MASADA: Will The Battle For Aleppo Decide The Fate Of Assad ?


MASADA: Will The Battle For Aleppo Decide The Fate Of Assad ?
by Darius Kadivar

While the deemed « civilized » world will be treated at the Olympic Games with it’s share of « bread and circus », I cannot help but think of another far more dramatic spectacle in the making. The Syrian rebels under siege in the city of Aleppo known for it’s ancient archeological sites already heavily bombarded by the troops of Syrian President Assad are about to face their most Deadly challenge yet. (Source:

As  the siege of Aleppo continues, already dubbed by both sides as « the mother of all battles », I am sadly reminded of all the tragic and desperate acts of resistance against all odds and one in particular that of Masada (72 B.C.) in a region which has witnessed so many others in it’s long history.

Although the brave Syrian rebels are far from suicidal, their desperate situation as a poorly equipped rebellious lot facing a brutally professional killing machine led by Bachar Assad’s henchmen (including his own brother) will definitively be remembered as a tragic bloody milestone in this already year long confict.

As BBC War Correspondent Ian Pannel describes it : « It is almost inconceivable that President Assad could allow his government to lose control of the city, so it is reasonable to expect that they are going to throw everything they possibly can at the city.

And that is what they are preparing for here. One of the neighbourhoods is appealing for more blood supplies. We are hearing reports of hundreds, possibly thousands of families leaving some districts. Everybody is bracing themselves for an intensive campaign.

The way it has worked in other cities is that there is an intensive bombardment by artillery and mortars, and then when it starts to go calm, tanks begin to roll in. This is a very congested heavily populated area, so it will be bloody. » (Seerelated News).



Battle for Aleppo 'crucial' for Syria's future (Daily Telegraph, Jul 23, 2012):

Speaking from a village on the outskirts of Aleppo in Syria, the Telegraph's 
Foreign Affairs Correspondent says that the rebels "think they have 
nothing to lose" in the battle for the city.

Crac des Chevaliers holds out against Assad troops (AFP, Jul 4, 2012):

The Crac des Chevaliers, Syria's best preserved castle from the Crusades of the Middle Ages, is once again providing shelter for armed forces. The Free Syria Army have been holed up in and around the hilltop the fortress for over a year as they resist the advance of forces loyal the President Assad. An exclusive AFPTV report.

(NOTE : To Watch Double Click Here)  





The Mother of All Battles ?



The siege of Masada was among the final accords of the First Jewish-Roman War. The long siege by the troops of theRoman Empire led to the mass suicide of the Sicarii rebels and resident Jewish families of the Masada fortress. The siege has become a controversial event in Jewish history, marking radicalism on the one hand and heroic struggle on the other. (More Here)

The Siege of Massada:


Documentary revists the myth of Massada in the light of new archeological discoveries


Peter O'Toole and Peter Strauss star in the Emmy Award-winning mini-series about the Romans' siege of the Jewish fortress at Masada. 

In first century A.D., Flavius Silva (Peter O'Toole), commander in Roman Palestine, leads his forces in combat against the remaining Jewish Zealots who have taken refuge in the seemingly impregnable fortress of Masada. There, the engineering and military might of Rome faces the passion and ingenuity of Eleazar Ben Yair (Peter Strauss) and his people. 

Based on the novel "The Antagonists" by Ernest K. Gann, this 4-part mini-series was shot on location in Israel.


Retribution :


Masada "The Leaders Meet" :

Generals Meet before Assault :


Recommended Readings:

Conflict threatens Syria's archaeological heritage (France 24)

With its ancient fortresses, castles, mosques and markets, Syria bears the imprint of millennia of Middle Eastern history. But the current uprising is threatening some of the world’s most valuable heritage sites.


Profile of the City of Aleppo (bbc)

The Old Quarter of Aleppo is listed by Unesco as a World Heritage site. Its population of two million is made up mainly of Sunni Muslims, most of whom are Arabs but some of whom are Kurds. It also has the largest population of Christians in the country, and along with a mix of other religious and ethnic communities, the city's demographics largely mirror those of the country as a whole.

As one of the oldest continually inhabited cities in the world - along with the capital, Damascus - and coloured with the stories of the many ancient travellers and merchants who passed through on their journeys along the famous Silk Road, Aleppo's beauty is hard to compare.

The medieval citadel and covered souk are two of its famous landmarks - both listed by Unesco as world heritage sites, which said it mirrored the rich and diverse cultures of its successive occupants.

Related Photo Essay:


In pictures : the Battle of Aleppo (bbc)


Related Blogs:

NIGHT OF THE GENERALS : Paul Conroy describes "pure, systematic slaughter of civilians"

MORAL DILEMMA? Obama & Cameron suggest “peaceful” transition in Syria instead of revolution

WANTED: Did Nazi Criminal Alois Brunner train Syria’s Security Forces ?

