S. population, and even less gutless (if that is possible) professors
and researches like yourself who, perhaps because of payments you receive from Israelis
and their lobbyist, are trying to justify it. All I can say now is: Shame on you!
I am sorry that while Maryland tax payers are paying your salary to teach the truth,
you are not telling the truth to everyone against the original intentions of your
masters!
M. H. Farzin
To top
* Right versus wrong
My hat off to you for defending the right versus wrong!
Sharon gives, the prospect of another Hitler! Sharon has never represented the real
jewish people who, for hundreds of years have lived, done business and even married
Arabs and Palestinians. He does not represent the ordinary jews among whom I have
had some of my best friends. My resentment is for hypocritical Jewish leaders like
Sharon who are wolves in sheep's clothing. Ironically the name of this hypocrite
means "peace"instead of war and war monger. I wonder
how the decent jews could stand the sight of this life-long terrorist-much less electing
him as prime minister. I guess every nation should deal with a curse like Sharon
so they don't take their blessings for granted.
The whole saga of Arab Israeli war revolves around selfishness, money and power
both internally and externally by those whose only motive is making money and selling
arms no matter at what cost to humanity. One would think that the tragedy of holocaust
was enough lesson for the jews to be careful not to give more reason for hatred for
jews in the world, but apparently corruption and hypocrisy once again have had the
upper hand. As for me, I do hope that the jewish people who refused to respond the
call of Sharon to fight this war will be the seeds of new generation of jews who
not give an excuse to another Hitler. It is typical of absolute dictators to resort
to quick fixes like thinking that bombing and ruthless extermination will put an
end to aspirations of the people.
I also resent our double standard policies of fighting terrorism that is actually
supporting the brand of terrorism that we like. I am bothered by the fact that we
only pay lip service to fighting terrorism. I had read eslewhere that annual stipend
that Isreal receives from America is $3 billion. Your figure of $5 billon is even
more outrageous. This amounts to about $14 million per day for support of terrorism.
We must either not have any use for that money or support of terrorism has priority
over education, health care and welfare of the American taxpayers. As long as we
endorse such atrocities, there is little or no chance of ending terrorism no matter
how much of taxpayers money we spend in the name of rather than stopping terror.
Ali Parsa
To top
* Sharon should be placed on trial
For the past 50 years, a genocide has been taking place in the occupied Palestine.
Many foreigners have invaded that country, and displaced the Palestinians and Arabs
who had lived there for over 50 generations. The American and British Imperialists
established a racist, zionistic, and genocidal occupying force in the region. America
is the only country in the world that supports its creation in the Occupied Palestine.
The genocide that has taken place in the refugee camps recently is only the tip
of the iceberg. Hundred of poeple have been murdured, and their corpses burried in
mass unmarked graves by the Zionistic murdurers. In addition, millions of Palestinians
have been displaced from their homeland by the occupying force present in Palestine.
And finally, the head of the racist establishment, Sharon, continues his genocidal
actions. The UN, the European Union, and the entire world has condemned the genocide
that is taking place in Palestine. In fact, the American government is the only country
in the world that supports the racist occupying force present in Palestine.
Sharon should be placed on trial for genocide and crimes against humanity. The
occupying presense in Palestine has forced teenage girls to blow themselves up. The
question is: what are they doing to these people, that it would force them to blow
themselves up with dynamite, rather than enjoy their childhood like other children
around the world? In the hope of a free Palestine, and the expulsion of all foreigners
from the region.
Hooman Golshan
To top
* LONG LIVE PALESTINE
In response to: Children
of genocide Ms. Fariba Amini states: "Suicide bombings only began when
Prime Minister Sharon, ignoring UN resolutions, continued building Jewish settlements
in Palestinian territories. In this whole affair, no doubt, Sharon will be the loser"
FIRST: every statement is either an action or a reaction SECOND: one must first
ask the question is this AN ACTION OR A reaction. THESIS: THIS is a reaction. BECAUSE:
1- "suicide-bomings" did not begin "when" a CRIMinal was elected
to office but, that it began from the very inception-conception of that "office".
2- in this "affair" no doubt the bad-seed IS "THE LOSER".
PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE
PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE
LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG
LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE
PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE
LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG
LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE
PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE
LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG
LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE
PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE LONG LIVE PALESTINE
LONG LIVE PALESTINE
Faramak Zahraie
To top
* Not war between Islam and Judaism
In response to one of your readers:
I do not believe this is a war between Islam and Judaism [Children
of genocide]. It is not a war between two ideologies. but a war between the
aggressor and the oppressed. It is a war between those who want EVERYTHING and those
who want their land, their homes and their self-respect back. It is a war between
justice and injustice.
You should not and are not allowed to threaten people with death as you have at the
end of your statement. Killing people will not solve anything. If that is the case
then Hitler should have won but he didn't. And Sharon will not win either.
People will come together very soon., and will live in peace again. Love will conquer
hatred.
Fariba Amini
To top
* Give New Mexico to Mexico
Dear Cowtipper, [Seems
dumb]
I did not quite get what country YOU are from by that comment. But from the part
including Iranians in Arab world (while neither one agrees with you on that) I believe
you are one of those Midwest middle class Americans calling our precious country
Eye ran. Well since you said yourself that what is a big deal about taking lands
and adding to your territory why not start with the closest country here.
Let's practice it by giving New Mexico to Mexico. After all they have a common
name and it seems appropriate enough. Or how about Alaska? It's to far and too cold
and who cares if Canada claims it as a part of it's land. One last thing why don't
you check your world map one more time and see whether the Israelis really do have
More land and More People or not.
I am not an anti semantic nor am I a fanatic Muslim but when the facts are ignored,
and along CNN and NBC and all the rest of the media the only ones we condemn are
the Palestinians for what's happening in that region and being dumb enough to say
that defending your land is dumb, then even I (who has not written her mom for months
- I call her all the time don't send me any hate letters!!!!) would want to reply.
Sorry that it was a very long reply but...
Sheila Dadvar
To top
* Iranian or Arab?
After reading Ms. Nezami's article "Marathon
woman", the first question that comes to mind is whether this person
is Iranian or Arab Palestinian(the latter seems more likely based on the content
of her writing). I am muslim, yet I feel sickened that someone wearing a hejab represents
my Iran. It is truely an embaressment to what my country and culture stand for. Not
only that, but she also makes an emphasis about representing the ISLAMIC REPUBLIC
of Iran.
The hejab has nothing to do with Iranian culture or Iran, yet Ms. Nezami makes
it seem so. This is the type of impression we don't want to give foriegners, yet
no matter how hard we try there will always be people like Ms. Nezami. Please leave
the hejab off next time, we have enough bad publicity as it is!
Kamran Shariati
To top
* Iranians who care
It's good to know that there actually exist Iranians who care about the plight
of the Palestinian people. Inshallah Movafagh bashin. [Marathon
woman]
Helia Azimi
To top
* We should learn from Europeans
I applaud your courage in showing your support for the Palestinian people [Marathon woman].
