In defense of free speech

Iranian bloggers' letter in response to Hossein Derakhshan's detention

Share/Save/Bookmark

In defense of free speech
by Jahanshah Javid
18-Dec-2008
 

We, the undersigned, view the circumstances surrounding the Iranian authorities' arrest of Hossein Derakhshan (hoder.com), one of the most prominent Iranian bloggers, as extremely worrying.  Derakhshan's disappearance, detention at an unknown location, lack of access to his family and attorneys, and the authorities' failure to provide clear information about his potential charges is a source of concern for us.

The Iranian blogging community is one of the largest and most vibrant in the world.  From ordinary citizens to the President, a diverse and large number of Iranians are engaged in blogging. These bloggers encompass a wide spectrum of views and perspectives, and they play a vital role in open discussions of social, cultural and political affairs.

Unfortunately, in recent years, numerous websites and blogs have been routinely blocked by the authorities, and some bloggers have been harassed or detained.  Derakhshan's detention is but the latest episode in this ongoing saga and is being viewed as an attempt to silence and intimidate the blogging community as a whole.

Derakhshan's own position regarding a number of prisoners of conscience in Iran has been a source of contention among the blogging community and has caused many to distance themselves from him.  This, however, doesn't change the fact that the freedom of expression is sacred for all not just the ones with whom we agree.

We therefore categorically condemn the circumstances surrounding Derakhshan's arrest and detention and demand his immediate release.

ما امضا کنندگان ذیل، شرایط  دستگیری حسین درخشان، یکی از سرشناس ترین بلاگرهای ایرانی، توسط مقامات ایران را به شدت نگران کننده می دانیم.  ناپدید شدن، حبس در مکانی مجهول، عدم دسترسی به اعضای خانواده و وکلای مدافع، و اعلام نکردن اطلاعات شفاف در خصوص موارد اتهام احتمالی نامبرده همگی باعث نگرانی ما ست.

جامعه وبلاگ نویسان ایران یکی از فعال ترین و بزرگترین جوامع اینترنتی جهان است.  از شهروندان معمولی تا رییس جمهور ایران،  بسیاری به امر نوشتن در وبلاگهای مختلف مشغول اند.  این وبلاگ نویسان دارای طیف وسیعی از عقاید و آرا هستند و نقش مهمی در مباحث اجتماعی، فرهنگی، و سیاسی ایفا می کنند.

متاسفانه ظرف سالهای اخیر، وبسایت ها و وبلاگهای متعددی به صورت منظم توسط مقامات ایران فیلتر شده و شماری از وبلاگ نویسان با آزار و حبس روبرو شده اند.  بازداشت حسین درخشان تنها آخرین نمونه از این نوع برخوردها ست و به نظر می آید این اقدام در راستای ایجاد رعب و واداشتن وبلاگ نویسان به سکوت طراحی شده است.

مواضع حسین درخشان در خصوص تعدادی از کسانی که بدلیل عقایدشان زندانی شده اند باعث رنجش جامعه وبلاگ نویسان ایرانی بوده و همین موجب شده بسیاری از آنان از وی دوری بجویند.  با اینهمه، این موضوع این حقیقت را نفی نمی کند که آزادی بیان حقی مقدس است و باید برای همه در نظر گرفته شود، نه فقط کسانی که با آنها موافقیم.

بنابرین، ما از این منظر، به طور اصولی شرایط دستگیری و بازداشت حسین درخشان را محکوم می کنیم و خواهان آزادی فوری او هستیم.