Other related blogs :

NO SCHINDLER: Shimon Peres say’s ‘Israel will stop’ Syrian refugees at border

SCHINDLER's LIST : In Tribute to the Abandoned Children of Syria

Syrian Protestors Burn IRI Flag

NIAC Ambassador Majid Rafizadeh: Appeasement with Iran But Sanctions & intervention on Syria?

IN DENIAL: Barbara Walters' Interview with Syria's President Bashar al-Assad


more from Darius Kadivar
Darius Kadivar

Rebels and Assad’s forces face-off in Zabadani

by Darius Kadivar on

Rebels and Assad’s forces face-off in Zabadani (france 24)


A special video report from our correspondent in the village of Zabadani, which has seen fierce fighting between President Bashar al-Assad’s forces and the rebel Free Syrian Army.




Darius Kadivar

After Assad falls, could Syria worsen?

by Darius Kadivar on

After Assad falls, could Syria worsen? (cnn)


  • Michael Hayden: The endgame is approaching for the Syrian regime
  • He says bombing of a security meeting killed Assef Shawkat, a key member of regime
  • Bashar al-Assad lacks his father's skill or political sense, Hayden says
  • He says U.S. should back opposition elements but regime could be replaced by civil war


Darius Kadivar

Libya rebels move onto Syrian battlefield

by Darius Kadivar on

Libya rebels move onto Syrian battlefield (cnn)


Tripoli, Libya (CNN) -- Their war for freedom in Libya may be over, but almost a year after they won the battle for the Libyan capital, a group of fighters have a new battlefield: Syria.


  • More than 30 men who fought against Libya's regime are moving into Syria
  • One fighter says: Libya was a walk in the park compared to Syria
  • Unlike Libya, in Syria fighters have no base and no cover from a no-fly zone
  • Libya's government and people have been vocal supporters of Syria's opposition




Darius Kadivar

'Nonstop shelling' rocks Aleppo - say's opposition

by Darius Kadivar on

'Nonstop shelling' rocks Aleppo - opposition (cnn)


Parts of Syria's largest city endure the fiercest clashes of the 16-month crisis, the opposition says. The regime is calling the confrontation "the mother of all battles." 


  • NEW: Dozens are killed in Syria on Saturday, opposition groups say
  • NEW: Russia vice admiral says personnel could be removed from Tartus base if it were attacked
  • Syria says regime forces "started to cleanse" a Hama town of terrorists
  • Tensions spill into Lebanon, 12 injured in clashes


Darius Kadivar

Syria’s most prominent defector pledges to help reunite country

by Darius Kadivar on

Syria’s most prominent defector pledges to help reunite country (france 24)


Defected general Manaf Tlass (pictured) told a Saudi newspaper Friday that he could be the man to lead Syria out of the crisis, despite his longstanding ties to the Assad regime. Opposition activists have voiced concerns over eager defectors.

Darius Kadivar

‘Mother of all battles’ as Syrian forces attack Aleppo

by Darius Kadivar on

‘Mother of all battles’ as Syrian forces attack Aleppo (France 24)


Syrian President Bashar al-Assad’s forces launched a counter-offensive on rebel-held areas in city of Aleppo Saturday, with troops backed by tanks moving in to southwestern districts. State media warned that the "mother of all battles" loomed.

Darius Kadivar

Syria's Kurds emboldened

by Darius Kadivar on

Syria's Kurds emboldened (bbc)


By Wyre Davies BBC News


What is happening in Syria cannot be taken in isolation. The protracted upheaval in one of the Middle East's biggest, most powerful and most influential countries is affecting the entire region and, most critically, its immediate neighbours.

Like Iraq, Jordan and Lebanon Turkey has already absorbed - almost without hesitation - thousands of Syrians fleeing the fighting, in particular from the northern cities of Hama and Aleppo.

Turkey is understandably concerned that the number of civilians fleeing across its relatively open southern border will increase as the fighting intensifies in Syria.

Some of those refugees also bring their own political baggage with them and there have already been disturbances in the border camps.

Occasionally ethnic and regional tensions spill over as thousands of displaced Syrians live cheek by jowl in tents under the blisteringly hot summer sum.

But for Turkey, the refugee issue is a mere inconvenience compared to what it thinks will be the biggest fall-out of the Syrian crisis - the Kurds and Kurdistan. 

Darius Kadivar

Ian Pannell in Aleppo: 'Army moves in'

by Darius Kadivar on

Ian Pannell in Aleppo: Army moves in (BBC, VIDEO)


We came into the city last night and since first light, we have been hearing the amplification of artillery bombardment.

There have been gunfights in a number of areas and helicopters flying overhead.