It is amazing that while most of the world are outraged by what is happening to the
Palestinians, most Iranians in the United States have been silent. Even the Iranian
televisions tip toe around the issue and are careful not to say anything pro Palestinian.
As if they are afraid to be labeled, God forbid, "anti Israeli"! We should
learn from the European leaders who have been strongly opposing Israel's occupation.
I wish you good luck and Gods speed in your race.
Rahele
To top
* I sympathize with Palestinians too, but...
I read in disgust what Azin Nezami wrote "I will be running with hejab....covering
my hair and claiming strong and proud, who I am, where I'm from,..." [Marathon
woman]
Although I wish Azin the best of luck in her marathon event, claiming who you
are and where you're from by wearing hejab says that you are muslim, not necessarily
Iranian. You say that you wanted to wear your country's colors, from the "Islamic
Republic of Iran?" It is a disgrace that Iran has a a muslim flag with foreign
letters in it. It is definitely NOT a flag that represents me as an Iranian and NEVER
will. I have competed in Olympic style Taekwondo in the past under the true Iranian
flag, but I have never personally recognized that pathetic Islamic flag (neither
does anyone I know) that has misrepresented my country and it's beautiful heritage
since it's introduction by these idiot fundmentalists.
The Islamic Republic's flag is a RELIGIOUS FLAG, NOT AN IRANIAN FLAG. If you want
your "roots to be known to everybody", then make sure you know what they
are and do it the right way. I know many great Iranian athletes, but they do not
go around trying to portray themselves as representatives of an oppressive, despotic
Islamic Regime. I sympathize with the Palestinians too, but they have nothing to
do with our heritage or culture. WE ARE IRANIAN, NOT ARAB!!
Soheil
To top
* Great to see an Iranian woman who is not afraid
Dear Azin,
You are truly an inspiration [Marathon
woman]. So great to see an Iranian woman who is not afraid or ashamed to
stand up for what she believes. Indeed, so strong and so proud. More power to you.
I wish I was in Boston so I could root for you there but from California I will pray
for you and hope your message makes its way. May peace and justice prevail, in Palestine
and in the heart of every human.
Safoora
To top
* Viva to you
Azin,
Your piece "Marathon
woman" brought tears into my eyes. I'm deeply touched by your devotion
and belief. I'm only sorry that I won't be there to cheers for you. As a former runner
and ex-Bostonian, I know exactly what you are talking about. I've been there and
witnessed so many proud runners from all over the world completing in this historic
event. Although, never was fortunate enough to qualify for this run, but have felt
the determination and energy of thousands of participant in Boston marathon. It'll
a mighty task to run with Hejab through ups and downs of Boston suburb.
Certainly you are not the first and won't be the last Iranian who compete in this
event, but surely you'll be the first Iranian to display such needed support for
innocent Palestine. Viva to you for voicing your political conviction and religious
belief through the sport. Viva to you for not being afraid of having thousands of
bystanders to stair at you. I can only imagine how proud you'll feel as you stride
toward the finish line in downtown Boston. Rest assured, your action would speak
loud and clear to those who are awake and those who are pained by the suffering of
Palestine.
Abbas Saffari
To top
* I don't understand
I read your article on the Iranian and would like to wish you good luck in the
marathon [Marathon
woman] but I also saw your picture with your lab members on:
//www.jhu.edu/%7Egazette/2001/may2901/29hiv.html
There is one thing that I don't understand here.
If you believe in hejab why aren't you wearing any head scarf in the picture and
if you don't, why are you going to run with hejab and why do you talk about it with
such a pride and enthusiasm?!
Are you just pretending something here? This hejab thing was not invented to be
worn just on one marathon day. It is supposed to be with you for a life time you
said you are covering your hair and claiming who you are....
Sorry to say this but I think what you are doing is lying to all the world about
who you really are. people in Iran are suffering because of people like you, people
who there is a big difference between what they say and what they do. isn't it what
is very popular in Iran these days? Are you sure you know who you are to claim it?
Neda
To top
* Hejab is not Iranian
I read the very poetic and a bit melodramatic piece by Mrs. Nezami [Marathon
woman]. As an Iranian woman I feel pride and joy for any accomplishment I
become aware of . Although I admire her accomplishments I was not quite sure what
she expected us to do. Are we supposed to be cheering her because she is representing
Iran? Then, I am all for it.
However, that was not my impression (may be because I am not a John Hopkins graduate!).
If she is asking us to cheer because she is wearing a hejab then, I have a problem
being patriotic because Hejab is not Iranian. It has been forced on many women. I
respect her choice of wearing Hejab because that is a matter of personal choice.
But, please don't tell me Iranian should line up the street and cheer because
you want to bring attention perhaps to Palestinian causes. That is an honorable cause
but let's keep things in perspective. Promoting Iranian causes should be kept purely
Iranian and religion should be kept out it. After all, we have many patriotic Iranian
citizens who belong to a different faith.
Regards
Azam Nemati
To top
* Thank you for opening the door
I just want to congratulate you on your wonderful and eye-opening article, "Aghaye
Hosseini". Your action and your decision to write this piece was courageous,
admirable and revolutionary. Thank you for opening the door for many other Iranians,
men and women, who have been abused and are scared to say anything. It is about time
for our society to talk about issues such as sexual abuse and start healing itself.
Congratulations and thanks,
Gita
To top
* Stories of abuse defied belief
Satareh Jan, [Aghaye
Hosseini]
My uncle Farokh was head of forensics for the province of Khorasan. The stories of
abuse we used to here defied belief. Your enlightened perspective about the abuser
and victim are very, very refreshing.
You lso write beautifully.
Siamack
To top
* I too was abused
A courageous piece and very well written indeed [Aghaye
Hosseini]. I particularly like your reasons for wanting to sit down with
him after all these years.
It is quite remarkable how - when we are able to find the appropriate alignment between
the mind and the feelings - we are able to discover the magical affinity between
our "humanity" and our "genuine" wish for understanding.
I too was abused by a trusted laleh when I was seven.
Thanks.
Behrouz
To top
* Flogged and shot
Everytime I get a mail from Iranian Times, 8 out of 10 of them I delete; knowing
that there is nothing to read about. But there was something about this email that
kept me from not deleting it, I would delete all the other mails that came from Iranian
times but not this. Even today I got a mail from Iranian Times and I deleted it and
left this, finally I opened this email thinking that the heading which reads Aghaye
Hosseini would be something religious (I am a lil religious). But was shocked
to read what you had written, I can't imagine such people who have signs of such
religiousness and I don't know how else to describe them would stoop so low there
is no word to describe them, I think even the worst Curses would not be enough for
such f****ing idiots. I think such people should be flogged and shot in front of
a firing squad.