Arash Abadpour
//kamangir.net/

Mohammad Afrasiabi
//amoo-arvand.blogspot.com/

Nazanin Afshin-Jam
//www.nazanin.ca/

Niki Akhavan
//benevis-dige.blogspot.com/

Pouya Alagheband
//fromvan.persianblog.ir/

Asdollah Alimohammadi
//www.mebaily.com/

Youness Alvandi
//www.younessa.com/

Anahita Aloocheh Khanoom
//aloochehkhanoom.blogspot.com/

Mehrdad Aref-Adib
//www.aref-adib.com

Bahare
//2khtarekhorshid.com/

Hossein Bagher Zadeh
//iranian.com/main/blog/hossein-bagher-zadeh

Bahram
//letrepersan.wordpress.com/

Banadfsheh
//banafsheh192.blogfa.com/

Qumars Bolourchian
//iranian.com/main/blog/q

Taha Bazri
//www.bazri.com/

Mani Behrouz
//mpahlavi.blogspot.com/

Behdad Borbdar
//parakandeham.blogspot.com/

Deserter
//deserter.wordpress.com/

Sanam Dolatshahi
//www.khorshidkhanoom.com/

The flying dutchman
//silisia1983.blogfa.com/

Mohammad Ali Entezari
//kallesangi.blogspot.com/

David Etebari
//peyvast.blog.com/

Fereshteh Ghazi
//www.fereshteh.blogfa.com/

Hossein Ghazian
//www.daal.ir/

Armin Gilehmard
//gilehmard.blogspot.com/

Farhad Heyrani
//farhadheyrani.blogspot.com/

Bamdad Irani
//bamdadi.com/

IranWrites
//iranian.com/main/blog/iranwrites

Sadegh Jam
//blognevesht.com/

Mehdi Jami
//sibestaan.malakut.org/

Jahanshah Javid
//iranian.com/main/blog/jahanshah-javid

Navid K
//www.livebee.wordpress.com/

Sadegh Kabeer
//www.eterazonline.com/

Sohrab Kabuli
//www.kabuli.org/

Darius Kadivar
//iranian.com/main/blog/darius-kadivar

Abdee Kalantari
//www.nilgoon.org

Sheema Kalbasi
//www.zaneirani.blogspot.com/

Mohammad Ali Kallesangi
//kallesangi.blogspot.com/

Nazli Kamvari
//sibiltala.blogspot.com/

Nazy Kaviani
//nazykaviani.blogspot.com/

Haji Kensington
//www.mibibi.com/

Yaser Kerachian
//vahid.blogspot.com

Naz Khatoun
//www.nazkhatoun.com/

Mani Khorsandi
//gapvgoft.blogspot.com/

Peyvand Khorsandi
//soulbean.wordpress.com/

Foaad Khosmood
//iranian.com/main/blog/foaad-khosmood

Nikahang Kowsar
//nikahang.blogspot.com/

Mardetanha
//mardetanha.blogspot.com/

Marjaneh
//marjaneh.blogsky.com/

Abbas Maroufi
//maroufi.malakut.org/

Mehran Mehrafshan
//xseer.com/

Omid Memarian
//omidmemarian.blogspot.com/

Seraj Mirdamadi
//www.roozneveshtha.com/

Pedram Moallemian
//www.eyeranian.net/

Ali Moayedian
//payvand.com/

Farhad Mortaz
//www.fmortaz.blogspot.com

Mostafa
//cafenaderi.wordpress.com/

Motevalled
//www.motevalled.blogspot.com/

Ebrahim Nabavi
//www.doomdam.com/

Babak Nabizadeh
//cloudy.blogsky.com/

Hadi Naseri
//hadinaseri.blogfa.com/

Masoome Naseri
//www.mimnoon.com/

Niloofar
//www.sunisblind.blogspot.com/

Partow Nooriala
//noorialapartow.blogfa.com/

Kaveh Nouraee
//iranian.com/main/blog/kaveh-nouraee

Zainolabedin Nourani
//nourani.blogfa.com/

Niloufar Parsi
//iranian.com/main/blog/niloufar-parsi

Shahrnush Parsipur
//www.shahrnushparsipur.com/

Farhad Radmehrian
//iranian.com/main/blog/farrad02

Ahmad Rafat
//rafat.malakut.org/

Fati Raja
//www.fatiraja.blogspot.com

Shadi Ramez
//measer-pear.blogspot.com/

Paris Rezaie
//www.excounty.blogspot.com

Khodadad Rezakhani
//www.vishistorica.com/

Arash Royayee
//www.dreamlandblog.com/

Farnaz Seifi
//farnaaz.org/

Cyrus Shahidi
//andishehblog.wordpress.com/

Sahand Shams
//www.sahandshams.blogspot.com/

Ari Siletz
//arisiletz.com/

Zan Zamini
//zamin4.blogfa.com/

Leva Zand
//balootak.com/

Zeitoon
//z8un.com/

Sameddin Ziaee
//sameddin-ziaee.blogspot.com/

Majid Zohari
//www.majidzohari.com/

[If you are a blogger and wish to add your name to this list, leave a comment below]

Share/Save/Bookmark

Recently by Jahanshah JavidCommentsDate
Hooman Samani: The Kissinger
4
Aug 31, 2012
Eric Bakhtiari: San Francisco 49er