We are hearing that there is a government offensive targeting Salah el-Din, which has been one of the most restive neighbourhoods - perhaps the key district - and which has been in the hands of the opposition Free Syrian Army for a number of days now. 



Darius Kadivar

Syria forces launch Aleppo attack

by Darius Kadivar on

Syria forces launch Aleppo attack (bbc)


Syrian forces attack rebels in Aleppo, activists say, as a BBC journalist there sees rebel fighters wounded and killed.

Darius Kadivar

Beyneh khodemoon Kurda daran Kerm Meereezan

by Darius Kadivar on

Darius Kadivar

Kurdish worries drag Turkey deeper into Syria war

by Darius Kadivar on

Kurdish worries drag Turkey deeper into Syria war - AlertNet



By Peter Apps and Daren Butler

LONDON/ISTANBUL, July 27 (Reuters) - - Turkey may be some way from acting on Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan's threat to strike Kurdish separatists in Syria, but week by week it finds itself sucked ever further into its neighbour's worsening war.

The shooting down of a Turkish reconnaissance jet last month was seen by many as a turning point, prompting Ankara to join Saudi Arabia at Qatar in semi-covert support for the Free Syrian Army fighting against President Bashar al-Assad.

On Friday, Reuters revealed the existence of a secret Turkish operations centre where it worked with the two Gulf states to provide aid and weaponry to the rebels.

For most foreign powers, events in Syria's Kurdish provinces are largely seen a sideshow compared Assad's battle to survive. But Erdogan's comments on Thursday made it clear that Turkey is alarmed by worries over Kurdish PKK rebels taking advantage of the chaos.



Darius Kadivar

Turkey won't tolerate Kurdish entity in Syria

by Darius Kadivar on

Turkey won't tolerate Kurdish entity in Syria - The Denver Post


ANKARA, Turkey—Turkey will not tolerate the creation of a Kurdish-run region in Syria, its prime minister said Thursday following reports that Kurdish rebels and a Syrian Kurdish political party had taken control of five cities along the Syrian-Turkish border.

Recep Tayyip Erdogan's comments underscored Turkey's concern that the creation of a Kurdish authority in the north of Syria could provide a sanctuary to Turkey's own Kurdish separatists, who took up arms against the state in 1984. The Kurdish rebels already use northern Iraq as a springboard for attacks in Turkey.

The prime minister said Turkey's military is closely monitoring the developments. He warned the Kurdistan Workers Party, or PKK, which is fighting for self-rule in Turkey's southeast, and the Democratic Union Party of Syria, known as the PYD, to avoid any attempt at collaboration.

Darius Kadivar

Syrian Kurds Could Tip Scales of Syrian Conflict

by Darius Kadivar on

Syrian Kurds Could Tip Scales of Syrian Conflict


A tent city among the ruins of a former tobacco factory along the Turkish-Syrian border is home to Syrian refugee Ciwan and his four-year-old son. The Yayladagi camp is swarming with Syrians fleeing the bloodshed of their homeland.  But for Ciwan, a Syrian Kurd, it's unfamiliar living among the predominantly Arab population.



Darius Kadivar

The Kurds in Syria: Fueling Separatist Movements in the Region?

by Darius Kadivar on

The Kurds in SyriaFueling Separatist Movements in the Region?


Muslims in general and Muslim leaders particularly have often been severely criticized for not more energetically condemning the violent acts of Muslim extremists. The uninformed often assume that extremists represent Islam’s mainstream. Even those who recognize that extremists are on the margins of the worldwide Muslim community do not understand the degree of pluralism within Islam. Islam comes in many forms and interpretations. Violent extremists are on one edge of the Muslim community, but they are counterbalanced by a growing movement of Muslim peacemakers. The purpose of this report is 1) to explore the extent to which Muslim leaders have spoken out publicly to condemn the violent acts committed by extremists; and 2) to identify growing efforts within Muslim communities to reach out peacefully to other communities and to reinforce the peaceful message of Islam. It is also hoped that reports of these efforts in one part of the world will be instructive for Muslims living elsewhere.


Darius Kadivar

Syria faces growing Aleppo anger

by Darius Kadivar on

Syria faces growing Aleppo anger (bbc)

The international community has stepped up the pressure on the Syrian government to end its assault on the country's biggest city, Aleppo.

Western nations have warned of a potential massacre as military forces press home their attack.

The pro-government al-Watan newspaper warned that the "mother of all battles" was about to start. 

Darius Kadivar

ex-UN observer; Assad's fall 'only a matter of time'

by Darius Kadivar on

Assad's fall 'only a matter of time' (bbc)


The former head of the UN mission in Syria says President Assad's fall is "only a matter of time", as Syrian forces renew an assault on Aleppo.