But I think you did a pretty good job in writing this article, it surely proves
to us that there is no such thing as perfect human being. Even these clergies and
Mullahs who preach about Islam and unity and piousness are not what we percieve them
to be. You have opened a pandora's box and I hope that there will be several more
articles like this, which surely was an eye opener. I myself have been victim of
sexual abuse when I was about that age and I think I do not have any clear memories
about what happened to that guy. But more than the sexual abuse it was about men
who pretend that they are the holiest of all and that they are next to the Holy Prophets,
they go sit on Membar and talk about Islam's history and unity of the 70 soldiers
who died for Imam Hussain. I mean they just talk, they don't practise what they preach,
There is one such incident over here.
I live in San Jose - CA and when I first came down to US in Jan 2000, I used to
go to the Masjud with my Bro in Law, and the Mullah over there used to offer sermons
etc. One day he has a fight with the Masjid Committee and deicides to have his own
Masjid and his own set of followers, I mean is this how they preach Islam and unity.
Well thats a long story I would not venture into that but someday I will have an
article about this so called Mullah who runs a masjid over here because now he has
total control over it.
Anyway Bravo to you. It was a very enlightening Article.
Ba Salaam
MAB
To top
* You are very strong
Thank you so much for posting your writings [Aghaye
Hosseini]. I am so proud of you "Shir Dokhtar". I am especially
amazed at how you have taken away that man's power.
I have always said that when something horrible happens it is as if someone has
written a blank check on your accout. You cannot change the fact that the check was
written but you can decide the price you will pay.
You are very strong. You are a wonderful,amazing person. Bless you. I am sure
you have prevented so many children from this happening to them. By opening their
protectors eyes.
Thank you so very very much.
JZ
To top
* Humbled and speechless
Jesus christ, you are a shir zan for having written that "Aghaye
Hosseini". I am humbled and speechless and don't know what t say, except
to say that I can't imagine a more gentle, courageous and unusual approach to such
a difficult subject as molestation.
L
To top
* For those who think Iranians have
no faults
Dear Setareh, [Aghaye
Hosseini]
I'd like to take this opportunity to congratulate you for your courage and honesty
in describing your childhood, especially revealing such an import and significant
event. I read your story perhaps a week or so after it was published (I don't read
the newsletter on a daily basis).
And since then, I often think of you and that evil man Hosseini. It is sad to
say that there are many Hosseini-type people who live in our country of origin, and
they continue victimizing innocent boys and girls. Unfortunately, not many reveal
their abuse for the sake of protecting family Aaberoo, and that the victims are often
the ones who are blamed.
I so much so wished that a former friend of mine, who is an American-educated
physician practicing in Colorado, would read your article. He is a type who thinks
Iranians have no faults whatsoever.
Several years ago, when one evening, my wife and I and then our one year old daughter
were visiting this gentleman and his wife, somehow our conversation digressed into
family secretes and issues such as incest. My former friend began lecturing us that
incest did not exist in Iran and these issues were only part of American culture
(in contrast to what I read in your article that American school actually saved you).
And of course, he went on bashing the U.S. for its flaws, etc.
He based his opinion on his emergency room experience, where he had frequently
tended incest victims. My wife who is a psychologist and had worked with these issues
for many years gently suggested that incest and other sexual innuendoes were common
nearly everywhere in the world.
However, my former friend, who by the way had not seen Iran after the age of 17,
adamantly denied and continued insulting Americans before my wife and his wife who
both happen to be Americans. Needless to say that was the last time we saw them.
(I absolutely agree with you and have no doubt that not only Mr. Hosseini himself
had been molested as a child, he perhaps had molested his own children as well.)
But that is not what I wanted talk about. I was pre-occupied with feelings of
much disgust toward Hosseini after I read your story. That evening when I got home,
I saw my daughter who is now 8 years old and suddenly it dawned on me that she is
just about your age when Mr. Hosseini violated you. As if I was hit by a huge rock
-- my anger toward Hosseini multiplied.
When later my daughter who had trouble sleeping alone in her room and wanted me
to lie down next to her, all I could think of was that how could a person sink so
low that he feel entitled to violate such innocent souls. My daughter fell fast asleep
as she put her head on my chest.
I wondered whether your enjoying Hosseini's touches was really an attempt to be
close to a father figure since your own father, as many fathers were (and still are),
wasn't available. I thanked God for the safety of my daughter and prayed that no
innocent children be victimized again. And I thank you for writing such a frank and
eye-opening article.
I also admire your mother for supporting you and sharing her story with you when
you found the courage to no longer keep it secret.
Regards
BH
To top
* Silence is more torture for the children
I just wanted to tell you how truly brave and amazing you are [Aghaye
Hosseini]. Your wrote the truth of your story with so much honesty and openess,
that must have been so hard to do and yet you had the courage to do it. You don't
know how many lives you will touch with your honesty. There are so many children
in all cultures and of all races who are being hurt by molestation and child abuse.
The silence of a culture makes it more torture for the children. Because, if no
one talks about it, then who will believe a child if he or she tells. You were so
brave to tell and a Hero to talk about it in a culture where things like that are
not usually spoken of. I too was molested as a child, I have spoken out about it
and child abuse in this community, I am not sure if people believed it could happen
in this or any other culture besides American.
As the manager for a famous Persian singer, Siavash (Shams), I have had an oportunity
to speak to so many young people and the troubles they face are real, but they are
usually afraid to speak out and the more people like you speak out, the more lives
you are saving. Your courage will give others courage and the safety to know they
are not alone, they are not the only one and they can survive and do great things.
Thank you so much for your braveness. You are helping so many persian youth and
educating the parents to understand and listen to and believe their children.
Fondly,
C.A.C.
To top
* Careful with approaching Mr. Hosseini
Dear Ms. Sabety, [Aghaye
Hosseini]
I would like to join the many individuals who have sent you messages of congratulations
and praise. It took a whole lot of courage and it was the best thing you could have
done for yourself, more than anyone else!
If you don't mind, here a couple of thoughts I would like to share with you. I
know you have made piece with your parents and their role (or lack there of) in what
happened to you. My opinion is that what you have shared with us is more than anything
else a therapeutic measure for your soul but for the rest of us it is a prime lesson
in parenting!
I would also be careful with approaching Mr. Hosseini in Iran. If you have to
go for it and do it, don't tell him it's for a book or article or in any way for
public consumption. Tell him that you have to talk to him for your own healing and
closure. Approach him by putting him in a guilty sphere so that he will feel obligated
to talk to you as a way to make it up to you. I can assure you that he won't talk
to you if you even hint the possibility of his feedback being shared with anyone
besides you and him. After you have spoken to him, then you can send him what you
will have written about him and solicit his blessing for publishing, etc.
Just my two cents.
BB
To top
* Should have been castrated
Dear Setareh, [Aghaye
Hosseini]
I am very sorry and angry to read this letter of yours.
Thankfuly you have overcome the problem. I believe, mr hoseini must have been casterated
for what was done so as your parents for negligence. Please see into your dates as
you are 41 now and went to Iran few years ago, say 10 years ago, then mr.hoseini
must have been about 72 years old working for the komiteh. I go to Iran very often
and never seen many at that age working particularly that kind of job, apart from
beggars of course.
All The Best.