6
Aug 26, 2012
You can help
16
Aug 23, 2012
more from Jahanshah Javid
 
default

Just in defense of free

by Atoosa (not verified) on

Just in defense of free speech


default

I sign it.

by Majid Zohari (not verified) on

Majid Zohari - Toronto, Canada.


default

Please add my blog as well

by Bamdad Irani (not verified) on

Dear Jahanshah, please add my blog to the list,
I personally would have preferred a better presented letter, something more clear and to the point not filled with general comments about freedom of speech without any specific receiver.

However I admire the effort and I do support it, now it is no time to talk about the details and I can obviously see the meaning and intention of your move, therefore I support it.


default

I support it too.

by Yaser Kerachian (not verified) on

//vahid.blogspot.com

Yaser Kerachian


default

in defence of free speech

by mohammad mohseni (not verified) on

Free Hoder plz


default

please add my blog and name to the list.

by Cyrus Shahidi (not verified) on

//andishehblog.wordpress.com/

cyrus shahidi

Switzerland, Geneve.


default

let him write

by AliR (not verified) on

I'm used to following up on his weblog and it's sad that he doesn't write anymore.
I never figured out how he didn't evolve to anything similar to a journalist/writer. His short paragraphs gave me some kind of perspective tho.
let's have him free and writing.


Souri

You are right

by Souri on

It is not abut Derakhshan. It is about our priorities and responsibilities. As I said, in a general scale, we all do support him and we want his immediate release from detention, but in a more specific theme, the image of this is :

Someone says I will walk trough the fire and you will see that nothing will happen to me and I will be just fine !!

Of course when he gets in the fire, we will do all we can to get him out, but still I feel a kind of frusration when I compare him with the innocent people who get themselves in the same situation without their own pre-meditated action, the ones who are the real defender of the human rights and freedom.

Otherwise, I always support freedom of speech, and you know that.


default

add me too

by hadi naseri (not verified) on

please add my sign. i published the letter in my blog. thx.


Kaveh Nouraee

Jahanshah

by Kaveh Nouraee on

Kindly add my name to the petition. Thank you.


samz1345

Iranian bloggers' letter

by samz1345 on

Whatever Derakhshan believes or has done that I'm not agree with them,but in the name of free speech,add my name too plz:  Sameddin Ziaee

//sameddin-ziaee.blogspot.com


Jahanshah Javid

Derakhshan

by Jahanshah Javid on

Thanks Souri. It's no secret that many have strong disagreements with Derakhshan. But whatever he has done or believes does not warrant his detention and denial of civil and human rights. This is not an argument about Derakhshan, but about respecting free speech for all -- including those we disagree with.


Souri

Denial or provocative ?

by Souri on

Dear Jahanshah,

I appreciate your effort for the cause of freedom for everyone, especially for the journalist and bloggers.

I value this petition as a great proof of standing for the freedom of speech from all Iranian in diaspora: bloggers, journalists, ordinary people.

I support the petition and hope Hoder will soon be released. We always condemned the arrest, sanction or intimidation of all Iranian, and all the journalist who speak for freedom, in particular.

Despite all the good intention and heartfelt hope for Hoder's release from prison, I have still one question:

How can I describe his action ?

