Benazir’s Foolish Death

Balatarin
Share/Save/Bookmark

Darius Kadivar
by Darius Kadivar
28-Dec-2007
 

I learned the news of Benazir Bhutto’s death as something of a Déjà Vue. I was shocked but not as surprised as I read through the various news sources on the assassination of one of Pakistan’s iconic figures whose family like the Kennedy’s in the US or the Gandhi’s in India will be for ever associated to some kind of eternal morbid malediction.  The death of Benazir Bhutto is not an April Fool’s day Joke but truly looks in many ways like that of a bad and predictable movie script :

An extremely beautiful and cultured Woman educated at Oxford and Harvard whose features were fit for modeling or a movie career but who decided instead to enter politics at an early age and ultimately to revenge his father’s memory ( The late President Zulfikar Ali Bhutto hanged in April 1979) by taking on politics and succeeding to high office twice thus entering history as one of the rare if not only true female leaders in the Muslim World. Her controversial and arranged marriage to a rich husband belonging to a powerful clan was also to make headlines suggesting that she was hungry for power rather than love or personal happiness. Accusations of corruption, true or false were also associated to her rise to power, but her rising popularity over the years in her homeland could not be boiled down to incompetence and slandering. In retrospect her highly profiled and dignified personality added to her physical courage and stamina should make many Nobel Peace Prize contenders and or awardees blush today. Killed in the most cowardly manner ( shot in the neck) her death will overshadow that of the 20 other lives that were taken away in the name of the Holy Koran by a suicide bomber.

What we get and will get in the weeks to come will be a series of predictable titles in the lines of:

Benazir Bhutto killed in attack

Bhutto's last rally 

Bhutto funeral held in Pakistan


There you have it: Three Lines to sum up a Life Time ...

As an outsider and impotent observer of Pakistan’s internal politics and the so-called yet very Real War on Terror, I cannot be indifferent to the news of her death. Yet the chilling news of her sudden and savage death leads me more to frustration and anger than any signs of grief. Maybe I would have reacted differently if she were a family member or if I was a Pakistani. What is certain is that I cannot set aside the idea that her death was so predictable and somehow makes me wonder if she did not ride towards her own death as a Bergmanian hero in The Seventh Seal. 

According to news experts It was the second suicide attack against her in recent months and came amid a wave of bombings targeting security and government officials. “Third Time Lucky” so goes the saying but yesterday’s cowardly assassination proved that wrong for Mrs. Bhutto’s political career and bid for Pakistan’s highest office for a third time.


Left with the sad reality of her tragic end, I cannot but feel angry at Mrs. Bhutto herself. Certainly I am extremely unjust towards all those who cherish her memory and particularly her family and loved ones. However one can wonder if death even in the course of one’s political struggle achieves anything over time ? Who except a few dusty history books will record in time and collective consciousness the death of John F. Kennedy and his brother Robert or that of the late President’s son John-John killed in a stupid Plane Crash. What does the death of Martin Luther King represent to the young generation of American’s today who seem more preoccupied by the whereabouts of Paris Hilton or the rehabs of Amy Whinehouse than the massacre of their fellow classmates and teachers on a Virginia Campus ? What did the death of Lady Diana and Dodi El Fayed provoked by French Paparazzi’s achieve except nurturing further tasteless conspiracy theories over time ? What did the assassination of Shapour Bakhtiar and his secretary achieve other than prolonging the life of the Islamic Republic of Iran and its soccer Team’s victories at the World Cup ?
 

Do death’s such as that of Benazir Bhutto achieve any goal at all ? Do or should theyy serve as "Symbols" of what we could have achieved or rather what we have definitively lost for good ?  I have no definitive answer to these questions except the bitter feeling that such tragic events will continue to the end of time as a reminder that humanity never, NEVER LEARNS. 

Adieu Benazir Bhutto, May You rest in Peace with Your Father. 

And If This Word Means Anything Today : Inch Allah ! … 

Darius KADIVAR
Balatarin
Share/Save/Bookmark

Recently by Darius KadivarCommentsDate
TOMBSTONE: Bidding Goodbye to Iranian.com (ers)
4
Dec 05, 2012
ROYAL PREGNANCY: Prince William, Duchess of Cambridge Announce Pregnancy
3
Dec 04, 2012
DESPERATE HOUSEWIVES: Golshifteh Farahani & Sienna Miller in Road Movie ‘Just Like a Woman »
-
Dec 03, 2012
more from Darius Kadivar
 
default

Not clear

by Saeed Kafili (not verified) on Fri Dec 28, 2007 12:50 PM PST

1)"The father was executed on charges of corruption", says dariushabadi. Is that what they really do? Mmmmm,...I wonder how many people would be executed if that was the law over there.

2)"I see recently on Iranian.com is support for anything that America supports, even if that is more corrupt than what is already there."
I didn't understand this sentence at all. Did anyone?

I am not knit-picking on dariushabadi. I am just genuinely interested in understanding what he says.


  •  
dariushabadi

Unfortunate for you

by dariushabadi on Fri Dec 28, 2007 12:02 PM PST

Unfortunate for you, I condemn both the corruption of Rafsanjani as well as the two Bhuttos.

 

You seem to support the Bhuttos while at the same stroke bashing Rafsanjani (which by many standards is way more of a democrat than Bhutto could ever dream of, which says a lot)

 

I wish for the day you guys have the gutts to condemn people like Bhutto for their corruption, rather than create an illusion for yourselves of a reality that does not exist. You justified your own position by asserting that I somehow support Rafsanjani, but if that was true, then why did I put Rafsanjani in the same line as Bhutto and condemn them both? Yet you condemn one and not the other.

 

I await your response Kadivar. I want to see you condemn the corruption, nepotism and tyrrany that plagued Pakistan during both Bhutto's reigns. We condemn our nepotists, we condemn our corrupt officials, we struggle against those who in the name of religion are abusing the people (yes, i'm speaking of certain Mullahs, Jamshid). But all I see recently on Iranian.com is support for anything that America supports, even if that is more corrupt than what is already there.


  •  
Darius Kadivar

Coming from an IRI apologist like you ...

by Darius Kadivar on Fri Dec 28, 2007 11:32 AM PST

Thanks I may consider Rafsanjani but I think I need not since you will be voting for him or another of those so-called IRI reformists who own half the country and send their assets to Swiss Banks.

I would love to know how you evaluate corruption and crimes in your book ? 

//iranian.com/abadi.html


  •  
dariushabadi

rest in peace?

by dariushabadi on Fri Dec 28, 2007 11:09 AM PST

Again, I find all the monarchists quick to defend two of the most brutal and corrupt individuals in Pakistan's history.

 

The reign of both Zulfaqar Ali Bhutto and his daughter Benazir Bhutto were one of the most corrupt periods of Pakistan's history. The father was executed on charges of corruption, and the daughter was sent to exile after she was found to be little different from her father. She only returned to Pakistan after Musharaf agreed to UNFREEZE her assets.

 

But apparently you all believe in the western hype that she was some beacon of democracy, some martyr for the cause of freedom. What a joke, she was Prime Minister of Pakistan in 1983, and proved she is neither.

 

Why do you guys always support the most corrupt individuals? I'm surprised you don't pray toward Rafsanjani with such a mentality.


  •  
« first‹ previous12