S. B.
To top
* Mom failed
I admire Mrs. Sabety's courage in coming to terms with such a painful memory [Aghaye
Hosseini]. I have a problem with the fact that her mother (despite having
been abused herself) did not try to warn or shield her. I had told my son from the
age of two about these matters.
When we moved to San Francisco in 1991 an incident took place that I hope encourages
parents to never think their children are too small to understand. I had just moved
to an apartment building and went to one of the neighbors to ask a question. She
was very pleasant and so was her husband and they offered to baby-sit if I needed
it.
A few nights later I went to their apartment and while I was talking to her regarding
a matter, her husband asked my then 5 years old son (who was admiring the baby pictures
on the wall) to see the rest of the pictures in the other room. Within minutes my
son came and held my hand and said in Farsi let's go home. I knew something was wrong
because he always addresses me in Farsi in front of non-Persians if the matter is
personal.
He told me that Larry (our neighbor) had placed his hand on his own Talla (penis)
and then had asked my son if he wanted to see Larry's Talla without his pants. My
son had told him that a man should not show his Talla even to his mom and ran out.
You can see that even at such young age he knew the difference. For an educated lady
Mrs. Sabety's mom failed her and she is as mush to blame for her daughter's suffering
as the very sick Mr. Hosseini,
Azam Nemati
To top
* Honesty and courage
Dear Setareh,
I highly admire your honesty and courage in your article "Aghaye
Hosseini". I think you're not the only one who had such a secret. I
assume all people have had times in their lives who they feel scared or feared to
talk about or even share it with their closest friend. You are extremely courageous,
open and honest and thanks for sharing part of your life with us.
Cheers to you and thanks again,
Sahar
To top
* Doesn't matter where one is from
Just wanted to let you know what an excellent article you wrote for the Iranian
titled "Priceless."
It fits my views now and fit them back in the 1970's. It just goes to show it really
doesn't matter where one is from... youth and maturity are similar no matter where
one is from.
Take care,
Bev Pogreba Karami
To top
* I realllllyyyyy loved it
As always, continuing to do a great job with your site. I realllllyyyyy loved
the short story you published today the one by Arash Emamzadeh [Flushing
sabze down the toilet].
For some reason I had missed all his previous
features. I just finished reading them all and I am blown away by how talented
this guy is. I just wanted to thank you once again for the great job you are doing
publishing all these wonderful diverse articles, from fiction to poetry, to satire.
(Sorry for gushing!)
Niki Tehranchi
To top
* Magnificent interpretation
Dear Saman,
You did it again. Where did you get such a clever ideas for a magnificent interpretation?
My heart congratulations to you.
H.Hakimi,
Norway
To top
* No, fuck you
Remove this article it is fucken bull shit full of crap [Ali].
you anti irani american fuck. you should be ashaimed of yourself. like in iran they
would dare to rape women. they get fucken stoned to death.
fuck you and your propeganda bull shit site. i wonder why iran and it reputation
is so fucked over here. well the answer is obvious it is because of you fucken dumb
as "khodforokhteh".
American ass kisser. Fuck you sir.
Ali Ahmed
To top
* Not another John Nash
Hi Niki!
You are the one with the gift [Ali].
You definitely have a knack for telling a yarn! I truly don't think Ali was delusional.
His lying may have resulted from a feeling of alienation. You don't need to worry
that he is another John Nash (Beautiful Mind).
By the way , why did you spell" rumor " as "rumour"? Was it
a slip? You know that words like 'honor', "labor"etc are spelled without
a "u" in the U.S.
Sincerely,
PM
To top
* Happened to me too
Your right on the money [Ali].
Exact same thing has happened to me. It would be interesting to find the routes of
this problem with Iranians.
Good luck.
Azad
To top
* Pathological liar
In response to the article Ali
I must say I have a relative who is also a pathological liar. I am not sure she realizes
what she is doing but she sure exaggerates everything to the power of 10. For instance
the day Americans defeated Iraqis in 1991 I talked to her on the phone before I hear
the news from Television. She went as far as saying that the Americans have captured
Baghdad and I believed her! But through the years I have learned that she exaggerates
everything. Therefore, I don't trust anything she says.
I was in her house the morning of September 11 2001. She came and awakened me
and told me that New York has been attacked and the towers have collapsed. To tell
you the truth I did not believe her. To me she was exaggerating again. Only when
I got up and watched it on TV did I believe her! My family members have asked her
to go to a Doctor and seek helped, but she won't do it!
Ali-Reza Kasra
To top
* Pissing my pants
I just read it (two weeks later) [Who
wants to marry a...] and I am pissing my pants with laughter....you are good!
Really good! Have you thought about writing plays? You have distinct voices for both
Amanpour and this priceless creation, Mr. Davi Nasser!
L
To top
* Extremely proud
How very exciting and wonderful [Junior
Jiant]. As a "hamvatan" I feel extremely proud and wish you and
your team all the success you deserve. I will recommend your site whenever I talk
to those who have teenagers and don't know what programs there are for their summer
vacations. And I will start right now to tell my sister who has a 16 year old daughter!
All the best,
Shahla Samii
To top
* Thank you
Thank you so much for putting the article on your site [Junior
Jiant]. I have never gotten so much feedback from an article then the one
you put up. How are things? Keep in touch... thank you.
Saied Ghaffari
CEO
JuniorJobs.com
To top
* Women's only REAL accomplishment: children
Dear Azadeh, [That
torsheedeh feeling]
You are right to say that "marriage isn't the only accomplishment in your life".
But you miss a point. The only REAL accomplishment of a life, either for a woman
or for a man, is her (or his) children. And in our culture (like many others) having
children means building a family. And building a family begins, generally, with marriage.
So please, don't pass by it. Build your family and then you will understand that
all other accomplishments (professional, scientific, etc;) can't campare to it.
Good luck
MA
A father with a lot of accomplishments in his life.
To top
* Hooloo!
Dear Azadeh, [That
torsheedeh feeling]
I think you are quite underestimating the long opportunities ahead of someone at
your age (25) before she can be called impolitely "Torsheedeh."
Torsheedeh is generally implied to perhaps an unmarried woman at about age 35 and
above, or if she is really plain looking then perhaps a little sooner. I don't think
being shaven is a total answer to feminism either. However think about Russian women,
they don't shave either, and as the result men turn into alcoholism to escape the
reality!
Now a days women even above 40 think about getting married for the first time and
having children thanks to artificial insemination and many other alternatives. I
think at your age (25) no man would call a girl Torsheedeh. To the best of my knowledge
the proper descriptive name for that age is HOOLOO!
Enjoy your twenties and the years that follow.