Hoder's political views were always clearly stated in his blogs. Most of us, don't agree with him, but this does not imply that we do agree with his arrest. But I would like to understand the logic or motivation behind his action. He always stated his opinion in regard to the government of Iran, the way the IRI does not perform accordingly to the democratic values and international human right's protocol. Hoder also stated his position in regard to Israel and the way the IRI is treating Israel in the international scale.

I am wondering then, how and why would this happen that a journalist/blogger with this state of belief and with this precedent and background, would decide to go back to Iran, right after traveling to Israel, which is considered as an enemy for the IRI?

Hoder is an intellecutal (at least he proclaim himself to be one) and he knows exactly the situation and the undemocratic laws in Iran. He knows that no Iranian have the right to travel to Israel without the permission and providing a valid reason for this trip.

Not so long ago (almost 25 years ago) if as an Iranian, you were unfortunate to choose to travel from Europe to Iran by Aeroflot (the soviet  travel company) you would have lots of Q & A at your entrence in US and most of other western countries.

I am just wondering, how was Hoder looking to this act of himself, a heroic action or a provocative one  ? Is he looking for the same  celebrity and popularity as Ganji ? or is he really in a state of denial as to how the Iranian government of today is functioning ?

a link from Hoder's website :

//hoderiniran.com/1387/07/104

With all due respect,


default

Free Hoder

by Mohammad Eslami (not verified) on

"the freedom of expression is sacred for all not just the ones with whom we agree."
Couldn't agree more.
Thanks JJ.


default

Please add my name too

by Mahmoud Azimaee (not verified) on

I would like to support this too.

Thanks


default

Finally an authentic petition

by Therer is hope (not verified) on

The signatories are real and they are such great people, and the petition in genuine. Even if one does not agree with Derakhshan’s views one can still agree that he is entitled to express them. He went to Israel against the wishing of the ruling class, but so what? His reasons for doing it are all the open in his blogs.

Sorry I couldn't put my given name up there, but I support you in the spirit of it.


default

In defence of free speech

by soroush (not verified) on

No one has the right to limit another's freedom of speech. We are all endowed with a brain and have the right to use it and to express our opinion in all matters as we see them.
www.Soroushphotocreations.com


default

I support it too

by QIL (not verified) on

Free Hoder!


ahvazi

Thank you JJ

by ahvazi on

For taking this action. Despite the unfortunate and venomous words of Hossein against his hamvatans, I believe he should be freed and enjoy the same freedoms that many in Iran are striving everyday to achieve.

 


Niki

Thanks Jahanshah

by Niki on

I think you deserve a lot of credit on this. Few other people would be able to draw such a diverse group of signers on one petition. Thanks again for your efforts on this, and I hope that hossein is released safe and sound in the very near future.


default

Free Him

by Nima Akbarpour (not verified) on

I support this too


default

Support

by MehranM (not verified) on

Mehran Mehrafshan
//xseer.com/


default

To the government in Iran:

by B. (not verified) on

respect the freedom of speech and free all of our thinkers and activist who are detained in your prisons. And respect the freedom of discussion among Iranian inside of Iran.

After three decades and in the 21st century it is a shame that a paranoid government is still active and silences writers, bloggers and students.

ONE OF THESE DAYS WE WILL GET YOU ALL !!!!!


default

Free Hoder immediately

by farrad02 on

I also hope they let him go immediately!


Aref-Adib

In defense of free speech

by Aref-Adib on

I also demand his immediate release.

www.aref-adib.com


Princess

Anonymous support!

by Princess on

I would like to support this as well, but am neither a blogger, nor would l like to lose my anonymity on this site. So I guess I will just have to support you in spirit in this forum.


Darius Kadivar

Please add my name to this letter

by Darius Kadivar on

Wishing his prompt liberation also.

//iranian.com/main/blog/darius-kadivar

Thanks


Foaad Khosmood

I support it

by Foaad Khosmood on

I hope they let him go soon.