F.A. Ashtiani
To top
* Ezdevaj esarat neest
neveshteye shoma ra khandam , [That
torsheedeh feeling]
pishnahad mikonam ezdevaj ra ba esarat va khane neshini motaradef nakonid va ezdevaj
nakardan ra azadi va harekat na namid !!! behtar ast be jaye tagheere negaresh be
sene ezdevaj be eslahe darke zendegie moshtarek be pardazid o kooshesh konim dar
har khanevadeh ey ke tashkil mishavad har do taraf be haghe zendegi va entekhabe
masire zendegie moshtarak eteghad dashteh bashand. sene ezdevaj mohem nist , balke
negaresh be khanevadeh va hamsar mohem ast ke shayad niaze be eslahati dashteh bashad
be har hal in ham nazare man ast va khosh halam ke vaght sarf kardid va shenidid
movafagh bashid
peyman-rajabi
To top
* Time for a voice in literary world
My name happens to be Sarvenaz
too. I'm... a writer and student. It's very bizarre to read about someone else with
these similarities! Anyway, I just wanted to tell you that you have some very interesting
points in your work. Have you ever been published or thought of publishing?
I am firmly of the belief that it's time for Iranian women to get a voice in the
literary world.
Anyway, good luck with everything!
Sarvenaz
To top
* Sarvenaz getting married
LI LI LI LI LI LI LI LI LI LI LI LI I I I I I I I I I I [Almost
genetic]
Hamsayeh ha ro khabar konin....
Varjoone
To top
* Wish you had not accepted his proposal
Even though, it is selfish on my part, still I wish you had not accepted his proposal
as I was really enjoying reading your writings [Almost
genetic]. This is partly to my admiration for hearing out an Iranian female
sexual fantasy and the fact that they are just as capable, but mostly due to your
increditable writing skills.
M&M
To top
* I totally understood
I loved part 10 of Sarvenaz' ongoing tale of her life (I assume it is at least semi-autobiographical,
but pardon me if I'm assuming wrongly)... it was sweet in its honesty. I totally
understood becoming monosyllabic in the face of declared love, of being swept up
in the tidal wave of love, of a time and a place - and a person - becoming everything...
Trish Lewis
To top
* You don't like Iranian men
Sarvenaz,
I must admit your articles in The Iranian took me by surprise. I have never look
at desire satisfaction from female point of view in depth. Please don't take wrong
sex is a two way street and in my point of view both satisfaction indicates positive
end results.
I did read almost all of your posted articles. There was something in there that
I could not put my finger on. Oh, than it hit me. You don't like Iranian men do you.
Sincerely,
R.
To top
* To get close to them or...?
Dear Mr. C Kadivar, [No
regrets]
I wonder , why you always interview the most disliked and hated people of the
last regime. Is it a way for you to get close to them and / or their unaccountable
money which was brought from Iran. What is the deal in here?
Thanking You.
S. Breheny
To top
* Greatest gift to our future
Regarding Kadivar's "No
regrets",
"Mirassi az gozashteh, armaghaani baraaye aayandeh."
"The greatest gift to our future is a connection to our past."
KEEP ON WRITING.... with best wishes.
Farhad Sepahbody
To top
* How many years has it been?
Salaam dAyi Jon,
I want to answer to your article "Harf-e
beepardeh". unfortunately don't have a Farsi software, would it be OK
to right in English and you turn it into Farsi??? You hit the spot about men's mentality
and virginity of women, but forgot to mention another big and serious issue that
perhaps it is more important to Iranian men than Virginity, the AGE of the woman!
I am sure that most Iranian population in US have checked the Iraniansingles sites,
where men , shamelessly aren asking for a woman at least 15 years younger than themselves,
why? Who gives them the right to ask for that, women! If most women say, you are
old for me, they would limit themselves to their own kind.
Of course, it could be that women are more pen-minded and don't value a relationship
based on numbers unlike men. Have you, GUYS, ever thought that if you were going
to college with someone and fell in love and married at the age of 23, you both will
be 56 at the same time (this sounds stupid and childish, but to some gentlemen, we
have to talk like a child to get through their heads).
As you said, dAyi jon, it is our culture and our up-bringing, but let's face it,
how many years has it been since we left Iran for better life and social conditions?
That's right, at least 20 years. How come the good part of western culture, freedom,
working conditions, dating American women is good, but when it comes to adapt or
change some of our own cultural shortcomings, we go back to Islam's conditions or
in other words, Asr-e Hajar! I think I said enough but hope that things will change
for better in next century!!
Parvin
To top
* Amazing
Has this guy published a book with these photos? [Story
with no ending] I think they are amazing!
Pedram
To top
* I just felt sad
Dear Samuel, [Story
with no ending]
I have seen your photos, and I have a complaint about the subject as an Iranian,
we have lots of interesting movements in our daily life in Iran. I live in a town
that is not a big city in Iran but still you can show the world so many more interesting
and strong points of my homeland, why you just zoomed on those typical scenes?
Well I just felt sad as you didn't take few more photos that show a happy life in
Iran.
Regards
Nadia
To top
* Flawed
With all due respect to Mr. Razavi's opinion [Sill
in denial] and his fine writing there are flaws in his thinking. If freedom
in gerneral is what Mr. Razavi is seeking in Iran, more political freedom will bring
even more sexual freedom.
Mr. Razavi wants to use the argument of morality with lack of political freedom
in Iran with his emotional writing about immoral acts by a few in Iran. But the truth
is that if the political freedom that he is seeking is attained, that will be augmented
with other freedoms. It is inevitable.
Farzod
To top
* Most prefer change without involvement
I wanted to thank Mr. Razavi for his article "Sill
in denial". I have not been back to Iran for eleven years, but I have
heard similar stories from young people who have gone back for a visit. It must be
hard for many young Iranian men (or women) who are visiting Iran to resist the temptation
of sexual opportunities offered to them by their special status.
But treating our country like a party paradise and a whorehouse every time we
go back for a visit will not help Iran. I think most Iranians want Iran to change
for the better, but most prefer that change to take place without their direct involvement.
This is particularly true for us Iranians outside of the country. We want Iran to
change, but we want to continue having a good time while that happens. That is an
understandable weakness, but significant change will not take place with that kind
of attitude.
N.A.
To top
* All of us versus IRI
Dear Mrs. Farjami, [We
forget that our true activists]
This is in response to your comments on Iranian.com regarding my article "The
Enigma of Reza Pahlavi".
First, most of what you raise in your letter has been answered in my article.
Regardless, I don't think anyone will know who the true representatives of Iranians
are until there is a referendum. Until such date, let us concentrate on actually
having a referendum.
I agree with you that our duty is first and foremost to support our brothers and
sisters who are jailed and tortured on a daily basis by the Islamic Republic. Reza
Pahlavi has been the most vocal critic of the treatment that our students have received
at the hands of the henchmen of the IR. This not an us versus them issue. It is rather
all of us versus the Islamic Republic.
Second, I disagree with your qualification of the Iranian Diaspora as "hypnotized,
manipulated and naive." All of the above are highly correlated with lack of
education.
For example, the Iranian emigre community in the United States are amongst the
most educated, professionally successful and socially prominent ethnic minorities
according to the US Bureau of Census statistics. You may want to read the following
article by Dr. Mehdi Bozorgmehr of UCLA for a detailed analysis.
"High Status Immigrants: A Statistical Profile of Iranians in the United
States." Iranian Studies 21: 5-36.Bozorgmehr, M., and G. Sabagh. 1988.
Third, you claim that the economic plight of rural Iran is no different today than
before the revolution. That is not correct.
According to a report published by the Iran Statistics Center and broadcast by
the IRNA on November 19, 2001. The annual income of rural households have dropped
by 20 percent between 1984-98.During the same period food expenditure has dropped
by by 18 percent for rural households.
Also in 1978, 33 percent of population were considered poor while currently 60
percent are below the poverty line.
I would happy to send you a copy of the report at your request.
Regarding the attitude of the youth in Iran vs Reaza Pahlavi. Below is an email that
I received from a 25 years old Iranian woman who has been in the US only for the
last few years. She was a medical student in Iran and was thrown out of school because
she used perfume! I am serious. She has now discovered a new gene and her article
was published in the prestigious Science Magazine last month. I have deleted her
name for purposes of confidentiality. It is an interesting perspective:
Considering that I have been living in Iran until 1996, and most of the other
Donkeys have not been in Iran for anyextended period since 20 years ago, I guess
I know what I'm talking about! Definitely the pre-revolution era has a big romantic
appeal in Iran now, and has had it ever since the Iran-Iraq war started.
I was very young, but I remember that was the first time after revolution that
people started to say loud that this disaster would have never happened had Shah's
regime not been overthrown. Later on, with people growing more and more disillusioned
with the new regime, Shah started to become sacred. People would pray for his soul
in their prayers, and I'm not joking.
My generation and those younger than me barely remember anything from Shah's era.
We think of it as a sunny, careless, idyllic period when people were so well off
they couldn't bear it. We always wondered what the hell it was that the revolutionaries
wanted. We thought they had everything under Shah: food, peace, freedom. To us, living
with food rations and mandatory scarves and Komite harassments and air-raids and
our fathers, brothers and boyfriends being sent to war, living in Shah's Iran was
like living in the best dream of our lives.
We asked our parents what the hell it was that they overthrew Shah for, and they
said freedom, and when we asked what freedom it was that they didn't have, they couldn't
say. They said there wasn't political freedom. It sounded pathetic. And it still
does. Like there's political freedom elsewhere. Most people my age find revolutionaries
ridiculous and irrelevant, both those of 1978 and those of now.
We have learned it the hard way that chaos is to be avoided at any rate. But then,
returning to monarchy doesn't sound like chaos to us, it sounds like something tested
and reassuring, like we know what it would be like. It's certainly silly to think
that a Pahlavi monarchy now would be like the one of pre-1978, but although logically
it's nonsense emotionally it has a certain appeal. It's certainly easy to sit here
and have lofty ideas about how things should be in Iran, but to be realistic, we
are IRRELEVANT.
The only opinions that matter are those of the people that currently live in Iran.
We are left out of the mainstream culture, and we don't belong anymore.
Mihandoust
To top
* Heeezome tar
Salam Dear Mr. Hakim, [Diplomatic
discourtesy]
Would you give us a background how this adverse mass media propaganda in Norway started
in 1960 that led to your experience?
Kodoom heeezome taree Iran yaa har irooni be Norveg saaleh 1339-1340 forookhteh bood?
(See reply below)
Ghorban shoma,
G.H. Massiha
To top
* Helping the West to tear us down
Dear Massiha, (See letter above)
Answer to your question is a lengthy affair, which takes too much time & energy,
I can not provide. I am indeed sorry for that. The adverse propaganda against our
country started immediately with the Nationalization of our OIL Industry & went
up to the down fall of our legitimate Head of State & disintegration of our national
identity & integrity. To their eyes the Iranian Nation had rubbed them off their
wealth. Mind you ( THEIR WEALTH )? [Diplomatic
discourtesy]
They never forgave the Shah, Mossadegh & on top of them the entire Iranian
Nation who stood fast the adversary. Nobody had soled any wet hey to Norwegians,
on the contrary we had a fantastic tow sided relationship. Yet, individuals where
constantly bombarded with adverse propaganda against our country. It got so intense
that even the high official of the Norwegian Government could not avoid or hide it.
My dear, Ham Vattan remember that WEST IS WEST, they are all together one way or
the other.
The situation gets worst when some of our own nationals also jump on the Band
Wagon. Our communists, toodeh party, confederation of students, mojahedin & very
many others had joined the west to tear us down. Our so called intellectuals were
blind to the flood of propaganda against us & they became ATESH BYAR MAAREKEH
!!!!! And if we protested, the westerners used to point to our own Nationals outrageous
propaganda against their own state. So as we say in Persian, it was ( TOFE SAR BALA
).
The result is, what the WEST wanted for so many years, from almost 1953, &
that is, to create instability all over the region so that they can buy much cheaper
Oil & sell all their defunct weaponry. As they did & are doing it under our
nose every single day. They crashed Iran, got revenge from entire nation & at
the same time thought a good lesson to the others to behave according to their will
& wish. Our example became a DAMOCLES' SWORD. And they have, to our indignation
& disadvantage succeeded. If we do not want to see it, it is our misfortune.
I wonder if you have read my two previous articles in the Iranian.com [Fatemi's
outburst, Oh
yeah? Take this]. Please do, since what I am writing is a series of the events
which are interwoven. Just yesterday I sent another part of my memoir to the Iranian.com.
I hope they will publish it for the benefit of the younger generation such as your
self.
H.Hakimi,
Norway
To top
* Support Reza Pahlavi II
Spending his entire life with no purpose other then lead a nation, and educated
in universities across Europe and US, no one is more distinguished then Reza Pahlavi.
As my generation (18-30yr), continues to pay for the mistakes of our parents, one
can only imagine what could have been.
History is to learn from as the future is to find the elusive freedom. For those
of you who still have a picture of Khomeini and/or other self-distinguished religious
authority, wake up, it's time for you pay for allowing your brain to be washed and
supporting that which has always been evil. Reza Shah was patient with you, his son
even more; his silence has made a point of your failure no one can ignore, not even
you! We are on the brink of shaping our nations future for ourselves and for our
children.
Today our nation is more educated then ever, with devastating socioeconomic condition.
Act as one and support Reza Pahlavi II, not to rule but to establish a secular government
where we can choose. Support him to fulfill his life's destiny as he's been trained
to. He is a product of our countries investment, thus far wasted. Let us collect
on our investment and bring hope for the future. With much respect to our parents,
please excuse the fact that WE have to fix their mistakes.
A proud Muslim, for separation of state and religion,
Pouria Nouri
To top
* Idea for a new flag
Doostan,
While some "Iranians" seem recently to be more concerned about Palestine
than Iran, forgetting completely the part Yasser Arafat and his killers played in
the bloody Iranian Revolution, I keep having with a very dear friend the same usual
and long discussions about our beloved Iran and the future. We both agree that IRI
has completely failed in every political, human, economical, social -- and you name
it-- way. We both agree that this regime can never survive, and IRI will soon be
only a dark page of our long history!
Then, what comes next?
We believe that, rich of the experience we, Iranians, had in our recent history,
Iran will rise greater than ever. It is clear to both of us that, although not perfect,
Democracy is the only way to save Iran and guarantee every freedom for our people.
As members of this great Nation, we both have our dreams and ideas about the future.
To begin with, we believe that any type of regime should be the result of the popular
choice. Every Iranian, regardless of his/her political, ethnical or religious background
should participate, equally, in any decision concerning Iran. It is clear that we
must have a new Constitution based on our own cultural and historical realities,
which would not be a copy from any other foreign country.
Then, we believe that the only way to reach a real democracy is to have a "Secular"
regime, respecting, at the same time, all religions, and even atheists, equally,
under the same laws of the land. All the different ethnical minorities are the jewels
of the same crown! They all belong to the same culture, nation, enriching it and
completing it the same way as they did during our long and glorious history. Therefore,
within the Iranian family, they should also enjoy some rights and freedom in their
respective regions...
My friend and I never get tired to spend our time, over and over again, for years,
speaking about the same subjects, re-making our world as we believe just and beautiful.
The same kind of discussions about our homeland that, I am sure, many of you have
every day with your friends.
Our last conversation was about our flag. We
both believed that "Shir-va-Khorshid" must return on our national flag,
but some changes are necessary! First, the "Lion" should be Iranian; neither
British or African! We all know that some spices of lions used to live in Iran and
they were quite different from their African cousins. They are the ones that have
been used for thousand of years by Iranian artists, before the Afro-British lion
was introduced to our country during the last century!
Also, a lion is the symbol of power and majesty; it doesn't need to carry a sword
that is the symbol of war and brutality. More specially, if we wish to separate religion
from state, "Zolfaghar" must be given up, once and for all, by our lion!
Our flag should represent every Iranian, regardless of his/her background! A non-shiite-Muslim
Iranian also should be proud of his/her flag! Then, since Iran is made of different
ethnicities, they should also be represented on the flag as parts of our "universe".
A few days after this conversation, my friend who is also a great artist sent me
the attached design that I would like to share with all my compatriots, hoping that
one day, in a free Iran, it would be considered as an idea for a new flag, along
with a new Constitution. This flag is neither "Monarchist" nor "Republican",
but only Iranian and "Nationalist".
As you notice, the three colors, green, white and red do not have equal width.
My friend explained to me that the "White" has to be wider for a well balanced
logo. Therefore, he divided the width of the flag in 7; then, he used 2 for green,
2 for red, and 3 for white. I think this was a great idea, and I, personally, prefer
these proportions much better than what we are used to; the lion stands much better!
The number of the stars that represent different ethnicities around the sun, our
common culture, are just subjective on this drawing and not accurate; if one day
this idea is accepted by the majority of Iranians, the number of stars should be
corrected.
I think it would be a great idea for those who are for freedom and democracy in Iran
to use this flag as the "Flag of Unity", till Iran is liberated and a new
flag is adopted! I am very interested to know what my other countrymen and women
think about this idea and about this lion that I would like to name "Shir-Shahrokhi"
after my dear friend the artist.
Regards,
S.
To top
* Is this architecture?
I understand that due to the Islamic Revolution there has been a backlash of pre-Islamic
art form and culture that might look to some as a 'BREATH OF FRESH AIR'. But unfortunately
when I looked at the photos of the Dariush Hotel in Kish Island [Sign
of the times] I was not only proud but a bit ashamed to associate myself
anyway with this kitschiest o all the hotels. It looks like the American copies of
the Egyptian pyramids in the Las Vegas hotels which were built 20 years ago.
I would actually add rather sadly it is an Arabic interpretation of the once glories
of this nation!!! All over the world people are trying to minimise clutter and over
decorative pieces and today in the poverty stricken country of mine people are spending
huge sums of money to redo what 2000 years ago was done. WHAT FOR? IS THIS ARCHITECTURE?
OR IS IT A MEMORIAL TO THE DEATH OF SECULAR ARCHITECTURE IN THIS COUNTRY?
This has nothing to do with opposing the dominant Islamic culture with another
type of culture. this is following exactly what the most backward Islamic cult is
trying to push us into. To consider our pre-Islamic culture as dead as ever. Good
for monumental memorials. Nothing alive to be proud of. This is how kings and mullahs
have always tried to associate themselves with. MONUMENTS. The late king did it and
now the newly mullahs in power are repeating. Culture needs stimulation not copying
old features that would remind us how great we were and how SMALL WE ARE NOW.
Sorry to disappoint you but I was so disappointed when I saw this horrible almost
Arabic interpretation of my past glories that couldn't stop myself writing this
Regards,
Homayoun
* Cultivate your love
Dear Abjeez, [I'm
not in love with him]
I'm a swedish man in my fifties and I've experienced the same situation as you
are now. It could be interesting to have a comment from the "other" side.
I met a divorced woman in Tehran and we was feeling the same things as you are. The
difference is that she was and are very much in love with me.
Believe me, I absolutely did not think of her as beeing cheap. She was and are so
dear to me. It's such a divine feeling, two persons from different ends of the world
with very different culture - and religion - melting togehter as a perfect chemical
reaction.
Go ahead, cultivate your love and respective experiances. If you both are careful
and open to each other, you can build a wonderful life together.
Love,
Olsson
To top
* Lezat bordam
Jenab e Javid e aziz, [Real,
fantastic]
az didane akshaaye zibaaye gerefte shomaa, bekhosos az tarighe chaape aanhaa,
lezat bordam.
movafagh baashid.
Bardia Haddadi
[Living color]
To top
* Horrible
These are horrible pictures [Real,
fantastic]. You'd better follow some photography course.
D. Danish
To top
* Kolli honarmandin
Good job [Real,
fantastic]. baba kolli honarmandin shoma :)
Keep up the good work
D Fghafari
To top
* Captured the spirit
Cousin joon, [Real,
fantastic]
I enjoyed the photo essay very much. First, I felt like I was there. Second, you
are so artistic! The variety of ways in which you had edited the photos was very
impressive. From Van Gogh to Monet to Andy Warhol, you had it all represented! You
really have a very artistic eye, and of course we know where you get it from. It
runs in the family....
You captured the spirit of the day and then added another dimension to it. Amazing,
I didn't even know you could do that with photos. Shows you what I know... But why
so many photos of food? Were you hungry that day? Just kidding, the essence of persian
culture is all about the food and the socialization that surrounds food.
Good job! Thanks for sharing it with us. Reminded me its about time to re-subscribe!
Ghorbanat. Say hi to Mahdiyeh (she looks fantastic, so lovely and so in shape - mashallah)
and please give an extra special hi to your Mom.
Love,
Mani
To top
* Legally changing my name
Having tried living in Iran after my graduation in the west, and not too happy
with the Shah's regime, I immigrated to the US and obtained US citizenship in mid
70s. However, I did not change my Iranian name on my citizenship application [Call me].
My thought was: when the Shah's regime eventually topples, Iran may become a better
place to live, and I may want to return to live there. So, I maintained my Iranian
name, a long and difficult one to pronounce in the West.
When Khomeini and his IRI gang came to power and Iran was thrown back into the stone
ages, I decided that my Iranian name was no longer going to be of any use to me.
in fact, it became a liability at my aerospace work, and cumbersome when making dinner
reservations. Since I did not foresee Iran ever becoming a place for me to live during
the rest of my life, I decided to legally change my first and last name.
In March 1980, when I appeared in the US court for legal name change, there was another
Iranian guy (obviously not highly educated) who was also changing his Iranian name
to a western name. I asked him what was he changing his name to. He responded "Drian
Smith". I said "you mean Brian Smith". He said " No. Drian Smith".
I told him I had never heard of a first name being "Drian". He responded
"Ah. You see, if I put a fullstop between Dr and Ian, people will see my name
as Dr. Ian Smith". There, he instantly became a Doctor with a mere name change
!!
I thought to myself 'Wow. Here we go. Another example of my fellow Iranians thinking
they were so clever (kheili zerang?)".
Sean Amour
To top
* NIYAZ shenidan an ra dashtam
Salam, Merci,az tabrike eydetan,[Heechkas
tanhaa neest] har chand ke kheyli az eyd gozashte,va ermouz 11 april ast
vali in ghadr in tabrik eyd be dele man neshast ke hamin tor ashkam dare miyad va
man be khodam migam,an rouzi ke man kenar panjere dashtam be biroun negah mikardam
va be Iran,be mardom,be khanevadam,ke madaram dare alan baghlava dorost mikone va
atresh hame khane ra bar dashte,be pedaram ke har rouz yk noyi Ajil mikhare,be Madar
bozorgham ke noghre hara dare az dasmal dar miyare,be ghol foushiya,be mardom tou
kheyaban ,be bouye mahi,be bou,be bouye eyd ke hame faza ra gherefte fekr mikardam,va
an rouzi ke man mesle alan gherye mikardam va ba khodam migoftam ke doustam va hame
anha ke man be anha ashegh boudam va hastam,aya lahzeyi be man fekr mikonand,ke man
in ja dar otagham cheghadr TANHAM,va cheghadr delam mikhast in jomle ra beshnavam,"
hame ba ham hastim" ! hata be dorough man ba tamam vojoud NIYAZ shenidan an
ra dashtam,pas kheyli mamnoun.
Mitra
To top
* He didn't say it
Hello,
No. He didn't say it [He
really said it: Jesus]. That part of the bible is probably written by Saint
Paul (or another disiple). Saint Paul was a later convert to christianism and he
didn't even see Jesus in person. He was a jewish who persecuted the new christians
and one day he saw a vision and converted to christianism. It was him who denied
the importance of respecting the jewish law and invited the Grece and the Romans
to chritianism. The only parts of the new testament which involves Jesus himself
are the 4 gospels which are written by 4 of the apostles and relate his life and
what he had said. Even from the text itself it is clear that it's not Jesus who is
talking. (The writer talsk about being Christian and believing in the Christ).
Sincerely,
Mohammed Reza Pakzad
PS. Bible is in two sections. Old and new testaments. What we call Torah is only
the first 5 books of the old testaments. Zabour of Davoud is the Psalms which is
another part. There are many other books in the old testament. The new testament
contains the 4 Gospels, the letters of apostles to christians and other nations,
and other parts as the Apocalypse which is the last book in the Bible and relates
a strange vision of Saint John about the end of the times. Usually there is this
confusion among the people of Islamic culture who think that the Bible is a book
similar to Qoran in its composition and origin.
To top
* Send me magazines
I am a student in the field of art at the University of
Tehran in Iran.
I have an international library in Shiraz with cooperative
ties with international magazines. To complete my list of publications and also promote
your magazines, may I ask if you could send me some of your magazines if possible?
Please accept me as one of your magazine's members. I am
interested in your publications.
I am looking forward to hearing from you soon.
Respectfully yours,
Mr. Amir Khojandi
Director Library
To top
* Good and Evil
This view on Good and Evil is from the records of Heaven
17. Zarathustra inquired of I'hua'Mazda, saying: Is evil, evil; is good, good? I'hua'Mazda
said: Evil is evil to man, but evil is not evil to Ormazd. Good is good to man; but
good is not good to Ormazd. Only two conditions are before Ormazd; not evil, nor
good; but ripe and unripe. To Ormazd, that which man calleth evil is unripe; to Ormazd,
that which man calleth good is ripe.
18. I'hua'Mazda went on explaining, saying: For sake of understanding, O Zarathustra;
for sake of not confounding, thou shalt call evil, evil; and good, good. Hear me,
then, my son:
19. Without green fruit, none could be ripe; without evil none could be good. So
Ormazd created all creation, and called it good; but lo, and behold, there was nothing
to do. All things moved not; as if dead, all things were as nothing.
20. Then Ormazd blew His breath outward, and every created thing went into motion.
And those at the front were called All Good, and those at the rear were called all
evil. Thus created the Creator the Good Creation and the Evil Creation; the I'hua'Mazda
and the Anra'mainyus.
Chapter X
Pete
To top
* What does Ahvaz mean?
I happened upon your site and I am very interested in Iran
and the names of its cities and landmarks. I know your site is not for such things
but was hoping you could take a moment to translate for me. The city of Ahvaz
on the Karun River ...what does the name "Ahwaz" mean? I think
it means breath or wind but not sure... also what does Karun translate to in English?
Thank you very much.
K Hoeck
To top
* A father knows these things
When I was asked for a Mahrieh (dowry), it was more than I had, and when it is
more than you have, it might as well be a "carriage of gold". So I emptied
my pockets of my last Centime, promised all of my worldly posessions and everything
I would ever own, and prayed to god that it it might be enough.
There was never a question in my heart or mind that I would be willing to make
any sacrifice to protect and respect her. I love her with every breath I take and
her laughter is the most beautiful sound I have ever known. I feel blessed with her,
it is that simple.
I am a father and am also blessed with a daughter, so smart, skillful, wise, endearing,clever,
kind and beautiful, she could win your heart with glance. But sooner a pauper with
good character and a true heart could win her hand, than a fool with a carriage of
gold.
If you knew in your soul that no sacrifice was too great to make for Mahtaab's hand
and that you would feel that way forever, then her mother would not be a problem
and you would be the richest man on earth. A father knows these things.
Perhaps it is time to search your soul?
Husain
To top
* Worst memories in Iran
I am Mahdi and I am leaving in USA.I was in so many counties. I have been a long
time in Baku doing my schooling, I have been in russia, Turkey, I was born in Iraq
& ... . But Let's say I grew up in Iran. I spent the most important of my lifetime
(my teenaging) in Iran.
I saw a lot of other people in other countries but I exprienced the my worst memories
in Iran. Please Iranian poeple don't suffer Afghan Refugees in Iran. They are tired,
damaged, suffered and ... Believe me if they had a little peaceful territory in their
country they would never come to Iran.
Mahdi
To top
|